Joy's Tavern

62 W Main St, Mount Joy
(717) 928-4857

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Todd Lawer

Went on a Monday for their 10.00/dozen wing special. Wings were small but I think that’s normal these days since most places post them as a market price menu item but if these are there normal wings for 15.00/dozen I’d be more disappointed. Other than being small my mild wings were decent, nothing special like most places.
Also ordered for an appetizer a half nachos grande and added beef for an additional 4.75. Tortilla chips piled on a plate with chopped peppers and onions and some half melted shredded cheese with unflavored browned ground beef thrown on top was what I got. No flavor, love or creativity put into them.
My girlfriend ordered the buffalo chicken dip as an appetizer which came with crackers and bread except ours only came with about 8 club crackers and no bread. We had to ask for the bread and that was only a small chunk of dry bread half cut into 4 slices. Dip tasted like some cheap store bought dip. Only after our appetizers came out were we given silverware which was not a big deal but a little backwards from almost any other place I’ve eaten.
We sat on the restaurant side which to me seemed kind of dingy, dirty and depressing. I have seen worse though.
My girlfriend raved about the food there she’s had in the past and even she was disappointed. I have also eaten there before and this time was definitely a different experience. I’m not writing this place off yet but hoping it was just an off night but it doesn’t make me wanna run back or recommend it to anyone right now.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Uncle Al’s Man Cave

Elissa is fantastic at the bar. Food is always delicious and not a long wait.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Rosati

Burgers and service were great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JD Lytle

We used to be regulars here
The food is great
The staff is wonderful but there are too many private parties which absorb the staff
We waited 45 min just to place an order and another 45 min to receive our dinner
We won’t be back
BTW
This happened 3 times in a row

Matt Spence

Lots of fun great staff.

Shane Gleason

Our server was great! He got hit with a lunch rush and handled it with ease. Prices were fair, but the food was just fine. Fries were pretty good and the bacon jam burger special was alright. Wouldn't recommend the crab mac and cheese, though. Seems like a good place for a drink, but I wouldn't go out of my way for the food.

Kim Carson

Order half nachos grande, was very good. Much better than the rare hamburger that I got well done on Memorial Day at night I did pay for the over cooked hamburger that Memorial Day.. I asked for my bill tonight and the Male bartender gave me a bill with someone else drink on it. It was totally different from the Labatt blue that I already paid for from the Female bartender. When I asked him why am I paying for someone else beer, he gets attitude and said he is not only bartender working. Then had smart ass comments. Then he and a person beside me had smart ass comments about Joy needs to do something about the Country music I was playing, it was Aaron Tipen. It has no beet. The last couple of times my burger was over cooked and I paid for it.

Nate OREMLAND

I've gone here for many years, Joy's is a place where the food and drinks are made with love. What brought me back for my second time was just how wonderful and fresh all the veggies were. Since then, Ive tried quite a few options and haven't found a bad one! If you didn't know, you should try the Sunday breakfast. The breakfast pizzas are wonderful!

Vanessa Pastorino

The bartender Dana was friendly. She greeted and sat us. Our server Francheska was kind and attentive! The owner Joy stopped at our table which I thought was cool. Good prices and good food!

Megan Leigh

Elissa is the most miserable bartender i’ve ever met and everytime i come here she seems like she wants to be anywhere else. This has happened multiple times within the last year, she only wants to sit at the bar talking to men

mike bish

Joy's is by far one of the best places to watch football games. Their food is delicious, beers and drinks are phenomenal, everything is fairly priced, and the customer service is beyond amazing.

Jae Perez

I don’t leave reviews but the bartenders at this place deserve one. My friends and I visited Joy’s Tavern for a drink. When I arrived I purchased a single drink for $5, paid, and closed my tab. I chose not to leave a tip, as it was a quick transaction and a small order. Later, I decided to order a Sprite for my pregnant girlfriend, but was denied service because I hadn’t tipped on the first drink. I didn’t realize 1 single dollar would have turned the light bill off. This experience left a poor impression, and I won’t be returning. If you’re that worried about $1 please get a new job.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Don B

Purchased one draft beer($3.50)… tipped 15%. I guess this was seen as a form of disrespect by Jordan so she chose to give the $ back and I was told to not even bother.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kari Keller

Food is always great, especially the pizza! Staff is always friendly and willing to help no matter what your request. Draft beers always taste fresh, unlike some of the other local places…

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries, Wings, Fried Pickles

What H

Amazing owner, fantastic staff
I have yet to taste something on menu I haven't loved. Blackened chicken mac-n- cheese is where is it's at! And Joy's burgers are the best around!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Southwest Cheeseburger, Pepperoni Pizza, Blue Cheese Burger, BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger Wrap, Wings

Loading...