I placed an order to pick up. Two medium pizzas. One with half pepperoni and on the other side onion. The other medium pizza was a white pizza, along with a dozen wings. They charged $53.00 Outrageous! I got home with this overpriced food and discovered instead of pepperoni they put mushrooms on one side. ( did I say both pies were like lukewarm) Additionally the wings came with 11 flats and 1 drumstick. One more thing, the pizza was so thin you could put it up to a light and see thru it. lol . I called to voice my concerns and they hung up on me. Do yourself a favor and go to several other pizza shops on the mountain. One last thing , this place is cash only. Why would you do that. Hmm. lol
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Howlingwolf 22
Geraldo the owner was there. What a treat! Funny, happy and definitely Italian lol. Wings, extra crispy, we're large and very good. Settle on hot, mild or barbecue sauce thought. Round pie with onions and sausage. I thought it was good too. Toppings end to end, lol round pie. Help yourself to drinks, kinda nice. No wait. Warm atmosphere, very clean and plenty to look at. The staff is great. Knows what's going on. That really matters. Give them a try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Adam Michael Spangler
Got myself a sweet sauce pie and a Geraldos stromboli this past weekend and boy ill tell you what. They were spectacular and im looking forward to ordering again in the near future.
Lori McKeown
EXCELLENT PIZZA!!!! Best in the whole area !!
Cindi Powell
Inconsistent. When it's good, it's good, but half the time, the pizza is dried out and not hot. Some of the food on the side from the Amish is old and should be in a fridge. It is expensive with $15 for a pizza that is barely edible 50% of the time. There are a few good places anymore. The homey atmosphere is nice, with trains and nice old tables. Always clean and friendly. I'm at the point though if the pizza is bad I call them and tell them. And I'm probably not going to even go there anymore. The hometown Farmers Market has their food truck there and that pizza is very good but it's $4 for one small piece of pizza. Although, when I was there I got an old slice the one day that was overcooked and I didn't like that much but it was still better than what's coming out of the restaurant, these days.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Diane Frymoyer
Had a pizza delivered the first call a young girl answered she asked for my address, I tried to explain it to her she laid phone down n I could hear her say I was being very Rude to her, took several minutes I hung up n called back then a young man answered took my order n it took them over an hour n half to deliver it. They gave me it for no charge, I in No way was being rude
Food: 5
Service: 1
Michelle
This was our second time having pizza and wings at the Whistle Stop and it won't be our last. The pizza is very tasty and has a thin ,crispy crust. The wings were super crispy and delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Whistle Stop Special Pizza
Tom Elliott
We canceled our order due to the limited availability of product.
Greg Paulson
Pizza is EXCELLENT & BIG!Wings are great as well.Once you try, you’ll keep on buying it!
Pizza is great! We drive from Scranton. It's worth the drive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Chris Ostroski
No idea how this place always gets these high ratings.....Literally tried it three times thinking I was missing something, but it takes forever, they have some antiquated slide oven that looks like it's from Quiznos, and the pizza was almost raw when it came out.......
I placed an order to pick up. Two medium pizzas. One with half pepperoni and on the other side onion. The other medium pizza was a white pizza, along with a dozen wings. They charged $53.00 Outrageous! I got home with this overpriced food and discovered instead of pepperoni they put mushrooms on one side. ( did I say both pies were like lukewarm) Additionally the wings came with 11 flats and 1 drumstick. One more thing, the pizza was so thin you could put it up to a light and see thru it. lol . I called to voice my concerns and they hung up on me. Do yourself a favor and go to several other pizza shops on the mountain. One last thing , this place is cash only. Why would you do that. Hmm. lol
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Geraldo the owner was there. What a treat! Funny, happy and definitely Italian lol. Wings, extra crispy, we're large and very good. Settle on hot, mild or barbecue sauce thought. Round pie with onions and sausage. I thought it was good too. Toppings end to end, lol round pie. Help yourself to drinks, kinda nice. No wait. Warm atmosphere, very clean and plenty to look at. The staff is great. Knows what's going on. That really matters. Give them a try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Got myself a sweet sauce pie and a Geraldos stromboli this past weekend and boy ill tell you what. They were spectacular and im looking forward to ordering again in the near future.
EXCELLENT PIZZA!!!! Best in the whole area !!
Inconsistent. When it's good, it's good, but half the time, the pizza is dried out and not hot. Some of the food on the side from the Amish is old and should be in a fridge. It is expensive with $15 for a pizza that is barely edible 50% of the time. There are a few good places anymore. The homey atmosphere is nice, with trains and nice old tables. Always clean and friendly. I'm at the point though if the pizza is bad I call them and tell them. And I'm probably not going to even go there anymore. The hometown Farmers Market has their food truck there and that pizza is very good but it's $4 for one small piece of pizza. Although, when I was there I got an old slice the one day that was overcooked and I didn't like that much but it was still better than what's coming out of the restaurant, these days.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Had a pizza delivered the first call a young girl answered she asked for my address, I tried to explain it to her she laid phone down n I could hear her say I was being very Rude to her, took several minutes I hung up n called back then a young man answered took my order n it took them over an hour n half to deliver it. They gave me it for no charge, I in No way was being rude
Food: 5
Service: 1
This was our second time having pizza and wings at the Whistle Stop and it won't be our last. The pizza is very tasty and has a thin ,crispy crust. The wings were super crispy and delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Whistle Stop Special Pizza
We canceled our order due to the limited availability of product.
Pizza is EXCELLENT & BIG!Wings are great as well.Once you try, you’ll keep on buying it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Best round
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
DELICIOUS! You have to try their pizza😋
Great pizza ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is great! We drive from Scranton. It's worth the drive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
No idea how this place always gets these high ratings.....Literally tried it three times thinking I was missing something, but it takes forever, they have some antiquated slide oven that looks like it's from Quiznos, and the pizza was almost raw when it came out.......
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Best pizza/wings in town.
Loading...