Cafe 58

58 W Main Ave, Myerstown
(717) 628-1642

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Leonard Pundt

Best crêpes I've had in a long, long while. Superb coffee. The owner knows his stuff. Tell him what you're looking for and put yourself in his hands; he won't steer you wrong. Relaxed atmosphere. Soft jazz in the background. Perfect for a nice unwind.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ian Wesley

Just went in for latte and cappuccino, but before we could order we got a rant about how he wouldn't be serving any tweeny foo foo drinks. 'My beverages are strictly Italian.' OK buddy I'll go get all my friends who drink strictly Italian beverages and help you out with your business. Wait, are your strictly Italian beverages any good? Uhm. Nooo! They're not. Nothing against Italian beverages at all. Honestly I think this is the first time I've actually tried an authentic latte. But I hope that's not what it really tastes like. I guess I'll find out if I go to Italy.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 1

TRACY M

The man was extremely rude to my daughter taunting her about the coffee is not dunkin. The cappuccino was terrible, I will never be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Annie Ketter

Highly recommend. Come early to sit and enjoy and talk. Leave your phone on airplane mode 😉 Best coffee around. I had both crepes. The meat crepe was so fresh. The fruit crepe was sinfully delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen Stepp

Absolutely the best espresso I have ever had. Atmosphere is welcoming and service superb 👏🏻 Open on Sundays.. I suggest the crepes!! Breakfast menu is available! Delicious 😋

Jed Weidner

Espresso local, delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole High

We were in the area and were excited to try this place. There was only a family of 4 then me and my husband in there. We had to wait for the owner to take the orders and make the other customers food before we were waited on. So after 45 minutes we were asked to order, everything we ordered was belittled and judged. He insisted he knew better. I'm all for suggestions, but defending ourselves made us uncomfortable just for some breakfast. He then made a reference to his food being orgasmic...🤢 Food was great, but we can not return if this will be the experience every time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

munks diossa

Good crepes and coffee, good conversation. Not a huge menu bc every item is well thought out and quality

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

matthew schouten

Great coffee with free entertainment

Erik Firestine

Classy place classy dude running it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nichita Sisman

It’s a nice good atmosphere Italian cafe, the owner is a nice guy who wants to make sure you have the right experience with coffee and food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brigette McSharar

I wanted to like this place. I love the weekend hours.

I found it to have mixed messaging and no prices! There was a sign on the counter that said kitchen closed but people ordered crepes after me. I was unsure if it was a breakfast spot with full table service vs bar ordering.

I ordered a plain latte. Now having read some reviews that seems to be a sore spot for the owner. I wasn't allowed to order that so I ended up with a plain cappuccino. I am not a fan of so much foam.

Please consider:
-Menus with pricing
-Consistent signage so the customer knows what to do
-Louder music: I felt like I was in someone's conversation and I was trying to do my own work
-Unlocked bathroom or be available so patrons can ask for a key.
-Reframing how you instruct patrons on ordering
- Hire a HS kid to do customer facing so you focus on the back of house, chit chat with customers, and they field all the orders.

You don't need to belittle other companies to promote yourself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 2

Steph

Well I tried to post about my experience and Google decided to delete my review, but it was such a bad encounter that I feel the need to post another one to warn other not to visit this place.

My fiancé and I decided to stop in the other week, and I tried to order a plain latte. I don't order sugary drinks because of the extra sugar, but the owner took my order as an offense and went on a SUPER condescending tirade about Taylor Swift, "caramel drizzle insulin resisting coffee", and how his coffee is so superb because it's imported from Italy and how all the coffee shops around here are just "8 ounces of watered down coffee." The fact that I was treated like a heathen for trying to order a basic plain latte had me floored.
My fiancé ended up getting a drink, and it definitely didn't taste good enough to warrant the owner's ranting and raving about his "sophisticated" Italian coffee.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

J. Mirwood

Chris has done a phenomenal job bringing the authentic flavors of Italy and France to Myerstown, PA. I genuinely couldn't believe that such a high quality crepe could exist on this side of the pond! All ingredients are sourced as high quality as can be.

My wife and I were on a road trip from PA up to NH and luckily stumbled past this cafe on our drive. We had just missed the back patio being open during Memorial Day (hope the weather worked out, dude.) We will definitely be back.

All I can say is: check your ego at the door, even if you already know what a true macchiato is. ? Enjoy the experience that is being curated for you, and understand that many Americans don't know what true espresso drinks are hence the spiel that some people might complain about.

Finally, good things take TIME ... so don't be in a rush.

Vegetarian options: The fully loaded vegetarian crepe is all you need to know.

Parking: Parked right outside on the street, but there is also a free parking lot on the other side of 501 with eight business parking spots.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Strawberry Banana Crepes

Matt Martin jr.

The drinks and crapes were fantastic. The owner was very helpful and gave some neat history on what we ordered 10/10 i will definitely be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...