Cafe 58

58 W Main Ave, Myerstown
(717) 628-1642

Recent Reviews

Alejandra Eaton

I was there for the first time with a group of friends. We were all treated poorly and even offensively. For starters, the cashier/server didn’t greet us at all. After she took our order of drinks, she came to our table to offer water, which I accepted politely. A long time later, while still waiting for our drinks, the barista/cook came out and yelled at us from behind the counter: “So, are you going to order anything or just came in here to drink water?” We were all shocked by his rudeness. We simply replied that we had already placed our order of drinks. Then he started preparing and bringing them to the table one by one. When he got to one of my friends’ order, he came to the table to ask her, and I quote: “Do you know what a macchiato is? It’s not the kind they have at Dunkin Donuts.” To this, he followed to explain what a real macchiato was and told my friend that that was what she was getting. My friend, very politely replied: “I know what a macchiato is, I’ve had it before many times.”This man just saw a bunch of latino women visiting his snobby cafe and assumed we were neophytes that just came out of jumping the boarder! Not all latinos are the same! In our case, we are all professional, smart women that speak more than 3 languages, including Chinese mandarin, and have traveled around the world visiting many countries in Europe and Asia. I, personally, am an agricultural engineer specialized in coffee production, and come from a family of coffee farmers. I know what real coffee is because I have tasted and tested the best coffees in the world! Sadly, I didn’t have the opportunity to try his coffee and see how good it was, if any, because he skipped my order.In life, assumptions kill.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

megan depugh

The owner of this restaurant is very nasty and doesn’t like anyone in there past 3pm even tho it closes at 5. Food also tasted horrible.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Clarissa Ortenzi

This was the best place I went I go with my kids or they go bye themselves it is very kid

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Strawberry Banana Crepes

John G.

Easily some of the worst service I've ever seen. The inside of the shop does not match what you receive from the staff. Good luck to all who venture here.

Huck McNasty

On point. Much needed business for a cute small town! Brings a different vibe and atmosphere to the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah

Very positive experience here; wonderful selection of teas as well as coffee! Excellent conversation with the owner as well :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sally Frazier

I come here a lot & no one should expect to be waited on. Its a cafe; just belly up to the bar & ask for what you want! I read a bad review so I'm just disputing it/ go check it out 4 yourself!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie Boyer

Defiantly one of the worst coffee shops ive been too. Im new to the area, and decided to try out a new coffee shop. I waited a total of 20 minutes until the worker even said a word to me and paid attention as to why i was there. Once he did, he went off on a whole lecture on why the drink i wanted was incorrect and i shouldn't've ordered that. Then told me what i should order. Then also continued to go on about how any other coffee shops around are not good because Americans dont know why their even drinking coffee. Would have much rather went somewhere else for a better experience because overall this was not a good one. Highly suggest you go somewhere else.I never leave reviews, but i felt i needed to warn people about this place. Overall a very rude and unprofessional person.

Service: 1

Michael H.

Stopped in for an ice vanilla latte and a ice pumpkin latte. The cafe only serves the best Italian espresso and whole milk. No half and half or artificial flavored creamers.The latte flavoring was the standard Torani syrups. The lattes were delicious.The barista was personable and the cafe itself was nicely decorated. A very comfortable environment. Couches in one area and tables and chairs in a different area.If you are heading south on 501 into Myerstown, look for the cafe on the left hand side.

Landen Hibshman

Great coffee and a welcoming environment. A perfect combination. Chris may seem a bit coarse initially, but he is very passionate about what he does. A true connoisseur of coffee. Definitely stop in here if you are in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Peg A.

The guy that owns this place is ridiculously rude. I've heard this from others but wanted to give him the benefit of proving it to me personally. While we were there recently, a customer came in and ordered a macchiato. The owner then proceeds to say "do you know what a macchiato is"? The customer repeated it back to him verbatim as it appeared on the menu. The owner then says "that's not right", this isn't Dunkin. He then goes on to say that he's the only one there. He's a one man show. The crêpes aren't ready to be made yet. He's the only Coffee shop open on a Sunday. Blah blah blah. His coffee certainly isn't good enough to warrant the attitude. I'll take Dunkin anyday. I'm very excited that they're coming to Myerstown.

Zach Martin

We ordered plain lattes and the owner immediately launched into a tirade bashing Starbucks, Dunkin Donuts, Taylor Swift and sugary drinks. Weird, not sure how that relates to a plain latte and was very off-putting. There are less hostile places in the area to get coffee... Suggest you try one out.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Sherri Mast

Cute lil cafe...crepes n espresso drinks...?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maria Brown

The coffee was good but will not be returning due to the owner being incredibly rude and condescending. We asked for 2 small plain lattes and were immediately given a lecture on how this isn't a coffee shop but an "authentic Italian cafe". He went on and on about how he doesn't serve to Starbucks/Taylor Swift/Dunkin Donuts drinkers. He really tries to make you feel like you know nothing about coffee. I never leave reviews but after my experience here I felt I needed to.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Dakota Frantz

Authentic Coffee Authentic Crepes. Authentic in everyway. Don't come here expecting to have your feelings catered to. Come here for a genuine sit down Café experience

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More