Marty's has great pizza and wings. I also really like their farmers cheese pierogies, smothered in onions and butter 🧈 😋
Jobey George
Great pizza. Great wings. Great prices. 10/10 would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Hartman
Excellent food and service. The convenience of having the blue cheese and celery packed in with the wings makes for a stress free search for a quick takeout experience without digging through 10 different bags and containers.
J B
Best pizza in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
howard QUOOS
Food was okay but why would you pack blue cheese and celery in the same box as a hot item? It went straight to the garbage. Who wants hot blue cheese and celery?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Geri collins
Quiet little restaurant with a wide range of delicious foods.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terence Joyce
1st timer here!
Fried Sicilian was the best I've ever had! Absolutely amazing. White pizza was pretty burnt unfortunately so I couldn't give 5 stars. We will absolutely try them again and happily edit the score, im sure it was maybe an off night!
Matt B
Marty's Pizza is always good. Not quite a NY style but definitely not a typical valley sweet sauce pizza. I've gotten it many times and it's always high quality. I've never eaten in but it seems like a classy place and crowd inside.
Food: 5
Vicki Amorosa
The way this guy speaks to paying customers... it's a wonder the doors are still open. How tf do you feel OK about berating a customer for leaving a mediocre review? Didn't leave BAD review. Just not a 5 star review. And if my food came with ingredients on it that was not advertised in the description(what if said person had an allergy against an "accidental ingredient"?), came out dry, and the seafood tasted old...I wouldn't have left a stellar review, either. And then to hop on the review and belittle them, rather than trying to make it right? Way to make sure those people never come back. Good job!
Jill Morris
We ordered out so we didn't get to deal with much of the service. It's Friday night and I know that means it's crunch time in a restaurant I've worked in MANY before. We ordered 4 things technically 3. We decided on 2 crab stuffed mushrooms, that tasted like there crab has been sitting out for a week, a chicken bacon ranch pizza with broccoli, which wasn't bad for the free extra toppings we didn't ask for like a couple uncooked onions and half backed tomatoes but I guess they were used becuase they ran out of baconor something, and mild wing bites, that were just a bit dry. Crab stuffed mushrooms should not be almost 10 bucks when your getting something like that back. We've been here not that long ago and raved about the food. I really hope you didn't get a new chef, and we were very disappointed.
A small gem tucked away in Nanticoke... A wine tasting event led us to find this great place and the pasta fagul, the lasagna and the charcuterie board along with the Tira-masu were absolutely fantastic. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tara Kandrac-Armbruster
We ordered the fried Sicilian pizza was my first time ordering from Marty’s. It was very good and boneless bites were also very good. Everything was fresh and hot.
William Perkins
Great food! I had stopped and purchased a few different items; cabbage roll special, spaghetti and meatballs, fish and chips, Clam chowder, and pierogies. I had some fries while waiting at the bar for my take out - EVERYTHING was OUTSTANDING! I can't wait to get back as I really want to try the pizza! Worth the trip!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
You Need To Know? Restaurant reviews
You Need To Know? This was a pleasant find in the neighborhoods of Nanticoke. Arrived around 5:45 and it was busy. By the time we left there was not a seat available. The two girls working the floor were busting there ass & made for a great team. The food is fantastic with homemade dishes. We tried the homemade pierogis, pizza, wings (red garlic), homemade meatball sandwich, homemade piggies, & a surf & turf cheeseburger 🍔. The food was very flavorful & well worth a visit when you are near Nanticoke. The only knock was the burger was served with tartar sauce, because of the crabcake on it but we didn't like the mixture with the burger. Personal choice. Now You Know! -TBH
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Eric McDermott
First time trying Marty's in Nanticoke. The pizza was amazing. The crust made the pizza top notch. The bites were good too.
Marty's has great pizza and wings. I also really like their farmers cheese pierogies, smothered in onions and butter 🧈 😋
Great pizza. Great wings. Great prices. 10/10 would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food and service. The convenience of having the blue cheese and celery packed in with the wings makes for a stress free search for a quick takeout experience without digging through 10 different bags and containers.
Best pizza in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was okay but why would you pack blue cheese and celery in the same box as a hot item? It went straight to the garbage. Who wants hot blue cheese and celery?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Quiet little restaurant with a wide range of delicious foods.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
1st timer here!
Fried Sicilian was the best I've ever had! Absolutely amazing. White pizza was pretty burnt unfortunately so I couldn't give 5 stars. We will absolutely try them again and happily edit the score, im sure it was maybe an off night!
Marty's Pizza is always good. Not quite a NY style but definitely not a typical valley sweet sauce pizza. I've gotten it many times and it's always high quality. I've never eaten in but it seems like a classy place and crowd inside.
Food: 5
The way this guy speaks to paying customers... it's a wonder the doors are still open. How tf do you feel OK about berating a customer for leaving a mediocre review? Didn't leave BAD review. Just not a 5 star review. And if my food came with ingredients on it that was not advertised in the description(what if said person had an allergy against an "accidental ingredient"?), came out dry, and the seafood tasted old...I wouldn't have left a stellar review, either. And then to hop on the review and belittle them, rather than trying to make it right? Way to make sure those people never come back. Good job!
We ordered out so we didn't get to deal with much of the service. It's Friday night and I know that means it's crunch time in a restaurant I've worked in MANY before. We ordered 4 things technically 3. We decided on 2 crab stuffed mushrooms, that tasted like there crab has been sitting out for a week, a chicken bacon ranch pizza with broccoli, which wasn't bad for the free extra toppings we didn't ask for like a couple uncooked onions and half backed tomatoes but I guess they were used becuase they ran out of baconor something, and mild wing bites, that were just a bit dry. Crab stuffed mushrooms should not be almost 10 bucks when your getting something like that back. We've been here not that long ago and raved about the food. I really hope you didn't get a new chef, and we were very disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
A small gem tucked away in Nanticoke... A wine tasting event led us to find this great place and the pasta fagul, the lasagna and the charcuterie board along with the Tira-masu were absolutely fantastic. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered the fried Sicilian pizza was my first time ordering from Marty’s. It was very good and boneless bites were also very good. Everything was fresh and hot.
Great food! I had stopped and purchased a few different items; cabbage roll special, spaghetti and meatballs, fish and chips, Clam chowder, and pierogies. I had some fries while waiting at the bar for my take out - EVERYTHING was OUTSTANDING! I can't wait to get back as I really want to try the pizza! Worth the trip!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
You Need To Know? This was a pleasant find in the neighborhoods of Nanticoke. Arrived around 5:45 and it was busy. By the time we left there was not a seat available. The two girls working the floor were busting there ass & made for a great team. The food is fantastic with homemade dishes. We tried the homemade pierogis, pizza, wings (red garlic), homemade meatball sandwich, homemade piggies, & a surf & turf cheeseburger 🍔. The food was very flavorful & well worth a visit when you are near Nanticoke. The only knock was the burger was served with tartar sauce, because of the crabcake on it but we didn't like the mixture with the burger. Personal choice. Now You Know! -TBH
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
First time trying Marty's in Nanticoke. The pizza was amazing. The crust made the pizza top notch. The bites were good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...