Windy Hill Bakehouse

364 Mellon Rd, New Brighton
(724) 843-4899

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mary Werner-Smith

Wow!! The peach cookies were delicious! The cinnamon rolls were too!! Highly recommend!! Thank you!!!

bigkaw2053

I've worked a couple events that they were vending at. The lady locks were really good, but last time I had chocolate cake with espresso buttercream & caramel drizzle. It might be the best cake I've ever had! And prices are reasonable too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hollie Walker

Delicious cake. We used windy hill for our wedding cake. We got many compliments.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauren Ferianc

We had a great experience working with Windyhill Bakehouse for our wedding! Jeanette was so easy to work with — kind and really understood what we were looking for. We chose a small cutting cake and a variety of cupcakes, and everything turned out perfectly. Not only did everything look beautiful, but it was absolutely delicious too! Our guests loved the variety, and we couldn’t have been happier with how it all came together. Highly recommend!

Food: 5

Lauren Ferianc Sarnese

We had a great experience working with Windyhill Bakehouse for our wedding! Jeanette was so easy to work with — kind and really understood what we were looking for. We chose a small cutting cake and a variety of cupcakes, and everything turned out perfectly. Not only did everything look beautiful, but it was absolutely delicious too! Our guests loved the variety, and we couldn’t have been happier with how it all came together. Highly recommend!

Mindy Searfoss

Jeanette was wonderful to work with through the process of planning our wedding reception. From customer service, to sampling cakes, to delivery and the final product. I highly recommend Windy Hill bakery for your needs! We had 3 different flavors available: carrot cake, vanilla, and funfetti. They were perfect!

Lili Molina

my second cake from her and both were amazing! her cake pops are the best too!

Pamela Monroe

Wonderful cookies! Everything was fresh and Jeanette was very friendly. Will definitely order again from this bakery!

Dawn C

Windy Hill made us a Bourbon Peach Cheesecake as a special request and it was absolutely fabulous!!! Fresh Peaches, excellent flavor, not too sweet and it was beautiful! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William Humphries IV

Absolutely the best cakes. We will never go back to the big stores as long as this place is operating!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexandra McKinney

Windy Hill Bakehouse is by far the best bakery in the Pittsburgh area. They made our wedding cake, individual cakes for our anniversaries, she will be doing our baby shower, and we've even gotten some baked goods from them at local get togethers. Every flavor that they have is great and each bite leaves us wanting more. Fortunately, the prices are so good that getting more is pretty easy!Jennette is super easy to work with and every time we see her, she remembers our names and it's fun to catch up while snacking on whatever new goodie she has. I can't recommend Windy Hill Bakehouse enough! If you haven't tried it yet, this is your sign to order something great!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexandra McKinney

Windy Hill Bakehouse is by far the best bakery in the Pittsburgh area. They made our wedding cake, individual cakes for our anniversaries, she will be doing our baby shower, and we've even gotten some baked goods from them at local get togethers. Every flavor that they have is great and each bite leaves us wanting more. Fortunately, the prices are so good that getting more is pretty easy! Jennette is super easy to work with and every time we see her, she remembers our names and it's fun to catch up while snacking on whatever new goodie she has. I can't recommend Windy Hill Bakehouse enough! If you haven't tried it yet, this is your sign to order something great!

Mj Isles McCurdy

Windy Hill is the best! We've ordered cookies, Valentine's Day treats, and the most delicious buckeyes we've ever had. My husband loves them. Jennette is always responsive, even with my last minute requests. Highly recommend!

Ashley Nicole

I cannot say enough good things about Windy Hill Bakehouse! Her cakes are amazing and very customizable. All I have to do is show her a picture and the magic begins! Whether it’s a simple birthday cake or as a grande as wedding, the taste and quality never disappoint.The cookies are so good sometimes I don’t want to share them with guests- especially at Christmas time! Not only are the baked goods delicious, but the baker, Jeannette is just as sweet and is always there for my crazy last minute requests. Highly highly recommend you give Windy Hill a try!

raquel abad

Jennette made the half sheet cake for our daughter’s 4th birthday- it was vegan as requested (funfetti cake/strawberry jam/vanilla “butter”cream), beautiful (printed an image of my specific selection), and most importantly of all, DELICIOUS! Many people at the party asked for the bakery information. It was reasonably priced and Jennette was so easy to work with. Will definitely order from her again in the future and will recommend her to anyone! 5 stars! Thank you, Jennette.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...