Millie's Pizza
34 Mill St, New Buffalo
(717) 834-6565
Customers' Favorites
Cheeseburger Sub
Millies Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Alot of Pizza
Neapolitan Style Pizza
Millie's Pan Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, sweet pepper, and onion.
Meat Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon, and ham.
White Pizza
Mozzarella, provolone, American, olive oil, and garlic.
Hot Wing Pizza
Chicken breast meat, blue cheese, and mozzarella.
Hot Hot Hot Pizza
Pepperoni, hot pepper relish, onion, and jalapeno pepper.
Chicken Ranch Pizza
Chicken, mozzarella, ranch sauce, bacon, onion, and tomato.
Bbq Chicken Pizza
Chicken, bbq sauce, and mozzarella.
Chicken Steak Pizza
Chicken, mozzarella, and onion.
Chicken Steak Supreme Pizza
Chicken, mozzarella, mushroom, onion, and sweet pepper.
Cheesesteak Pizza
Steak, onion, and mozzarella.
Steak Lover's Pizza
Steak, onion, mushroom, sweet pepper, and mozzarella.
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Mozzarella, bacon, and hamburger.
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, pineapple, and mozzarella.
Vegetarian's Dream Pizza
Mushroom, onion, sweet pepper, fresh tomato, and black olive.
Pizza By The Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
Appetizers
French Fry
Mozzarella Stix
Pizzarolla
Wings
Dry, mild, hot, bbq, honey bbq, garlic, garlic mild, garlic hot, honey mustard, ranch, add parmesan to any sauce served with blue cheese and celery.
Jalapeno Poppers
Breaded Mushroom
Onion Rings
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers and Fries
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Millie's Munchie Mania
Mmm includes 2 mozzarella sticks, 2 jalapeno poppers, 2 breaded mushrooms, 2 onion rings, and 2 chicken fingers.
Salads
Tossed Salad
Lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Garden Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, and green pepper
Chef Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, ham, salami, provolone cheese, green pepper, and cucumber
Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, and cucumber
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Hot, mild, or bbq grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, and cucumber.
Grilled Steak Salad
Grilled steak, lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, and cucumber.
Turkey Salad
Turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, and cucumber.
Turkey Chef Salad
Turkey, provolone, ham, salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, and cucumber.
Calzone
Ham and Cheese Calzone
Ham, mozzarella, and sauce.
Cheese Calzone
Mozzarella and sauce.
Cheesesteak Calzone
Steak, onion, mozzarella, and sauce.
Chicken steak Calzone
Chicken, onion, and mozzarella.
Meatball Calzone
Meatball, mozzarella, and sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Calzone
Blue cheese, mozzarella hot, mild, or bbq chicken.
Broccoli Calzone
Broccoli, mozzarella, and sauce.
BBC Calzone
Beef, bacon, mozzarella, and sauce.
TBC Calzone
Turkey, bacon, and mozzarella.
BLT Calzone
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mozzarella.
HB Calzone
Ham, bacon, mozzarella, and sauce.
Stromboli
Regular Stromboli
Mozzarella, pepperoni, ham, salami, sausage, sweet pepper, onion, mushroom, and sauce.
Cheesesteak Stromboli
Steak, onion, mozzarella, and sauce.
Cheesesteak Supreme Stromboli
Steak, onion, mozzarella, mushroom, sweet pepper, and sauce.
Chicken steak Stromboli
Chicken, onion, and mozzarella.
Chicken steak Supreme Stromboli
Chicken, onion, mozzarella, mushroom, and sweet pepper.
Vegetarian Stromboli
Sweet pepper, onion, mushroom, fresh tomato, black olive, mozzarella, and sauce.
Hot Subs
Cheeseburger
2 quarter lbs. Hamburger patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Steak Sub
Steak, onions, and sauce.
Cheesesteak Sub
Steak, onion, American cheese, and sauce.
Cheesesteak Mushroom Sub
Steak, onion, mushroom, American cheese, and sauce.
Cheesesteak Sweet Pepper Sub
Steak, onion, sweet pepper, American cheese, and sauce.
Cheesesteak Sweet Pepper
Steak, onion, sweet pepper, American cheese, and sauce.
Cheesesteak Supreme Sub
Steak, onion, mushroom, sweet pepper, American cheese, and sauce.
Cheesesteak in the Garden Sub
Steak, onion, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Chicken Cheesesteak Sub
Chicken, onion, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken Cheesesteak Mushroom Sub
Chicken, onion, mushroom, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken Cheesesteak Sweet Pepper Sub
Chicken, onion, sweet pepper, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Supreme Sub
Chicken, onion, mushroom, sweet pepper, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Cheesesteak
Chicken, bbq sauce, American cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato chicken club chicken, bacon, onion, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken Ranch Cheese Steak Sub
Chicken, onion, ranch sauce, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken Club Sub
Chicken, bacon, onion, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken Ranch Club Cheesesteak Sub
Chicken, bacon, onion, ranch sauce, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
Breaded chicken, sauce, and mozzarella.
Chicken Finger Sub
Breaded chicken, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Bacon Cheeseburger
2 quarter lbs. Hamburger patties, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Pizza Steak
Steak, pepperoni, mozzarella, and sauce.
Pizza Burger
Hamburger patties, sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
Hamburger
Hamburger patties, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Meatball and Cheese Sub
Meatballs, sauce, and mozzarella.
Ham and Cheese Cosmo Sub
Toasted ham and American cheese, with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Cheese Cosmo Sub
Toasted mozzarella, provolone, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
BLT Sub
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken steak Sub
Chicken, onion, lettuce, and tomato.
Cold Subs
Italian Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Ham and Cheese Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Turkey and Provolone Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Turkey Club Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Vegetarian and Provolone Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Salami and Cheese Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Cheese Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Combo Sub
Turkey, ham, and provolone. Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Pepperoni and Cheese Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Party Subs
Turkey and Cheese Sub
Ham and Cheese Sub
Kid's Menu
Kid's Grilled Cheese
Kids Chicken Fingers and Fries
Kids Apple Juice Box
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Millie's is a wonderful pizza shop that deserves all of your business. They have the best pizza crust, sauce, and toppings. This family owned shop does whatever it takes to make sure you have a wonderful meal and atmosphere.
November 2025
We ordered a large meat lovers pizza and 1 Italian sub and 1 cheeseburger sub. The delivery was faster than expected and I did not have the pizza but my son in law said it was awesome. I had the cheeseburger sub. 1st the hamburger patties were amazing tender and juicy,2nd the roll hand made and soft and delicious. This roll did NOT come out of a bag. The sub was well put together and perfectly portioned additional toppings. I have rarely enjoyed one more. The delivery driver was...
September 2025
I've been getting food from Millie's for about 10 years now. The food is always excellent. Once in a while there's a small mistake but considering they help the young community by employing some kids as their first time job, I can see past it. All in all this place is a must if you're in the area or even passing through.
July 2025
You May Also Like
Lumberjack's Kitchen - 3200 Susquehanna Trail
![]()
Family, Comfort Food, Seafood, Vegetarian
Tim Hortons - 3298 Susquehanna Trail
![]()
Cafe, Coffee Shops, Coffee
Burger King - 3294 Susquehanna Trail
![]()
Burgers, Fast Food