Culhane's Steak House

1 Laurel Rd, New Cumberland
(717) 938-0930

Recent Reviews

Sort by
April Wright

Food wasn't as awesome as I'd been told by others, maybe an off night

Monica P

The surf and turf dinner was so good and reasonable.

Dale Zartman

Large group and server got everything correct. Food was great and served hot - steaks sizzling. Server made sure my wife's haddock had no old bay. My steak was done to perfection - medium rare. Been going here for many years and consistently good.

Travis Fitterling

Great place

Karen Meister

Food is superb. Staff very polite. But it's too loud when all tables are occupied. Very difficult to have a conversation.

Ron Sigel

Great steaks and seafood.

Joffrey Chandler

We came in 30 mins before 9pm. The place was empty. Turns out the google times for their hours of operations were wrong. However they were able to serve us right before they closed. Sue, our waiter was great. She was very knowledgeable and courteous . The value for the food was excellent. The food came out perfect. The steaks are better than most chain steak houses in the area and better priced. Great value if you are looking for a great dinner. Also the peanut pie was delicious!

David Roadcap

Great food and service. We didn't have reservations. There was an open table the whole time we waited... but after getting a table the food and service was great

Marc C

We wanted to like it but will never go back. Our server was not attentive, the crabcakes were flavorless, and the prices were high for what we had.

Michelle Evans Phillips

Excellent surf n turf. Great server and nice atmosphere. Will visit again.

Paula Mcclure

Filet with crab imperial excellent. Always cooked perfect.

garry willders

Wow, what used to be a great steak house was terrible. Seated quickly. Then no one ever came for drinks or appetizers. (30 minute). Then waitress shows up, nothing but excuses. Ordered drinks/soda, they come from the bar. No straws. Asked, another 10 minutes, went to bar for straw ourselves. At last 4 tables of customer came in after us, they all had their food, now mind you, we eat there several times a year. Will not be going back. Even after our food came out, no offer if condiments or steak sauce. Pathetic! Especially for the price.

C S

Horrible experience. Waitress was rude, not helpful and didn't follow order. Once she brought the raw steak and processed cheese mixes with crab and I told her it was wrong she argued with me in front of the entire table. If you are paying over $40 for an entree, you expect to get it the way you asked for it!

Calvin Thumma

Great place for steaks, chicken is also good here. The chocolate eclair is the best part.

Pete Distenfeld

Great steaks, and salmon. Service was good. No hostess stand so when you walk in your in the restaurant, kinda weird. They need sound absorbing panels, hard to hear your table, other tables you can hear great.

Loading...