Honestly it's been a while since I last went, but my family had a private event here a few years back for my Great Uncle's unfortunate passing during COVID. This is part of my family's legacy and it means the world that the owners keep my great grandfather's restaurant alive. The food is well made with recipes they kept, the service was pleasant whenever I went growing up, and though it's only our names on the sign now it still felt like we were welcomed back like family. If you're ever in the New Cumberland area, stop by.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Cake
cindy berrian
steaks are the best around! when the steaks come out sizzling...you know they are goid! crab imperial...yummy! service always friendly! place clean!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynn Bixler-Koll
Great place to gather with friends and food is great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MD Halperin
The staff and the food were fantastic, the exterior gave me nursing home vibes, but the interior was spacious, clean, and well lit. I wouldn't have dinged them on the atmosphere but whatever they use for a cleaner has a distinct lingering smell. Not bad necessarily but enough for me to notice or stop me from coming back again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eddie F.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ “Culhane’s Steak House: Where Steak Dreams Go to Rage!”
Culhane’s isn’t just a steakhouse—it’s a meat-fueled rock concert wrapped in a whiskey-scented hug. Tucked into Cumberland like a well-kept local legend, this place doesn’t just serve food—it throws down a full-throttle flavor experience that grabs your taste buds by the collar and shouts, “You’re welcome.”
🔥 The steaks? Absolute monsters. Thick-cut, sizzling, perfectly crusted on the outside, juicy on the inside like they were forged by lightning in a cast-iron thunderstorm. 🥩 I had a ribeye that made me question every other steak I’ve eaten in my life. It wasn’t just good—it was savage-level delicious. 🧈 The sides? Built to ride shotgun: buttery mashed potatoes, baked mac that tastes like it was engineered in a comfort food lab, and garlic bread that should probably be illegal.
The vibe? Straight-up vintage swagger with no gimmicks. Dark wood, low light, and a staff that knows exactly what you want before you do. Zero fluff. Just steak, spirit, and soul.
Culhane’s is what happens when old-school steakhouse tradition gets a jolt of rock ’n’ roll adrenaline. If you’re looking for a bland chain meal, keep driving. If you want the kind of dinner that makes you high-five strangers in the parking lot, this is your meaty Valhalla.
Five stars, no question. I’d give it six if I could carve one into a T-bone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Myers
First time visiting Culhanes and very pleased
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lester Seibert
This is one of my favorite places to go. The food is ALWAYS amazing and the service is just as phenomenal. I have NEVER had a meal that was less than excellent and the prices are quite affordable given the quality of food and the all around dining experience. I've been visiting this establishment since I was a child with family and will continue to frequent every chance I find. It's all around great place whether it's a family dinner, date night or just a solo lunch. Highly recommended if you haven't tried yet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandra Miller
I have been going to Culhanes for many years(probably 40 years). The food has always been exceptional, however our visit this evening was not what we thought it would be. It was crowded and it was hard to hear our party to hear each other. The waitress was great, however was not keeping up. We noticed that there were not many servers which would explain our waitress not keeping up. It would be helpful to address the noise within the dining room and increase your staff. If this my first visit, I might not have considered coming back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Leslie Lamb
The burger is great. My coworker told me to give it a try and it was well worth it. Great prices too, i ate a burger, fries and soda for less than $15. The space is a little dated, but it's well kept so it doesn't feel neglected
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Szczski
This is my favorite place for a nice steak dinner. I always get the surf and turf. Their prices and service are amazing. Steak is always cooked perfectly.
Food wasn't as awesome as I'd been told by others, maybe an off night
Monica P
The surf and turf dinner was so good and reasonable.
Dale Zartman
Large group and server got everything correct. Food was great and served hot - steaks sizzling. Server made sure my wife's haddock had no old bay. My steak was done to perfection - medium rare. Been going here for many years and consistently good.
Travis Fitterling
Great place
Karen Meister
Food is superb. Staff very polite. But it's too loud when all tables are occupied. Very difficult to have a conversation.
Honestly it's been a while since I last went, but my family had a private event here a few years back for my Great Uncle's unfortunate passing during COVID. This is part of my family's legacy and it means the world that the owners keep my great grandfather's restaurant alive. The food is well made with recipes they kept, the service was pleasant whenever I went growing up, and though it's only our names on the sign now it still felt like we were welcomed back like family. If you're ever in the New Cumberland area, stop by.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Cake
steaks are the best around! when the steaks come out sizzling...you know they are goid! crab imperial...yummy! service always friendly! place clean!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place to gather with friends and food is great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The staff and the food were fantastic, the exterior gave me nursing home vibes, but the interior was spacious, clean, and well lit. I wouldn't have dinged them on the atmosphere but whatever they use for a cleaner has a distinct lingering smell. Not bad necessarily but enough for me to notice or stop me from coming back again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Culhane’s Steak House: Where Steak Dreams Go to Rage!”
Culhane’s isn’t just a steakhouse—it’s a meat-fueled rock concert wrapped in a whiskey-scented hug. Tucked into Cumberland like a well-kept local legend, this place doesn’t just serve food—it throws down a full-throttle flavor experience that grabs your taste buds by the collar and shouts, “You’re welcome.”
🔥 The steaks? Absolute monsters. Thick-cut, sizzling, perfectly crusted on the outside, juicy on the inside like they were forged by lightning in a cast-iron thunderstorm.
🥩 I had a ribeye that made me question every other steak I’ve eaten in my life. It wasn’t just good—it was savage-level delicious.
🧈 The sides? Built to ride shotgun: buttery mashed potatoes, baked mac that tastes like it was engineered in a comfort food lab, and garlic bread that should probably be illegal.
The vibe? Straight-up vintage swagger with no gimmicks. Dark wood, low light, and a staff that knows exactly what you want before you do. Zero fluff. Just steak, spirit, and soul.
Culhane’s is what happens when old-school steakhouse tradition gets a jolt of rock ’n’ roll adrenaline. If you’re looking for a bland chain meal, keep driving. If you want the kind of dinner that makes you high-five strangers in the parking lot, this is your meaty Valhalla.
Five stars, no question. I’d give it six if I could carve one into a T-bone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time visiting Culhanes and very pleased
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is one of my favorite places to go. The food is ALWAYS amazing and the service is just as phenomenal. I have NEVER had a meal that was less than excellent and the prices are quite affordable given the quality of food and the all around dining experience. I've been visiting this establishment since I was a child with family and will continue to frequent every chance I find. It's all around great place whether it's a family dinner, date night or just a solo lunch. Highly recommended if you haven't tried yet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been going to Culhanes for many years(probably 40 years). The food has always been exceptional, however our visit this evening was not what we thought it would be. It was crowded and it was hard to hear our party to hear each other. The waitress was great, however was not keeping up. We noticed that there were not many servers which would explain our waitress not keeping up. It would be helpful to address the noise within the dining room and increase your staff. If this my first visit, I might not have considered coming back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
The burger is great. My coworker told me to give it a try and it was well worth it. Great prices too, i ate a burger, fries and soda for less than $15. The space is a little dated, but it's well kept so it doesn't feel neglected
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my favorite place for a nice steak dinner. I always get the surf and turf. Their prices and service are amazing. Steak is always cooked perfectly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Food wasn't as awesome as I'd been told by others, maybe an off night
The surf and turf dinner was so good and reasonable.
Large group and server got everything correct. Food was great and served hot - steaks sizzling. Server made sure my wife's haddock had no old bay. My steak was done to perfection - medium rare. Been going here for many years and consistently good.
Great place
Food is superb. Staff very polite. But it's too loud when all tables are occupied. Very difficult to have a conversation.
Loading...