Five Loaves Sandwiches

16 Center Sq, New Oxford
(717) 905-5623

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Reece

Just a little bit of constructive criticism towards your customer service, I visited the carry out this morning after placing an online order. There was a woman sitting waiting for her order and nobody else at the counter, a young man walked in clocked in and went about his business. Just a word of advice, 1 have some bells or a device notifying people coming and going your store when you’re in the back. You don’t want people coming in with nobody at the counter and wanting to place an order. You’re going to loose customers this way, they will walk out. 2 if your employees arrive walk by people in the lobby, clock in, acknowledge their presence, ask if everyone has been waited on. 3 write down on the paper wrap what sandwich it is so nobody will be eating or opening someone else’s order. It’s just small issues that need to be fine tuned. Your food is very good and we will be back !

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Kyle H

Delicious breakfast sandwiches!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Strand

Great place, clean and bright, food is fresh and SOOOO tasty.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Staub

First time here and had a delicious Reuben panini for lunch and wife had a BLT. Can’t beat a tasty fresh sandwich. Also love the concept of a Christian based restaurant.

Sydney A

I got the Bacon, Egg & Cheese on white toast and my gosh is it delicious! I wish I would’ve gotten a picture of it before I started eating, but attached is the sandwich. What I thought would be boring white toast was extremely yummy sourdough bread! I highly recommend! ⭐️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg & Cheese

Abigail Repasky

Food was incredible and easy to eat around my allergies

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Strand

awesome food, fresh and tasty. highly recommend, try the Jersey Favorite, get extra meat.

Leanne Lewis

My issue isn’t the food. It’s actually good. My issue is the owner. He speaks to the staff in totally inappropriate ways, he does not give breaks, and lowered pay without telling them. I will never eat there again because I can’t support two faced people.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Tyler Keeney

Rude staff, small store, who charges 13 dollars for a grilled cheese? No bathroom? Loud music in the back? Nasty flies everywhere. Overall a terrible experience.

Ty

Great place to grab a sandwich. I always go with the BLT on panini. 10/10 recommend. The garlic mayo is a much appreciated addition! My girlfriend and I love stopping here to grab lunch on our errand running days!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: blt Panini

Average Joe

I have never in my life been so disgusted with words that a grown man said. I was waiting for my food and I heard this bigger guy in a shirt way too small say "I love being the owner. No HR and I can say what I want". Utterly disgusting.

Christopher Lintner

rather pricey for what you get and the employees screw off too much at night.

Kathleen Myers

Great food and service. I haven’t had an order I didn’t like. Everything is always fresh and made with love. The chicken pesto for lunch or dinner is awesome and so is the bacon egg and cheese croissant for breakfast. They do the thin shredded lettuce to which is a great touch. It’s a nice convenient spot in town and a really great local business added to the community!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Croissant, Bacon Egg & Cheese, Chicken Pesto Panini

Robin Hudspeth

Meh. Subs were okay, but nothing special for a restaurant that only sells sandwiches. Comparable to Jersey Mike's. I ordered Italian sub no pickle no tom. I got pickle and tom. My husband ordered ham and American cheese sub no oil and vinegar. He got provolone and oil and vinegar. I know they aren't perfect... but that's a lot of mistakes!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Maggie Lawrence

delicious!! You have to try!

Loading...