Theo's Diner
8 S High St, Newville
(717) 776-1525
Customers' Favorites
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Sweet Potato Fries
Chicken Parmesan
Grilled Chicken
Chicken Fingers
Mashed Potatoes
Smother Chicken
French Fries
Cheeseburger
Tater Tots
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Nice place where people know each other and even the employees know the customers and have small talk with them. So much nicer than Carlisle restaurants where everyone's a stranger and a kind of big city indifference between customers. Theo's the customers even know each other. I don't want to go back to Carlisle when I am eating their great food, enjoying the small town atmosphere in Newville. ALSO the food I love, (grilled cheese sandwich and French fries),...
We highly recommend Theo's you feel welcomed from the moment you walk in. The server's are great. I have not once had a bad meal. The soups are flavorful and delicious. You can just tell that the owners care and want you to have a great experience!
Carolyn WV
Went to Theo’s today for my daughter’s birthday, Pam, with her uncle Doc and aunt Darlene from WV. This is a great place to eat. Food was good, reasonable prices, pleasant atmosphere. Our waitress was pleasant and friendly, checked frequently to ask if we needed anything. We felt like we were family. That’s a definite stop when we visit Pam again.
Went to Theo’s today for my daughter’s birthday, Pam, with her uncle Doc and aunt Darlene from WV. This is a great place to eat. Food was good, reasonable prices, pleasant atmosphere. Our waitress was pleasant and friendly, checked frequently to ask if we needed anything. We felt like we were family. That’s a definite stop when we visit Pam again.
You May Also Like
Whiskers Brewing Inc - 9 S High St
![]()
Brewery, Brewpubs, Pet Friendly
Kane's Korner Ice Cream - 52 S High St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Pizza, American, Italian, Ice Cream