Nottingham Inn Kitchen & Creamery

The Nottingham Inn is one of our favorite restaurants.

My friends and I have been coming here for the last few years. We started a tradition of meeting here around Christmas and then going to see the Herrs lights. We all love it! I’ve had breakfast and dinner here and both do not disappoint! Servers are always great! I feel like I am in a Christmas Cabin when I’m here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our family had dined at the Inn several times over the past 9 years, our last visit was about 2 years ago.

The food and service has always been very good, above average with a nice cozy atmosphere but the evening of Nov 1st 2025.

Out of our party of seven, two of us became violently ill a couple hours after dinner which was around 6:30pm.

We both had the Nottingham burger then small portion of ice cream (I didn't finish my baby cone of twist) out of the blue it hit us like a bomb!

Each of us spent the evening well into the next morning vomiting and other unenjoyable activities in the bathroom, I was considering a trip to the ER because of dehydration? As of this post at 7:16 then next morning, the frequet trips to the bathroom have stopped but have no appetite.

Sorry for the bad review, it must have had to do with the ice cream? We two were the only members of our party to get sick.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Charming country style diner with exceptionally good drinks and ice cream. The menu has some unique options and the food was good with very large portions, fantastic presentation and all at a fair price. Service was just right. We will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very wonderful and relaxing place to get a home cooked meal. Patience always greets us when we walk in and leave. She has also stepped into make 🍨 sundaes!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This restaurant is a true hidden treasure. The food is always delicious, hot, and served with a smile. They rotate their menu and update items with great subtle twists on traditional items. I can honestly say I've never had a bad meal. It's become one of the only places we seem to end up eating at.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We were in the area to see the corn maze, drove past and noticed all the cars and the vibey dining room. Decided to go inside for dinner. Wow. Whoever is running that kitchen should be proud. This place leaves all the Amish restaurants up north in Lancaster county in the dust. I noticed Turkey was mentioned a lot in reviews so I ordered that. It was the best turkey dinner I've ever had, along with perfect mashed potatoes, dressing and green beans for only $16. My wife had a chicken and shrimp special and the boys each had a burger. Everyone raved about their food and helped me finish my generous turkey portions. I don't remember the last time we had such a good experience at a restaurant. Atmosphere was happy, service was friendly and prompt. Like they all wouldn't choose to be doing anything else on Friday night. It was a meal I will never forget. We plan on coming back often. Can't wait to try the fried chicken and pot roast.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Menu has a lot of variety and all food offerings are delicious. Sandwiches are quite creative. Our favorites are French Dip and hot roasted turkey with Swiss on rye. The wait staff is absolutely charming and accommodating. Kyle our server was the bomb!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Breakfast was awesome today and affordable for the portion served.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It has been a few years since the last time I ate here. Not because I didn't have a great experience, rather it is a great distance from my home and regular rout of travel. My experience today lived up to what I can remember from my last visit.
My wife had their awesome mushroom soup! I had the French Dip. It looked so good that I forgot to take a picture. Lol.
It wasn't very busy when we stopped. However, it was around 2pm on a Thursday. Not many places are busy at that time.
The dining room was very neat, clean, and it had plenty of natural sunlight. The men's room was also very clean and well lit.
Our waitress was very nice and we enjoyed a lite conversation with her since she wasn't busy.
I would recommend this little restaurant. There were many good items on the lunch menue to choose from. I am sure that you'd find something that you like!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Although it may be small on the inside you'll get big time service, the staff outstanding, the food great, the bananas foster was delicious, prices good. If you're in the area you owe it to yourself to stop by, you won't be sorry.

Excellent service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

The ice cream was good and so was the service. The prices were a little high.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very pricey. The ice cream was good but a 10 dollar milk shake is high.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Ice cream is DELICIOUS