Cooked Goose Catering Company

7851 Steubenville Pike, Oakdale
(412) 258-5944

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Diane Hartman

Super happy with our wedding buffet food. Food arrived hot, on time , was well seasoned and portions very generous !!!

Mary Jo Weltner

I used Cooked Goose for my son's graduation party. The food was absolutely amazing! I can not say enough. Thank you very much!

Melissa Crump

We ordered food for 30 people and when we picked it up my husband said the fried chicken smelled burnt. We got the food to the party and the chicken was way over cooked so much so it was hard as a rock. The potatoes were under cooked and the pasta had no flavor whatsoever. I expected more for my almost 600 dollars. I will not be recommending this at all. We threw away 75% of all the leftovers. I’m not sure if they book too many pick ups on a Saturday but I’m sorry this was sub par. I’m am sick over this.

margaret wagner

If I could give this place a 10 star rating I would. I can’t say enough about Debbie and her expertise and professionalism. We called her with a tall order for our dad’s funeral wake. We were working against the clock trying to get catering for about 60 people in a day and a half. She gave us our options and we were just happy we found someone who could accommodate us on such short notice. We honestly weren’t expecting much at all. I’m sure you would all agree that planning your dad’s funeral in 2 days would be stressful. I can’t tell you how pleasantly surprised we were!! They delivered on time and the food was exceptionally good! Everyone there was commenting how good it was. We ordered chicken, roast beef,roasted potatoes and green beans and carrots. The roast beef just melted in your mouth. The potatoes were roasted with a coating on them and they were delicious. Thank you Cooked Goose for taking such a big burden away from us and helping us shine a little that day.

Rachel Danik

The food was good, but otherwise, we were disappointed with our experience with the Cooked Goose catering my baby shower. First, when I received the phone call from the delivery driver that he arrived at our venue, he was rude and short with me. I let that go after he left, but was surprised when the desserts were iced in “random” colors rather than colors that matched our theme. The cupcakes were iced in purple and yellow, and the brownies were iced in blue and pink. Our shower theme colors included greens and browns (woodland/camping theme). When I inquired about this, I was told that they were supposed to ask about our colors but they didn’t, so they chose whatever colors they wanted instead. Many guests agreed that there were not nearly enough desserts. The Cooked Goose told me after the fact that they allow 1 per person, which seems low to me, considering most catering companies allow more than 1 per person, especially when there are a variety of desserts. I will also note we only had 27 guests but I ordered enough food/desserts for 40 just to be safe, and we still ran out of desserts in a matter of minutes. The bottled water that was supposed to be included in our order (which I confirmed with The Cooked Goose) was forgotten, which led to a guest leaving my shower to pick up a case of water. The guests raved about the food being good, but for the cost of everything, and the reviews I’ve heard and read, I expected a lot better of an experience. To top it off, I tried to reach out to the company to resolve this issue and rather than being offered compensation for the order we already paid for, I was offered compensation toward a future order, which I don’t believe is fair considering the experience we had. I have no need or desire to spend more money with this catering company and be compensated for said future order. I believe the right thing to do is to compensate for what we already paid for. We didn’t receive the services we were promised. Sadly, I won’t be returning to the Cooked Goose or recommending them to family or friends and will share my experience with whoever asks.

Rachel Danik

The food was good, but otherwise, we were disappointed with our experience with the Cooked Goose catering my baby shower. First, when I received the phone call from the delivery driver that he arrived at our venue, he was rude and short with me. I let that go after he left, but was surprised when the desserts were iced in “random” colors rather than colors that matched our theme. The cupcakes were iced in purple and yellow, and the brownies were iced in blue and pink. Our shower theme colors included greens and browns (woodland/camping theme). When I inquired about this, I was told that they were supposed to ask about our colors but they didn’t, so they chose whatever colors they wanted instead. Many guests agreed that there were not nearly enough desserts. The Cooked Goose told me after the fact that they allow 1 per person, which seems low to me, considering most catering companies allow more than 1 per person, especially when there are a variety of desserts. I will also note we only had 27 guests but I ordered enough food/desserts for 40 just to be safe, and we still ran out of desserts in a matter of minutes. The bottled water that was supposed to be included in our order (which I confirmed with The Cooked Goose) was forgotten, which led to a guest leaving my shower to pick up a case of water. The guests raved about the food being good, but for the cost of everything, and the reviews I’ve heard and read, I expected a lot better of an experience. To top it off, I tried to reach out to the company to resolve this issue and rather than being offered compensation for the order we already paid for, I was offered compensation toward a future order, which I don’t believe is fair considering the experience we had. I have no need or desire to spend more money with this catering company and be compensated for said future order. I believe the right thing to do is to compensate for what we already paid for. We didn’t receive the services we were promised. Sadly, I won’t be returning to the Cooked Goose or recommending them to family or friends and will share my experience with whoever asks.

Angela Engram

Best food ever. Well cooked.

Diane McBane

Cooked Goose catered a surprise party for us. Food was great..everyone wanted to know where we got the food!!
Delivery guy was awesome also!

Nicole Ruckert

Cooked Goose Catering is by far one of my favorite places to order for my team. Working with Debbie on orders for the plant, they are accommodating and always provide the best food. We utilize them often because of the ease of ordering, flexibility and reliability. When you are a 24/7 operation, flexibility and understanding make our relationship work. Quality food is important for my team and they always provide.

J A

The Cooked Goose exceeded our expectations once again! Great food!

Evan Bookbinder

Cooked Goose provided catering to our band function last evening. Now I've gotten food from there to go for lunch a few times, but this was at a whole other level of excellence. Everyone raved about it. Roast beef and gravy I could eat every day of the week. The Mac and cheese was some of the best I ever had. Chicken breast, skinned potatoes, green beans, and super fresh rolls. Everything was top tier restaurant quality. Thanks again!

Donna Bowes

Just enjoyed the Thanksgiving box dinner for 2 that we purchased at Lu Lou’s. Delicious! Only wish reheating instructions were included.

Anna Ryniawec

Cooked Goose cater our son’s wedding. We had roast beef stuffed chicken breast, rigatoni, potatoes, carrots, salad. The Food was absolutely delicious. All the guest were raving how good the food was. There was a lot of out of town guests that attended.

James Devlin

Used to eat there at least twice a week. Then they stopped the fried chicken which was really good. The last five or six times I've tried to order this new girl always said they are out of fried chicken, is there a shortage? I don't know. Too bad I liked that place.

Steven Yurkovich

Cooked Goose Catering recently catered a large fundraising event for a local fallen warrior. I can't say enough about their service and how good the food was. I would recommend and will use them in the future.

Loading...