Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA

Exceptional service! ⭐️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

From the time I lived here in NEPA I finally got time to stop in to have a tray of their red pizza. I wish I never hesitated to go out of my way to here. The pizza definitely beat my expectations and these guys easily hold the heavy weight title for old forge pizza. Thank you for the excellent service as well!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Menu sticks to comforting classics with occasional surprises

Banquet. Great food. Pizza, chicken bites, pasta, roast beef. Only negative - Caesar salad was drowning in dressing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Arcaro and Genell are always worth the visit. Since childhood, I’ve remembered them as one of the pillars of Old Forge Pizza. The crust is fresh and flaky with every bite, and the cheese pulls you back in, piece by piece. The Limoncello Cake reminded me of home-style Limoncello by the shot 😜😁🙌 Don’t miss out on one of the best local pizzas around!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Got takeout pizza, it's very good.

Food: 5

Service: 5

chef can’t make a basic alfredo sauce, it was salty and curdled. italian hoagie was okay but every time we get take out from this place it’s been disappointing.

Great pizza. Great staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I can't speak on their pizza because I've never had that but I've ordered twice from here and both times were disappointing. The first time I ordered was the scallops with linguine and there was so much oil it was inedible. This time I got the chimpini with the white sauce, chicken fettuccine alfredo and clams casino. With the fettuccine, I'm not sure how you can mess up Alfredo sauce but it happened. With the chimpini the shrimp and lobster were extremely tough and everything tasted like it was spoiled including the clams casino. Something just tasted extremely off about everything. I spent a over $60 and we took a couple of bites of everything and threw it out. Also they said over the phone 25 minutes and got there and had to wait 20 minutes vefore it was ready. Everything was just so disappointing.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Came here with my dad back in the early 90's after a car auction down the road. Pizza was excellent.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Crust White

Good Old Forge red square pie. A&G soda is good too.

Amazing pizza, food, service and thing to do. Loved it all good

Love the sauce and cheese,and the crust is oh so PERFECT

Maybe a bad day...

First solid food my kid ever had was white pizza from here when I was working in the area and her mom brought her by to see me. Afterwards, we always made it a stop when we were in the area. 40 years later I stopped by on Easter after a funeral in Rochester. Mike was gracious enough to heat us up a half tray of double crust white to go. Still amazing Pizza! Like no other. You gotta stop here.