Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA

443 S Main St, Old Forge
(570) 457-5555

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

White Pizza with Tomatoes and Onion
Tray Red Thin Crust
Double Crust White
Homemade Tiramisu
Homemade Cannoli
Porketta Hoagie
Hot Sausage
Everything
Red Pizza
Cut

Menu

Pizza
Tray of Red Pizza
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Double-crust White Pizza
Order by 8-cut tray only. Our double-crust white pizza is two layers of crust stuffed with a blend of cheeses and topped with a mix of seasonings.
Single-crust White Pizza with Fresh Garlic and Onion
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our single-crust white pizza in old forge style with a light and airy crust topped with a blend of cheeses.
Tray of Red with Pepperoni
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Tray of Red with Meatball
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Single-crust White Pizza with Tomato, Fresh Garlic, and Onion
Tray of Red with Sausage
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Tray of Red with Mushrooms
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Tray of Red with Extra Cheese
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Tray of Red with Sweet Peppers
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Tray of Red with Hot Peppers
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Tray of Red with Mixed Peppers
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.
Tray of Red with Olives
Order by 12-cut tray only. Our red tray of pizza is an old forge style with a light and airy crust. Red sauce with a hint of onion and topped with a blend of cheeses.

Stromboli
Italian Stromboli (10")
Our homemade stromboli is stuffed with pepperoni, salami, and blended cheeses. Served with a side of homemade marinara sauce.
Soda (2 lt)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+26 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+25 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

From the time I lived here in NEPA I finally got time to stop in to have a tray of their red pizza. I wish I never hesitated to go out of my way to here. The pizza definitely beat my expectations and these guys easily hold the heavy weight title for old forge pizza. Thank you for the excellent service as well!
August 2025
Arcaro and Genell are always worth the visit. Since childhood, I’ve remembered them as one of the pillars of Old Forge Pizza. The crust is fresh and flaky with every bite, and the cheese pulls you back in, piece by piece. The Limoncello Cake reminded me of home-style Limoncello by the shot 😜😁🙌 Don’t miss out on one of the best local pizzas around!
August 2025
First solid food my kid ever had was white pizza from here when I was working in the area and her mom brought her by to see me. Afterwards, we always made it a stop when we were in the area. 40 years later I stopped by on Easter after a funeral in Rochester. Mike was gracious enough to heat us up a half tray of double crust white to go. Still amazing Pizza! Like no other. You gotta stop here.
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Revello's Pizza Cafe - 502 S Main St
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
Cusumano - 432 S Main St
Italian, American, Gluten-Free, New American, Vegetarian
Cafe Rinaldi - 426 S Main St
Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian

Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA

443 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518
(570) 457-5555