Cusumano
$$ • Italian, American, Gluten-Free
Hours:
432 S Main St, Old Forge
(570) 457-4166
About Cusumano
Customers' Favorites
Cusumano Reviews
Share your opinion about Cusumano
I probably should have checked this place out before I brought other people there. We were disappointed with the slow service, drinks left empty and they're nickel and diming every soda at 4.00 each, even refills. 12.00 for 4 panko coated clams was outrageous.The general consensus on the food was just so so. We probably won't be back.
Fathers Day…
I had a 4pm reservation. First they sat us at a picnic table at the back of the bbq pit. Which I could over look if this was the only issue. Near tall weeds and other things on the ground. Waited for service and after 40 minutes I had to go get a waitress myself. We ordered food and drinks at this point. Waitress seemed annoyed that we wanted to order everything at once. Unfortunately with a 1 year old we can only last so long. 30 more minutes go by and at this...read full review
I’d like to share my honest review of our experience yesterday for Fathers Day dinner.
Let’s start off with the good!
- the food was delicious!! Our entire table enjoyed all of their food!
- the overall vibe of the BBQ pit was so fun; live music, axe throwing, lots of fun outdoor games for guests to enjoy
- after some pretty awful service and some lip from the owner, the owner did make it right.
The bad-
- we started off waiting quite some time...read full review
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 5 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 5 - 9PM |
| Friday | 5 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 5 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 5 - 9PM |
People in Old Forge Also Viewed
Cusumano is a favorite among regulars, who visit multiple times a week. The staff is amazing and friendly, ensuring that visitors feel at home. The food is consistently amazing, with awesome portions and drinks. Guests have praised the cleanliness and beauty of the inside, and servers are always great. The atmosphere is lively, making it perfect for nights out with friends and meeting new people. Even on busy days, the attentive servers ensure a great experience. Guests have enjoyed a variety of dishes, from grandma's pizza to standout options like wild boar pappardelle and chicken parm. The restaurant offers a relaxed downstairs area with a friendly bartender who shares helpful information. The party food table features delicious options like gnocchi, three kinds of pizza, and a charcuterie board. The food is often praised for being very fresh, and prices are fair. Cusumano remains a must-visit for anyone looking for a fun night out with great food and drinks.