So disappointed, this used to be the best pizza ever but it’s gone so down hill. We gave Salerno’s THREE changes praying it was a bad day, but sad to say we’re done with this place. It was our family’s favorite pizza and it’s now gotten so bad we’ve had to throw it out, throwing our money in this economy isn’t feasible to anyone. The cheese is never cooked and it’s slimy and so gross, don’t know if they switched brands or what but it’s so sad.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
John Rivera
I arrived to this location with 13 individuals for lunch we waited a minute or five for service the waitress told the group that they were under staff. I asked for a menu and said separate check for me I didn’t split bills she copped an attitude about it and repeated that they were understaffed and that I should just split the bill. So I canceled my order and left the restaurant. It’s not the customer responsibility to staff the establishment . So one start is fitting for the service that I received.
Service: 1
shaun skursky
The wings were good the pizza not good...service was awesome
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
monte isom
The Old Forge style pizza here is a huge disappointment. The flavor simply falls flat. The sauce has no character, the cheese is chewy and dull but the crust was pretty good. Ordered red tray with pepperoni, onion, garlic and fresh tomato in addition to 4 cuts of red. My daughter announced after 1/2 a slice that the cheese was gross. I believe that to be an overstatement but when a pizza loving teen stops eating 1/2 way through 1 slice it tells you something. Love the old school bar and simple dining room. Compared to the vast options of Old Forge style pizza nearby this pizza was dead last between 6 places we tried in a week. I'd have a beer here but I'd skip the pizza. Woman taking the order was extremely nice and they are open on Monday (which most pizza places in Old Forge/Scranton are not).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
867aprila
Ordered a red and a white pizza. Neither were very hot. Very tasty. Great service. Very clean. Separate bar area from dining area. Parking out back.
Bill Peck
Take out pizza
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza
Eddie Wicks
1st time, pizza was a great OF style tray. As usual very simple place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza
SHARON K
Quaint old Tavern restaurant unchanged for decades, but that's the charm. You're coming here for the food. A lot of the pizza places in Old Forge have lost their "pizzazz "... many times because the owners died and didn't pass on the exact recipies. Not Salernos. Still moderately priced with great food and fast service. Since old Mary Gingerelli passed and took her perfect recipe for sofrito with her, this has become the next best in town. They also have one of the best square red pizzas around. Had mine half sausage. If you eat in house , they will provide you with hot seeds, oregano, and garlic powder. Besides the basic salt and pepper. They have several beers on tap and an array of basic wines. TV in the bar for its patrons. Got a tray of red half sausage and a dinner of sofrito and drinks for 43. And change. This the average person can afford.
Parking: Parking behind building and on surrounding streets.
Wheelchair accessibility: Go in the back way right in from the side.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks, Stromboli, Italian Sausage Sandwich Italian Bread and Long Hots with Provolone, Stuffed White Pizza, Antipasto Salad
Tom Buko
Great Old Forge style pizza!!! Light and airy crust and just amazing pizza!! Very nice people too. I get a tray whenever I travel through. Half Plaine half hot sausage pictured. Reheats really well to, 360F @ 6-7min in my air fryer is perfect!!
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza, Red Cuts
Nathan McGeever
Best, pierogies and burger I've had in a long time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Reynolds
Bartender was friendly she is pretty and great service we had pizza and drinks great job
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Slim
The waitress was great however my friend sent her food back twice and it still wasnt right. They did take it off the bill and offer to remake it but she decided not to
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Karissa Edwards
Great food ! Love the antipasto , ravioli , gnocchi , calamari & pizza
Great white pizza in Old Forge!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza
So disappointed, this used to be the best pizza ever but it’s gone so down hill. We gave Salerno’s THREE changes praying it was a bad day, but sad to say we’re done with this place. It was our family’s favorite pizza and it’s now gotten so bad we’ve had to throw it out, throwing our money in this economy isn’t feasible to anyone. The cheese is never cooked and it’s slimy and so gross, don’t know if they switched brands or what but it’s so sad.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
I arrived to this location with 13 individuals for lunch we waited a minute or five for service the waitress told the group that they were under staff. I asked for a menu and said separate check for me I didn’t split bills she copped an attitude about it and repeated that they were understaffed and that I should just split the bill. So I canceled my order and left the restaurant. It’s not the customer responsibility to staff the establishment . So one start is fitting for the service that I received.
Service: 1
The wings were good the pizza not good...service was awesome
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
The Old Forge style pizza here is a huge disappointment. The flavor simply falls flat. The sauce has no character, the cheese is chewy and dull but the crust was pretty good. Ordered red tray with pepperoni, onion, garlic and fresh tomato in addition to 4 cuts of red. My daughter announced after 1/2 a slice that the cheese was gross. I believe that to be an overstatement but when a pizza loving teen stops eating 1/2 way through 1 slice it tells you something. Love the old school bar and simple dining room. Compared to the vast options of Old Forge style pizza nearby this pizza was dead last between 6 places we tried in a week. I'd have a beer here but I'd skip the pizza. Woman taking the order was extremely nice and they are open on Monday (which most pizza places in Old Forge/Scranton are not).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Ordered a red and a white pizza. Neither were very hot. Very tasty. Great service. Very clean. Separate bar area from dining area. Parking out back.
Take out pizza
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza
1st time, pizza was a great OF style tray. As usual very simple place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza
Quaint old Tavern restaurant unchanged for decades, but that's the charm. You're coming here for the food. A lot of the pizza places in Old Forge have lost their "pizzazz "... many times because the owners died and didn't pass on the exact recipies. Not Salernos. Still moderately priced with great food and fast service. Since old Mary Gingerelli passed and took her perfect recipe for sofrito with her, this has become the next best in town.
They also have one of the best square red pizzas around. Had mine half sausage. If you eat in house , they will provide you with hot seeds, oregano, and garlic powder. Besides the basic salt and pepper. They have several beers on tap and an array of basic wines. TV in the bar for its patrons. Got a tray of red half sausage and a dinner of sofrito and drinks for 43. And change. This the average person can afford.
Parking: Parking behind building and on surrounding streets.
Wheelchair accessibility: Go in the back way right in from the side.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks, Stromboli, Italian Sausage Sandwich Italian Bread and Long Hots with Provolone, Stuffed White Pizza, Antipasto Salad
Great Old Forge style pizza!!! Light and airy crust and just amazing pizza!! Very nice people too. I get a tray whenever I travel through. Half Plaine half hot sausage pictured. Reheats really well to, 360F @ 6-7min in my air fryer is perfect!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Style Pizza, Red Cuts
Best, pierogies and burger I've had in a long time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bartender was friendly she is pretty and great service we had pizza and drinks great job
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The waitress was great however my friend sent her food back twice and it still wasnt right. They did take it off the bill and offer to remake it but she decided not to
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Great food ! Love the antipasto , ravioli , gnocchi , calamari & pizza
Loading...