Waited 20 minutes for no service. Can not seem to keep servers. Old guy tough on the help. Not worth any stars.
mike d
Although it's just another pizza place in stature. The people are always really nice, iam getting to know them better.It's the food the sandwiches are great ,the bread is tasty,soft,and wonderful for sandwich, the meats are always a good amount and have good flavor. The pizza is pretty good to and works great for lunch the next day. Stromboli was good to. We usually order once a week haven't been disappointed yet, good meals every time
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Blaine Newkirk
Typical Pizza shop menu but at a better price point than the other 2 local places in Oley, and I would have to say better food than the other 2 in the area as well. I was in the pizza business for a very long time before retiring within the last year and would consider myself a pizza snob and at Bella Italia the slices of pizza are gigantic not saying they stand out for the taste because they all pretty much all make the dough and get the ingredients from the same suppliers ... it's the sauce and blend of cheese that makes one from another stand out, but you do get a bigger and better sandwich at Bella. I drive a half hour to get their sandwiches so that should speak for itself.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Steak, Cheese Steak
Zachary Gieringer
It’s a shame, I moved back to Oley in 2018 with my family and we would eat here in the summer time once sometimes twice a week, it would be fair to say they had some of the best pizza and sandwiches in town. Unfortunately over the last few years the business has declined dramatically, primarily in the most important facet, the food. I’m no one but it really upsets me how much this place has declined, the “facelift” or new front desk is merely a facade of what’s going on behind it. This is the 4th time I’ve ordered food there and it turn out downright awful, two times in a row we’ve ordered cheesesteaks that were the literal opposite of requested order, the bread was chewy and was easily a few days old, the fries cold and undercooked and the cheese sauce was literally sour. My last and final attempt was this evening and to no avail was a terrible experience yet again, simple order, well done pizza half veggie half pepperoni, the pepperoni was fine but the veggie aspect was terrible, they literally took raw uncooked veggies, broccoli stems, put them on the pizza and barely cooked it, the veggies were cold and so was the cheese they tried to camouflage the pizza with, not to mention the base of the pizza was mush and literally fell apart. I’m incredibly disappointed and dismayed with the unsettling reality that this establishment is in the state it’s in. I hope they turn it around for their future but I will never return. Time to go back to MM or give Zolas a try!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Heather Williamson
Just stopped in on a quick hungry whim. Excellent choice!!! My husband and I both ordered a slice and a small sub. The people were super friendly and even told us how to make our order a little cheaper. When the slices came out (his a plain slice & mine buffalo chicken stuffed slice) they were humongous!!!!! I've had entire pizzas that were smaller than them! They were each only $3.75 a slice. My slice was an entire meal. I could only take a single bit of my tuna sub just to see how it was. It was very good also. My husband managed to eat his slice and half his sub. He said it was the BEST meatball sub he thinks he has ever had. Put it this way, I don't leave reviews normally, but as soon as we got into the car, I looked at how to leave one. If you get the chance and you are close, stop in. It's worth the stop! A++++ (I wish I would have taken a picture of the slices before we devoured them!!!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patel Parikshit
Love your pizza...... ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric
I agree with the recent comments there pizza should be 5$ there worst then lil ceasers ?
Food: 1
No Bueno
They got horrible pizza nia’s is way better ?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Trill riv
There pizza sucks!
mdelligatti78
I called and placed an order for a 16 inch mushroom pepperoni and onion pie. When I got home I noticed that I had multiple different sizes of cuts like it was rushed. I said something to the girl who answered the phone and had a serious attitude with me. I will never order there again. Very sloppy pizza.
Waited 20 minutes for no service. Can not seem to keep servers. Old guy tough on the help. Not worth any stars.
Although it's just another pizza place in stature. The people are always really nice, iam getting to know them better.It's the food the sandwiches are great ,the bread is tasty,soft,and wonderful for sandwich, the meats are always a good amount and have good flavor. The pizza is pretty good to and works great for lunch the next day. Stromboli was good to. We usually order once a week haven't been disappointed yet, good meals every time
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Typical Pizza shop menu but at a better price point than the other 2 local places in Oley, and I would have to say better food than the other 2 in the area as well. I was in the pizza business for a very long time before retiring within the last year and would consider myself a pizza snob and at Bella Italia the slices of pizza are gigantic not saying they stand out for the taste because they all pretty much all make the dough and get the ingredients from the same suppliers ... it's the sauce and blend of cheese that makes one from another stand out, but you do get a bigger and better sandwich at Bella. I drive a half hour to get their sandwiches so that should speak for itself.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Steak, Cheese Steak
It’s a shame, I moved back to Oley in 2018 with my family and we would eat here in the summer time once sometimes twice a week, it would be fair to say they had some of the best pizza and sandwiches in town. Unfortunately over the last few years the business has declined dramatically, primarily in the most important facet, the food. I’m no one but it really upsets me how much this place has declined, the “facelift” or new front desk is merely a facade of what’s going on behind it. This is the 4th time I’ve ordered food there and it turn out downright awful, two times in a row we’ve ordered cheesesteaks that were the literal opposite of requested order, the bread was chewy and was easily a few days old, the fries cold and undercooked and the cheese sauce was literally sour. My last and final attempt was this evening and to no avail was a terrible experience yet again, simple order, well done pizza half veggie half pepperoni, the pepperoni was fine but the veggie aspect was terrible, they literally took raw uncooked veggies, broccoli stems, put them on the pizza and barely cooked it, the veggies were cold and so was the cheese they tried to camouflage the pizza with, not to mention the base of the pizza was mush and literally fell apart. I’m incredibly disappointed and dismayed with the unsettling reality that this establishment is in the state it’s in. I hope they turn it around for their future but I will never return. Time to go back to MM or give Zolas a try!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Just stopped in on a quick hungry whim. Excellent choice!!! My husband and I both ordered a slice and a small sub. The people were super friendly and even told us how to make our order a little cheaper. When the slices came out (his a plain slice & mine buffalo chicken stuffed slice) they were humongous!!!!! I've had entire pizzas that were smaller than them! They were each only $3.75 a slice. My slice was an entire meal. I could only take a single bit of my tuna sub just to see how it was. It was very good also. My husband managed to eat his slice and half his sub. He said it was the BEST meatball sub he thinks he has ever had. Put it this way, I don't leave reviews normally, but as soon as we got into the car, I looked at how to leave one. If you get the chance and you are close, stop in. It's worth the stop! A++++ (I wish I would have taken a picture of the slices before we devoured them!!!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love your pizza...... ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I agree with the recent comments there pizza should be 5$ there worst then lil ceasers ?
Food: 1
They got horrible pizza nia’s is way better ?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
There pizza sucks!
I called and placed an order for a 16 inch mushroom pepperoni and onion pie. When I got home I noticed that I had multiple different sizes of cuts like it was rushed. I said something to the girl who answered the phone and had a serious attitude with me. I will never order there again. Very sloppy pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place to get food. Hospitality is top notch even though I only order for pick up.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Pepperoni Pizza
Great menu, quick and timely service, and friendly staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bella Italia pizza puts big city pizza to shame. Cozy and friendly. Truly a hidden gem.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
The stuffed pizza was to die for! We added in sausage and black olives. Pizza for days!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5