Felicia Fisher's Black Buggy Baking Company
1839 Memorial Hwy, Oley
(610) 914-9090
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Best Shoo Fly pie!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love her delicious pies!! Especially Shoo-fly pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Her home cooking as well as her baking is delicious. Her presentation along with a large menu of food is amazing. Just came from one of her catered parties & everyone commented on how good the food was! Have enjoyed her baking for years!!
The best wet bottom shoofly pie I’ve ever had - you won’t be disappointed?
I hate to give a bad reviewI have been buying these pie’ a here for at least 10 years and bought one yesterday and it is totally differentWhat happenedDid you change the recipe?It was terribleWas not like anything I remember
Best Shoefly pie in the world! Taking a bunch back to FL with me! Everything they make is fantastic!
Homemade chocolate pie from top to bottom (no whipped cream) made especially for my husband as a surprise 🙂 He said it is the best he has ever had and he wouldn’t let me have a bite 😏😑😒
Her custom cakes are awesome
The very very BEST TASTING ZUCCHINI BREAD you will ever eat, the flavor is out of this world, ??? 3 thumbs up and then some ?
The most delicious pies and cookies in all the land. Always sad when Felicia goes in pie-atus.
Restaurantji Recommends
I'm 54 years old and can tell you with out a doubt their shoo fly pie is the best I have ever had. I have had them from Lancaster area and they don't even compare. Can't wait to try the other pies next year.
Felicia, Great presentation last night with Women 2 Women. Wanted to tell you how many quick trips I've made to the West Reading market so my grand daughter can have one of your sugar cookies and of course, so I can get corn, potatoes and more. Also frequent the Oley farm when I m in that area. Good friends of mine are Pam & Tom Kopel. Have good winter break. Sandy Witman
We just got our first ever peach pie!!! It's so delicious!!! Will defiantly be getting more!!!
We just had the best... most amazingly delicious coconut custard pie ever !! Thank you for making us one Felicia
Felicia did an AMAZING job creating a signature cookie for us to use as part of our sweets bar at our wedding. She went above and beyond to work with us for a custom recipe that was sure to please all. AND IT DID!! People were/are raving about these delectable creations. We had people traveling from states away who are looking for us to visit Black Buggy throughout the upcoming seasons and ship them her delicious items! Thank you!!
Loading...