Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop

THIS PLACE DID NOT USE GLOVES I IMMEDIATELY ASKED FOR MY MONEY BACK, THIS IS STRAIGHT UP NASTY!!!!!!

THIS PLACE DO NOT USED GLOVES, THIS IS A FOOD HAZZARD!!!!

They illegally charge a dollar for any debit card/credit transactions. No gloves. The girl at the front was nice but I had to wait for my order even tho it was ready because she had to answer phones and show some dude how to heat up a slice of pizza.
I got the small pizza, do not get scammed into paying extra for toppings I got 8 slices of pepperoni, which is about 2/shov slice, this is basically cheese pizza.
I got half italian hoagie which is the only reason I have 3 stars is cause I’ve had it before and it’s not bad.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

I was very impressed with this place. The taste of the pizza reminded me of NY slices. It wasn't too greasy and the crust was just as good as the rest of the pizza. The chicken was good as well. Cooked to perfection. Great customer service and fair prices. I will be back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best family pizza restaurant in the area! The staff is warm and welcoming, greet you with a smile, and work quickly to prepare your order. I was surprised at how quickly my order was ready. The Greek pizza with white sauce is the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’m going to add chicken to it next time and then I’m certain I’ll have same praise for that pizza. I have some super picky kids and one of them said “I can actually eat the crust of this pizza because it’s soft and chewy”. Truly, this could very well be the perfect pizza. I’m impressed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delivery was efficient. Thank you Joe for the hospitality on Wednesday 5-27-25
The food was good and fresh

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hoagies are 🔥

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This pizza place is small and almost hidden. I would describe this place as a hidden gem of Penn Hills.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious pizza all around. The buffalo chicken pizza is amazing. Prices are super reasonable too. They handle large orders very well. I've ordered 10 extra larges for parties and they got everything right and had it done super fast.

I had a take out medium pizza. If you read my reviews, you know I like thick best. It wasn't thick, but the service was good and the chocolate chip cookies were good as well.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Kudos to whoever the cook is! I’ve had the best bbq chicken pizza I’ve ever eaten here. The mild wings with the sauce are amazing as well. Very satisfied.

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken

Finally, some good freaking food.
I got the steak hoagie 6 inch and my wife got the Italian stromboli.
My regret was that I didn't get the large hoagie.
I can't wait to try more on their menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian

I ordered a Steak salad with extra meat chicken. I was very specific about NO RAW ONIONS. The onions had to be grilled. My salad was delivered and guess what? RAW ONIONS! I got in my car and took the salad back to them to show them that they didn’t do what I asked. The woman that made the salad put her hand in the salad and said “ there you go, no raw onions” and threw the onions in the garbage. I told them to refund my money and they lost a good customer. Learn how to treat your customers especially the ones that give good tips to the drivers.

Eat in or delivery always fresh and hot

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always been good food I love the cheese steak hoagies and peperoni sausage pizza

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza