One of the best pizzas I have ever eaten. I have been eating here since the late '80s. Always consistent, always delicious.
Parking: More than the location can handle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
David lacivita
Some of the best pizza I have ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacki Murphy
Absolutely the greatest owner and staff. THE best pizza and hoagies. so worth the visit!
Samuel C. Severino
Best pizza around ! They have reprised the Mom’s recipe and it is delicious . Only open Thursday,Friday and Saturday .
Food: 5
Mikie Toomey
Love the pizza. Very friendly atmosphere.
Kelsey Braun
THE BEST Sicilian pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Meadows
Wow can I say how highly mad/disappointed I am!!, For so many years since a kid i have heard Caputo's in Pitcairn was amazing the best, these people who stated also where being taken there young.So I've had this anticipation built up for years and the stories since, because they are only open two days for couple hours, I haven't had the time to try, and because of that reason I thought even better, it's gonna be deliciousWell tonight was IT we are finally trying and so very thrilled to do so....It's definitely very disappointing,My kids(2-15) years old who would prefer to order or make pizza every other night didn't like it and wouldn't finish it,????♀️Definitely mediocre at best, sorry
NoName 1234
To get started it was alright, the crust tasted as if it was stall bread. The wife did not enjoy the pizza. I on the other hand found it to be alright
Chris Bianco
I was so excited to try the pizza cause I've heard nothing but good things about it. I finally got a chance to try it and it was the worst pizza I've ever had. Had it not been for how hard the struggle is right now I would have thrown the pizza in the trash. It's so bland!!! There is literally no taste to it at all. I'm usually all for supporting family from business over a corporate owned business but in this case ill take a pizza but or dominos pizza over this
Clay Cova
This place is a Pitcairn Institution! Family owned forever. Pizza and Sammie’s are the best!
One of the best pizzas I have ever eaten. I have been eating here since the late '80s. Always consistent, always delicious.
Parking: More than the location can handle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Some of the best pizza I have ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely the greatest owner and staff. THE best pizza and hoagies. so worth the visit!
Best pizza around ! They have reprised the Mom’s recipe and it is delicious . Only open Thursday,Friday and Saturday .
Food: 5
Love the pizza. Very friendly atmosphere.
THE BEST Sicilian pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow can I say how highly mad/disappointed I am!!, For so many years since a kid i have heard Caputo's in Pitcairn was amazing the best, these people who stated also where being taken there young.So I've had this anticipation built up for years and the stories since, because they are only open two days for couple hours, I haven't had the time to try, and because of that reason I thought even better, it's gonna be deliciousWell tonight was IT we are finally trying and so very thrilled to do so....It's definitely very disappointing,My kids(2-15) years old who would prefer to order or make pizza every other night didn't like it and wouldn't finish it,????♀️Definitely mediocre at best, sorry
To get started it was alright, the crust tasted as if it was stall bread. The wife did not enjoy the pizza. I on the other hand found it to be alright
I was so excited to try the pizza cause I've heard nothing but good things about it. I finally got a chance to try it and it was the worst pizza I've ever had. Had it not been for how hard the struggle is right now I would have thrown the pizza in the trash. It's so bland!!! There is literally no taste to it at all. I'm usually all for supporting family from business over a corporate owned business but in this case ill take a pizza but or dominos pizza over this
This place is a Pitcairn Institution! Family owned forever. Pizza and Sammie’s are the best!
Restaurantji Recommends
Something old time and quaint about this place that is hard to find anymore. Find the time to visit when you can.
Great Pizza and salad!!
Pizza was on point. They nailed it. I was a little skeptical about it. I am impressed by it. Marvelous job.
Great hoagies, somewhat of a true legend in Pitcairn.
Love the Italian Hoagie and Pizza with Meatballs!
Loading...