21 Best Bakeries near Plains

“Stopped in this afternoon and got a pastry pretzel. Sooooo good! They had so much to choose from!“

“Nicely decorated and comfortable. Some of the best pizza and baked goods I’ve ever had. 👍💯“

“We’ve utilized Black Cat Bakery for birthday cakes in the past, and each time they are absolutely stunning as well as delicious; but we were even more blown away by how absolutely perfect our wedding cake was this May. My husband and I were treated so well for our cake tasting in the months prior to the wedding, and the flavor combinations are as always, incredible. I trusted Madison to design a cake that matched our theme after choosing our flavors (this is HER art!), and she completely nailed it! It actually made me tear up how perfect it was. Our guests had nothing but compliments on both the design and flavor of our cake, and I’m already looking forward to eating it again for our first anniversary even if it risks being freezer burned 😆 You can tell that the staff here really loves what they do, and they put their hearts into their desserts and creations. Thank you so much!“

“This was the best food I ever had ! Sweet fall chicken sandwich and autumn harvest salad ! Fast pleasant service“

“I needed a cake very last minute and they were so kind to help me out even though I know they were very busy! Great customer service and I will be definitely be back again for future parties. Not only did my 6 year old get the cake he wanted for his birthday, but it tasted and looked amazing too! Thank you!“

“I got my usual Sunday morning takeout shortly after 10am on 9/14. I could tell as soon as I looked at my meal that it was skillfully prepared by someone who cared. I had the Eggs Benedict from the senior menu, and it was done to perfection. I enjoyed every bite. Kudos to the chef on duty. I appreciate and acknowledge your effort. The staff is friendly and knows me by name, making me feel special. 5 stars to you all!“

“Sugar craze is the best place i go their every time its open and buy whatever i can its so good i think you all would enjoy it to.“

“By far the best cheesecakes I have ever tried!! My favorites are the Tandy Cake & Tuxedo. 😍 if you haven’t already I highly recommend trying these!“

“Susan at the front porch bake shop does ABSOLUTELY phenomenal work! We were having a lot of difficulty finding a reliable shop to make cupcakes and our wedding cake. From start to finish, Susan was responsive and willing to work with us to make our wedding sweets exactly what we wanted! From the most exclusive tasting we had, to making cake pops for our shower favors, to making “getting ready trays” for our morning of, to the best tasting cake and cupcakes we could’ve asked for, the front porch bake shop delivered on every aspect! Absolutely consider them for your next event!“

“Best Place To Get Cookies, Cakes, Pastries And More. My Mom Use To Take Us Here All The Time When We Were Kids. Can't Wait To Have More Soon.“

“I'm from Staten Island N.Y., and I'm 56 years old. My wife and I moved to Old Forge Pennsylvania on Monday October 16th, 2023.
I've been a milk route truck driver, a Sanitation worker for NYC, and a Commercial Sanitation Route driver; I had many Straight Truck, Air Brakes, CDL Driving jobs ew my life including dump trucks. I KNOW NYC.
I had apartments in Brooklyn as well as Staten Island. I worked in every Borough including Yonkers, Westchester County, and many parts of New Jersey, where I also had quite a few apartments over the years.
My point?
Being Italian/American and submerged in the heritages culture, I'm VERY familiar with GENUINELY AUTHENTIC Italian Breads; and BOTH the right and wrong types of baking them.
Agostini's Bread?
PHENOMENAL!!!
I was shocked at the old fashioned authentic LOOK, TEXTURE, and TERRIFIC TASTE, of the Two different large loaves that I bought:
Sesame Seeded Twisted loaf; AND, a Dark Brown loaf of Russian Rye bread.
Both, EXCELLENT!
I met Rita in the store front and it was like stepping into Cammerieri's Bakery from the Movie ? "MoonStruck ."
Or Addeo's Bakery in the Bronx.
This 100 year old plus business was purchased by Rita and her husband 2 years ago. They are carrying on the tradition of superior Italian bread and more, and they are carrying the TORCH.
I dipped a piece of that Twisted loaf into Extra Virgin Olive oil that was sprinkled with Cracked Black pepper and Cracked Sea Salt, and was drizzled over Fresh Homemade Mozzarella topped with Garden Basil leaves and Juicy Grape Tomatoes. The Bread was DIVINE!
Dinner was served with a Barbecued Cheese and Parsley Sausage Ring from Staten Island N.Y., with Homemade Red and Yellow Roasted Bell Peppers, and Green Poblano Roasted Peppers marinating in Olive oil and garden parsley and slices of Raw Garlic cloves.
Along with a homemade Pesto my wife makes to perfection, Agostini Bread was a perfect accompaniment to our dinner table. Some home made Sangria and our table was furnished with all of the BEST!
Thank you, Agostini Bakery!
You have a new permanent patron; ME!
GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY, ✝?????✝“

“I love the pizza that they sell.“

“You probably never knew this place existed and have driven past this place countless times. The baker takes great pride in his fresh mexican pastries, breads, and delicacies. Are you in the mood for a breakfast sandwich or some tacos for lunch ? Nothing is as delicious as fresh baked goods, so you will not be disappointed. A small whole in the wall with great service and pride.“

“Recently visited the Royal Bake Shop , as I used to live in Exeter and was in town from FL for a wedding. The lady behind the counter was very friendly and informative. Learned they shipped to my area, thank you. Bought a nut roll and prune roll , cookies and a blueberry muffin, all were fantastic.“

“They go Above & Beyond to make there customers happy . The food is Amazing & the Baked Goods are Just out of this world ! We Literally Can’t imagine having to go Anywhere else for Any of our Cakes etc.“

“Very nice local option for your bakery needs! I had ordered my wedding cake from Imelda and she was very friendly and the cake was exactly what I wanted! Instead of freezing a piece of the original I asked for a mini version of the wedding cake for my husband and I’s anniversary which was well priced and tasted exactly the same.“

“Bagel Art Bakery has the best bagels ever!! Just had one of their pizza bagels and they tasted delicious!! Fast service and great employees!“

“I saw a lady really going at this worker. She was verbally abusing the employee. I have never had a problem with the employees at this location. They have always been extremely friendly and helpful. We all have off days, and there is no excuse to lash out at other people like this woman. I was behind her when everything happened and I saw a review from earlier, and I was the one that walked away because I was extremely uncomfortable with the confrontation that this woman caused. Again, I hope for the best for this employee.“

“The best poppyseed and nut roll. Hands down. The best everything.“