we were talking about this today and we both felt the same way..still VERY ANGRY .. when we go back to the Poconos in 2026 we will DEFINITELY seek another pizza spot... DISREGARD THAT $1-$20 NONSENSE..NOT POSSIBLE NOT @ EVEN 1 cheesesteak & 1 single drink for 2 !! $50 to $100 minimum unless you get a solo plain pie& share a drink perhaps !! WOW!! prices really went up over the past couple of years.. 2 drinks, 1 half & half large pizza & 8 wings will set ya back $60 now ... that is some serious coin for comfort food even if it is some of the best on the plateau.. I can not recommend this place anymore for eat in dining .. it seems that they are now banging eat in customers for as much as 40% more than online take out orders.. check their webpage .. a flat out a rip job at $22 for 12 wings . i got 8 at $15 which weren't that good , over dry and with not much meat ..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Christopher Wanko
I love coming here. Tap beer and pizza and occasionally they have a game on the TV. Very relaxed atmosphere. Pizza, hot sandwiches stand out here. I'd pass on the obligatory chicken fingers and just do wings and fries. VERY kid friendly mini arcade attached.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Karen Ryan
Very good PA pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Olivia Gutmann
Undercooked pizza! We paid around $45 for a Sicilian pizza with 2 toppings only to bring it home and it not be edible because the dough was still RAW.
dorothy hodge
Price went up but Pizza quality did NOT. Sausage was ground not whole & sliced. I have paid less for a pizza with full topping (not 1/2 like this one) on Long Island! Definitely will not be going back to this place!
Food: 3
Service: 4
Steven Glatts
Awesome pizza and hot wings
Food: 5
Bill Poutre
We got pizza for the first time here last night. It was very good and the staff couldn’t have been nicer. The sauce is very tasty, with a touch of sweetness in the overall savory flavor. The pizza had a good proportion of cheese to sauce … just the right amount in my opinion. I enjoy a pizza where the cheese fully covers the sauce but doesn’t overwhelm it.
The crust was also really good. It is a little fluffier than a typical NJ or NY pie, but it was nicely crispy and very flavorful.
There was a minor mishap with ordering through Slice. For some reason the ticket wasn’t produced , but they quickly got the order out to me once I got there. I think in the future I will just call them directly. I like the convenience of paying through the app, but I think it’s easier to just deal directly with the shop.
I’m glad to see a really good pizza place in that spot again!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Arjun Mouron
Decided to order in because of the good reviews and the recommendations of our airbnb's host. We ordered 1 cheese pie and 1 veggie pie. Both were way too doughy. The dough itself was also dense and chewy, probably underproved. Pizza should not have that thick of an undercarriage. Nobody in my family wants the leftovers. To be fair it was a Friday and maybe the dine in experience is better. But in our eyes, DEFINITELY not worth $53.
Best pizza in the poconos! Comes out hot and fresh, cooked to perfection. We stayed here this week and came twice because we loved the pizza so much! Game room was a good time for our kids after and staff was very nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Wright
We ordered take out. My family enjoyed the pizza. Ordering on the app was easy and the pizza was ready when they said it would be.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jeffr Wall
small gluten pizza and an anti pasta for $50
Mark Evaldi
Your daughter makes a kick ass pile of Stromboli
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Todd Litke
Exceptional service really good cheesesteaks with an absolutely delicious sauce. The lady at the counter is super friendly and very personable I highly recommend you give this place a shot if you're up this way
we were talking about this today and we both felt the same way..still VERY ANGRY .. when we go back to the Poconos in 2026 we will DEFINITELY seek another pizza spot... DISREGARD THAT $1-$20 NONSENSE..NOT POSSIBLE NOT @ EVEN 1 cheesesteak & 1 single drink for 2 !! $50 to $100 minimum unless you get a solo plain pie& share a drink perhaps !!
WOW!! prices really went up over the past couple of years.. 2 drinks, 1 half & half large pizza & 8 wings will set ya back $60 now ... that is some serious coin for comfort food even if it is some of the best on the plateau.. I can not recommend this place anymore for eat in dining
.. it seems that they are now banging eat in customers for as much as 40% more than online take out orders.. check their webpage .. a flat out a rip job at $22 for 12 wings . i got 8 at $15 which weren't that good , over dry and with not much meat ..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
I love coming here. Tap beer and pizza and occasionally they have a game on the TV. Very relaxed atmosphere. Pizza, hot sandwiches stand out here. I'd pass on the obligatory chicken fingers and just do wings and fries. VERY kid friendly mini arcade attached.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Very good PA pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Undercooked pizza! We paid around $45 for a Sicilian pizza with 2 toppings only to bring it home and it not be edible because the dough was still RAW.
Price went up but Pizza quality did NOT. Sausage was ground not whole & sliced. I have paid less for a pizza with full topping (not 1/2 like this one) on Long Island! Definitely will not be going back to this place!
Food: 3
Service: 4
Awesome pizza and hot wings
Food: 5
We got pizza for the first time here last night. It was very good and the staff couldn’t have been nicer. The sauce is very tasty, with a touch of sweetness in the overall savory flavor. The pizza had a good proportion of cheese to sauce … just the right amount in my opinion. I enjoy a pizza where the cheese fully covers the sauce but doesn’t overwhelm it.
The crust was also really good. It is a little fluffier than a typical NJ or NY pie, but it was nicely crispy and very flavorful.
There was a minor mishap with ordering through Slice. For some reason the ticket wasn’t produced , but they quickly got the order out to me once I got there. I think in the future I will just call them directly. I like the convenience of paying through the app, but I think it’s easier to just deal directly with the shop.
I’m glad to see a really good pizza place in that spot again!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Decided to order in because of the good reviews and the recommendations of our airbnb's host. We ordered 1 cheese pie and 1 veggie pie. Both were way too doughy. The dough itself was also dense and chewy, probably underproved. Pizza should not have that thick of an undercarriage. Nobody in my family wants the leftovers. To be fair it was a Friday and maybe the dine in experience is better. But in our eyes, DEFINITELY not worth $53.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great Pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice pizza 🍕
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza in the poconos! Comes out hot and fresh, cooked to perfection. We stayed here this week and came twice because we loved the pizza so much! Game room was a good time for our kids after and staff was very nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered take out. My family enjoyed the pizza. Ordering on the app was easy and the pizza was ready when they said it would be.
Food: 4
Service: 4
small gluten pizza and an anti pasta for $50
Your daughter makes a kick ass pile of Stromboli
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Exceptional service really good cheesesteaks with an absolutely delicious sauce. The lady at the counter is super friendly and very personable I highly recommend you give this place a shot if you're up this way
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...