I have gone here for a couple years and every time I go there they have pretty good food, service, and a great atmosphere. This restaurant is a great place to eat food there and even take food home to eat. Every time I have gone there I get pizza or spaghetti with meatballs. Both of these meals are very good but could be a tad bit better. If your reading this and haven't gone to Brothers Pizza I would say that you should go. I think that you should get a plane pizza with sausage or spaghetti with meatballs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Luke Lorenz
For a small town pizza place, this is just the bomb.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jack Harris
The young girl that waited on us never came back the 2nd time to see how things were . She talked to her friend too much . Food was O K however I will stick to downtown Port Matilda . Not that much out of the way .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Michael S.
Great food and great owners. They take pride in their business and always a pleasure talking to them. Our go to place on Friday night
Mildred Feliz
Delicious gluten free pizza and saladGood service.
Jonathan H.
Consistent product, good service. I know what I will get when I order from this pizzeria, and most importantly, my kids like their pizza and they are close to us.
Ann Brown
The interior is absolutely beautiful- very roomy yet cozy, the staff was very friendly and the pizzas were great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sam
We stopped today and purchased two slices of pizza a chef salad and an antipasto salad the salads came with garlic bread .I am only giving a two star review because they were the worst salads we have had in a while. For $13.00 each I was expecting some meat and cheese on the salad but the meat was sparse and I never saw an antipasto salad made the way mine was .One and done. I wondered why it wasn’t busy. ??
Jason Hart
My men and I are working close to this restaurant. So on our first day we stopped after work to order a pizza for the long ride home. They told us 20 - 25 minute wait. 45 minutes later and still no pizza. I asked for my money back and she gave me $26 dollars back on a pizza that cost me $38 bucks that I didn't even get. Crooks! Very poor management. These people do not care about there walk in customers. They are all about takeout. My guys and I planned on eating lunch here for the next 3 or 4 weeks. We will be packing are lunches. Inflation at it's finest.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jackie Kimberling
Apparently it takes an hour to make a pizza. Very disappointed in this establishment! They also don't give you the correct amount of money back, that you paid. I agree with the other review on here, save yourself the hassle and go somewhere else.
I ate there last night, the food is great a little expensive but good.
Alesia Detwiler
Hands down the BEST cheesesteak I’ve ever had! The bread is so soft and the portions are awesome! I got the cinnamon sticks for dessert and the icing it came with was to die for. Everyone there was so nice and extremely welcoming to me as a first time customer. I would highly recommend!!!
Dave DeCapria
Good food, Live music on Friday evenings (weather permitting) nice crowd of Locals.
I have gone here for a couple years and every time I go there they have pretty good food, service, and a great atmosphere. This restaurant is a great place to eat food there and even take food home to eat. Every time I have gone there I get pizza or spaghetti with meatballs. Both of these meals are very good but could be a tad bit better. If your reading this and haven't gone to Brothers Pizza I would say that you should go. I think that you should get a plane pizza with sausage or spaghetti with meatballs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
For a small town pizza place, this is just the bomb.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The young girl that waited on us never came back the 2nd time to see how things were . She talked to her friend too much . Food was O K however I will stick to downtown Port Matilda . Not that much out of the way .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Great food and great owners. They take pride in their business and always a pleasure talking to them. Our go to place on Friday night
Delicious gluten free pizza and saladGood service.
Consistent product, good service. I know what I will get when I order from this pizzeria, and most importantly, my kids like their pizza and they are close to us.
The interior is absolutely beautiful- very roomy yet cozy, the staff was very friendly and the pizzas were great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped today and purchased two slices of pizza a chef salad and an antipasto salad the salads came with garlic bread .I am only giving a two star review because they were the worst salads we have had in a while. For $13.00 each I was expecting some meat and cheese on the salad but the meat was sparse and I never saw an antipasto salad made the way mine was .One and done. I wondered why it wasn’t busy. ??
My men and I are working close to this restaurant. So on our first day we stopped after work to order a pizza for the long ride home. They told us 20 - 25 minute wait. 45 minutes later and still no pizza. I asked for my money back and she gave me $26 dollars back on a pizza that cost me $38 bucks that I didn't even get. Crooks! Very poor management. These people do not care about there walk in customers. They are all about takeout. My guys and I planned on eating lunch here for the next 3 or 4 weeks. We will be packing are lunches. Inflation at it's finest.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Apparently it takes an hour to make a pizza. Very disappointed in this establishment! They also don't give you the correct amount of money back, that you paid. I agree with the other review on here, save yourself the hassle and go somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food! Love the staff
Fast pickup & tasty food!
I ate there last night, the food is great a little expensive but good.
Hands down the BEST cheesesteak I’ve ever had! The bread is so soft and the portions are awesome! I got the cinnamon sticks for dessert and the icing it came with was to die for. Everyone there was so nice and extremely welcoming to me as a first time customer. I would highly recommend!!!
Good food, Live music on Friday evenings (weather permitting) nice crowd of Locals.