Honey Creek Inn

4698 Old US Hwy 322, Reedsville
(717) 667-2314

Recent Reviews

meredith rogers

Food is decentWait is crazy and act like it is customers fault when something goes wrong,"you can see how busy we are"!Pass an go anywhere else food is just not worth the wait

Tim Rogers

WILL NEVER COME BACK Second time this has happened to us in past three months.This was our "go-to" breakfast place for many years, but they've taken a nose dive in recent years. Today was our last visit EVER.*The highlights: waited 40 minutes for our food, there were two of us.*Three tables around us, all came in long after us, were served before us.*We asked if we were forgotten, since the waitress never bothered to check on us.*No coffee refill, no water refill, no nothing.*Finally we asked, and nine minutes later we got our food. 49 minutes for an omelet and a breakfast sandwich.*The breakfast sandwich was missing cheese we ordered so we asked for cheese.*Waitress snapped it up, took it back and one minute later came back with it.*Cook had put 1/2 a slice of cheese and just threw it in there. Didn't bother to melt it, and the sandwich was blown apart.*My wife told her to just send it back and remove it from the bill.*Waitress never came back with the bill.*Went to the register to pay and she told me an amount. A large amount. Wouldn't show me the written piece of paper. I asked if it was correct and did she remove the breakfast sandwich? Oh yes she told me.*As we were driving my wife looked up the menu. She charged us for the food we sent back.*Management DOES NOT CARE*After thousands of dollars spent, we will not be back*Go to Sticky Bun Cafe 8 minutes away and 1/3 the price with great service.NEVER AGAIN!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jonathan Saeger

Came here hungry for lunch with my kid on a Sunday at noon. VERY Disappointing.I ordered Meatloaf sandwich and daughter ordered kids chicken nuggets with applesauce and we had waited 20 minutes for our food to come out. Very Disappointed with the plates our waitress put in front of us.For $10 bucks, My meatloaf sandwich was literally a thin slice of reheated meatloaf in between 2 slices of white bread, LOL, my daughter was given 5 chicken nuggets and no side. I gave my mashed potatoes to her because they were out of applesauce and 5 nuggets weren't gonna cut it.. they at least offered her a different side but at that point we were done sitting there in the most uncomfortable chairs in PA. The food we chose here here sucks, overpriced and bland. Go somewhere else.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Josh Troyer

Awesome breakfast definitely

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tim R.

This was our "go-to" breakfast place for many years, but they've taken a nose dive in recent years. Today was our last visit EVER. *The highlights: waited 40 minutes for our food, there was two of us. *Three tables around us, all come in long after us, were served before us. *We asked if we were forgotten, since the waitress never bothered to check on us. *No coffee refill, no water refill, no nothing. *Finally we asked, and nine minutes later we got our food. 49 minutes for an omelet and a breakfast sandwich. *The breakfast sandwich was missing cheese we ordered so we asked for cheese. *Waitress snapped it up, took it back and one minute later came back with it. *Cook had put 1/2 a slice of cheese and just threw it in there. Didn't bother to melt it, and the sandwich was blown apart. *My wife told her to just send it back and remove it from the bill. *Waitress never came back with the bill. *Went to the register to pay and she told me an amount. A large amount. Wouldn't show me the written piece of paper. I asked if it was correct and did she remove the breakfast sandwich? Oh yes she told me. *As we were driving my wife looked up the menu. She charged us for the food we sent back. *Management DOES NOT CARE *After thousands of dollars spent, we will not be back *Go to Sticky Bun Cafe 8 minutes away and 1/3 the price with great service. NEVER AGAIN!!!

smoochie wallace

We found this place because we saw a sign on the highway. We are southern people, and are some what skeptical of places like this, that claim to be homemade and such, but this place was AMAZING. The food was outstanding, and the service was top-notch. We stopped again on the way back through. Great place, great foo. This will be our go to everytime we pass through the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Home Fries, Sausage

Briana Byers

Overall it wasn't a bad experience. The staff were very friendly and busy with topping things up as it was near the end of their day. They attended to us well enough.The food was pretty good. My husband loved his pancakes, said the scrapple was decent (could have been fried a touch more, but he likes his crispy) and my roast turkey sandwich w/fries and gravy were okay. The turkey was fresh off the bird, or had that feel and the fries were cooked well too. The bread was homemade, and I love that little detail, especially being in Amish country. The gravy though, that needs some help. It was just cornstarch slurry added to flavorless stock. Salt helped a smidge.I will be back, because I'm not a judge a restaurant by one meal type of person. Also, the gravy could be way better the next time. The staff were great, the atmosphere was cozy and had a "down-home" feeling.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Cara B

My family stopped for brunch. Don't expect drink refills. We enjoyed the eggs Benedict and the pumpkin cream cheese stuffed french toast. What is labelled as a skillet is more a frittata. The prices are great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Thomas Whitsel

Ordered Goose dinner to go expecting to be Hot ?, now I have to reheat the meal at home in the oven for 45 minutes, planning on eating for lunch, that plan went to hell, almost like self

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Tiffani Esh

The food was good, the service was good. It always takes awhile to get service and get the food but still a great place to eat and it's clean.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Home Fries

Dan Shetler

A nice friendly atmosphere! Good waitress!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John A

Food was good but not special. Nice place and good service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Charlie B.

Waited an hour and a half for food on a Wednesday. I was told because it takes awhile to cook scrapple.. well it came out paper thin.. do not recommend at all

nikki treaster

Food is always amazing. I've never had anything there that isn't good. Is our favorite place for breakfast when we go for breakfast the French test is absolutely amazing. My number one recommendation

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kalyn E.

Stopped at this place for lunch during a recent trip. I'd never stopped here before. I was looking for a local restaurant for lunch and this place seemed to fit the bill. It was rather busy inside but I didn't have any issues finding a table. I waited around 7 minutes to be greeted- I didn't mind as again, they were busy and had limited staff. I ordered the Club Sandwich with chips. It was quite tasty! They use real Turkey on their sandwiches which is impressive!! I left full and happy! Prices are quite cheap too! I love little gem finds like this - hometown diner with lots of local / historic charm!

Load More