We've only eaten here on Wednesdays so far but burger night is great. Every soup we've tried has been packed full of flavor. Love the smash burger! Great service, great specials.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rick N
Food was good, portion was good, staff is great, chairs are the most uncomfortable I ever set on
Amber Boozel
First time visitor, I ordered the Pittsburgher with pasta salad. The sandwich was stacked 1/2 a foot tall! The "side" of pasta salad, could have very-well been a main dish! Our server was very attentive and explained menu questions we had. The atmosphere was ambient with an industrial theme along with some trophy mounts of local trout on the walls. I forgot to mention a cute little vase of fresh flowers on each table, rounded out the entire experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Just Peachy
Alyssa Householder
I have been to this establishment several times. The quality of the ingredients in the food is very apparent. They make a lot of their stuff in house. The prices are very reasonable and the food is fresh. I love their shoe-string fries and their house made ceasar dressing is really tasty. The chairs are very comfy and the place is always clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Connie Gunsallus
This place was recommended to us. However, we were very disappointed. It is not handicapped accessible due to many steps up into the place and the seating is on tall chairs difficult to get up onto and slide in. It was very cold where we were seated in the back. So much so that I was shivering throughout the meal. The food was even worse. The prime rib was well-done and tough (according to our server it only came that way), the broccoli was over cooked and limp with barely any flavor, the butter was not softened for use, and the entire meal was served on such a small plate that the food kept falling off onto the table. We will not be eating there again and do not recommend it unless you want to pay 4 star prices for a one star meal.
michael wolfe
Nice little eatery. Was expecting food to be better, at least warm. Service was slow. The front of the house was only staffed with 2 servers on a Friday evening. I'm assuming the slow service and cold food was directly related to them being understaffed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Maryann Beck
My husband & I stopped at the Stonefly Café last night on our stop in Reedsville, PA. It was just a spontaneous stop to grab some food before we went to the hotel. We were pleasantly surprised by the friendly workers, pleasant environment and delicious food and drinks.The chicken Parm was delicious! The citrus salad was phenomenal and the feeling squeezy, apple cinnamon and rum drink was so delicious!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
johkal
Interior was cute, staff was friendly, food was nothing special. Not a big deal, but my burger was supposed to be medium rare and it was cooked to medium well. Unacceptable since there was only my wife and I and 2 other people there. Hardly too busy to make mistakes. Prices would have been on par if the food was better and cooked properly. Over priced for the quality.
Jim H.
A hidden gem. The service was very friendly and super attentive. Food was very good as well. They have done a really nice job with this place and it is very welcoming. We had come in late from a very wet Penn State football game. We were greeted with a warm welcome and friendly atmosphere. We definitely swing back thru when it town again. Cheers!
Tiffani Esh
Everything was amazing!!! The food was really good, and it was hot temperature wise. Some places you go it's only hot for a short amount of time. This was hot the whole time. I had the Parmesan crusted salmon and potatoes and my husband had the two crabcakes with their vegetable of the day.Parking: If it's a busy night there is limited and hard to find parking. Tonight we got there early and had no trouble getting a parking spot.
Bar tender for the night was Marissa, a very good server, friendly and easy to order with . Prices are awesome ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Molek
Burger night! Best burger in town no matter what night of the week it is.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon Cheeseburger
Renee Williamson
We visited the Stonefly Cafe for the first time on June 29, and we will most definitely visit again. We started with the smoked salmon flatbread, and it was phenomenal! We would go back just for that dish. My husband ordered the parmesan crusted salmon, and I ordered the special, which was shrimp tacos. Both entrees were wonderful! We completed our meal with the lemon blueberry cake, which was delicious. Amazing little cafe; don't change a thing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish Taco
C M
I met an old colleague at the Stonefly because it was midway between our homes, and it was amazing! We shared some arancini & ceasar salad for appetizers then had the parmesan crusted salmon & steak w/frites for entrees. We enjoyed our meal with their rosé sangria & finished with their crème brûlée. Absolutely delicious. Brought home a slice of the decadent peanut butter pie for our respective husbands. What a fantastic recommendation, and not too far at all. Hope to go back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee
Mark Kocsi (Mark and Colleen)
We decided at the last minute to head up for the Penn State special Olympics and the closest hotel was the Holiday Inn Express in Reedsville. Wanted dinner and decided to drive in to Reedsville to see what they had to offer. Ended up at Seven Mountains Wine Cellar and Stonefly Cafe. Wasn’t expecting much for a small mountain town. We were way wrong. The cafe was clean, quaint and comfortable. Our waitress Maddie was awesome. The drinks we ordered were spot on. Most surprisingly our appetizer, meal and dessert were something we would expect from a five-star restaurant. Everything was delicious. Plan on returning next year when we head back up to PSU.
We've only eaten here on Wednesdays so far but burger night is great. Every soup we've tried has been packed full of flavor. Love the smash burger! Great service, great specials.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was good, portion was good, staff is great, chairs are the most uncomfortable I ever set on
First time visitor, I ordered the Pittsburgher with pasta salad. The sandwich was stacked 1/2 a foot tall! The "side" of pasta salad, could have very-well been a main dish! Our server was very attentive and explained menu questions we had. The atmosphere was ambient with an industrial theme along with some trophy mounts of local trout on the walls. I forgot to mention a cute little vase of fresh flowers on each table, rounded out the entire experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Just Peachy
I have been to this establishment several times. The quality of the ingredients in the food is very apparent. They make a lot of their stuff in house. The prices are very reasonable and the food is fresh. I love their shoe-string fries and their house made ceasar dressing is really tasty. The chairs are very comfy and the place is always clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was recommended to us. However, we were very disappointed. It is not handicapped accessible due to many steps up into the place and the seating is on tall chairs difficult to get up onto and slide in. It was very cold where we were seated in the back. So much so that I was shivering throughout the meal. The food was even worse. The prime rib was well-done and tough (according to our server it only came that way), the broccoli was over cooked and limp with barely any flavor, the butter was not softened for use, and the entire meal was served on such a small plate that the food kept falling off onto the table. We will not be eating there again and do not recommend it unless you want to pay 4 star prices for a one star meal.
Nice little eatery. Was expecting food to be better, at least warm. Service was slow. The front of the house was only staffed with 2 servers on a Friday evening. I'm assuming the slow service and cold food was directly related to them being understaffed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
My husband & I stopped at the Stonefly Café last night on our stop in Reedsville, PA. It was just a spontaneous stop to grab some food before we went to the hotel. We were pleasantly surprised by the friendly workers, pleasant environment and delicious food and drinks.The chicken Parm was delicious! The citrus salad was phenomenal and the feeling squeezy, apple cinnamon and rum drink was so delicious!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Interior was cute, staff was friendly, food was nothing special. Not a big deal, but my burger was supposed to be medium rare and it was cooked to medium well. Unacceptable since there was only my wife and I and 2 other people there. Hardly too busy to make mistakes. Prices would have been on par if the food was better and cooked properly. Over priced for the quality.
A hidden gem. The service was very friendly and super attentive. Food was very good as well. They have done a really nice job with this place and it is very welcoming. We had come in late from a very wet Penn State football game. We were greeted with a warm welcome and friendly atmosphere. We definitely swing back thru when it town again. Cheers!
Everything was amazing!!! The food was really good, and it was hot temperature wise. Some places you go it's only hot for a short amount of time. This was hot the whole time. I had the Parmesan crusted salmon and potatoes and my husband had the two crabcakes with their vegetable of the day.Parking: If it's a busy night there is limited and hard to find parking. Tonight we got there early and had no trouble getting a parking spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee
Restaurantji Recommends
Bar tender for the night was Marissa, a very good server, friendly and easy to order with . Prices are awesome ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Burger night! Best burger in town no matter what night of the week it is.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon Cheeseburger
We visited the Stonefly Cafe for the first time on June 29, and we will most definitely visit again. We started with the smoked salmon flatbread, and it was phenomenal! We would go back just for that dish. My husband ordered the parmesan crusted salmon, and I ordered the special, which was shrimp tacos. Both entrees were wonderful! We completed our meal with the lemon blueberry cake, which was delicious. Amazing little cafe; don't change a thing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish Taco
I met an old colleague at the Stonefly because it was midway between our homes, and it was amazing! We shared some arancini & ceasar salad for appetizers then had the parmesan crusted salmon & steak w/frites for entrees. We enjoyed our meal with their rosé sangria & finished with their crème brûlée. Absolutely delicious. Brought home a slice of the decadent peanut butter pie for our respective husbands. What a fantastic recommendation, and not too far at all. Hope to go back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee
We decided at the last minute to head up for the Penn State special Olympics and the closest hotel was the Holiday Inn Express in Reedsville. Wanted dinner and decided to drive in to Reedsville to see what they had to offer. Ended up at Seven Mountains Wine Cellar and Stonefly Cafe. Wasn’t expecting much for a small mountain town. We were way wrong. The cafe was clean, quaint and comfortable. Our waitress Maddie was awesome. The drinks we ordered were spot on. Most surprisingly our appetizer, meal and dessert were something we would expect from a five-star restaurant. Everything was delicious. Plan on returning next year when we head back up to PSU.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Catch of the Day