The same people own the new one in Newry. Below is my review of how I was treated there.
Went to the new OIP in Newry tonight. What a disaster. Placed our order and sat down, couple minutes go by and the girl brought my wife’s tuna salad and an order of breaded mushrooms. Waited about 10-15 minutes and asked about my Stromboli, she said it’s coming up. About another 15 minutes go by and I asked again, she said “what did you want?” I told her again a small Stromboli. Another 10 minutes go by and my wife’s done with her meal and I went to the counter and the owner said he was sorry, it got misplaced and I said just forget it. He said he wouldn’t charge us for anything and I said thanks. We left a couple minutes latter and we’re almost to the car and heard someone calling. Turned around and it was the owner, he said his daughter said I never ordered the Stromboli originally and ordered it later to which I said no sorry I ordered all at once. He got angry and said aw bulls**t and walked back in. I followed him in and he wouldn’t come back over to talk, he and I assume his son just kept telling me to get out.
That’s no way to treat a customer. I will not be back and I’ll make sure I tell everyone the way they treat people.
Hannah Decker
We have made this our every Sunday stop after church, the food and service is amazing we are very thankful for Saxton OIP!
Gaylan Carl
Delightful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Resig
Only hires illegals to support his restaurants. Pizza sauce is plan tasting.
Ian Theis
Their menu has all of the classics you can expect. Their pizza is absolutely on point. They prep food right behind the counter, and are super efficient. Very comfortable atmosphere too. Legitimately one of the best pizza places I've ever been to, including the places I've been to in Italy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiffany Edwards
It sucks
Mark Crum
I like the subs the buns are great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Weimert
Great food! The owners are good people, service is almost always quick. Definitely recommend if in the Saxton area
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
E Hughes
Nice sandwiches. Liked the homemade rolls on the steak sandwich. Would stop again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
SHANNON B
Service sucked at this OIP in Saxton. I’m assuming he was the owner but he was rude and really acted like he didn’t care. The food was average I wouldn’t say it was great. The pizza crust and bread were really tough. The salad was full of peppers. The sauce was very bland and our pizza was crammed into a box that was too small causing it to fold over. They placed our salads in the bag with the hot sub and fettuccine. Who does that? Anyways I will be going to the one in Huntingdon from now on. This place sucked.
By far the best OIP I’ve ever been to. It’s not even close. The staff are great. The food is second to none. We honestly can’t recommend this place more. We love it here! ❤️
Angela Addario
The food was acceptable . I ordered 3 large pizzas that were too large for the box they attempted to cram them in, ok not the worst problem to have. The steak sandwich was an OIP special that was made earlier than the rest of the food which made it pretty soggy but still good enough to eat on an empty stomach. The Sicilian was very thick, didn’t have a crispy bottom but it mainly fed children anyway. The cheese sticks were a little oil logged. The wings and garlic knots were the highlight of the meal and were both pleasantly very delicious. The service equally was acceptable upon pick up. However, please use caution when clicking on the menu from Google. The prices listed are very inaccurate. In this new financial world I guess it is my fault for not thinking better about it. As I returned to the restaurant to inquire about the amount I felt I was inaccurately charged, I was met with unfriendly service only an owner that couldn’t care less about the mistake and offered no apology just a simple “ that’s not our menu”. So if you are aware of the prices then order the food. Just do not base your ordering on the menu that is linked to the search.
The same people own the new one in Newry. Below is my review of how I was treated there. Went to the new OIP in Newry tonight. What a disaster. Placed our order and sat down, couple minutes go by and the girl brought my wife’s tuna salad and an order of breaded mushrooms. Waited about 10-15 minutes and asked about my Stromboli, she said it’s coming up. About another 15 minutes go by and I asked again, she said “what did you want?” I told her again a small Stromboli. Another 10 minutes go by and my wife’s done with her meal and I went to the counter and the owner said he was sorry, it got misplaced and I said just forget it. He said he wouldn’t charge us for anything and I said thanks. We left a couple minutes latter and we’re almost to the car and heard someone calling. Turned around and it was the owner, he said his daughter said I never ordered the Stromboli originally and ordered it later to which I said no sorry I ordered all at once. He got angry and said aw bulls**t and walked back in. I followed him in and he wouldn’t come back over to talk, he and I assume his son just kept telling me to get out. That’s no way to treat a customer. I will not be back and I’ll make sure I tell everyone the way they treat people.
We have made this our every Sunday stop after church, the food and service is amazing we are very thankful for Saxton OIP!
Delightful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Only hires illegals to support his restaurants. Pizza sauce is plan tasting.
Their menu has all of the classics you can expect. Their pizza is absolutely on point. They prep food right behind the counter, and are super efficient. Very comfortable atmosphere too. Legitimately one of the best pizza places I've ever been to, including the places I've been to in Italy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It sucks
I like the subs the buns are great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food! The owners are good people, service is almost always quick. Definitely recommend if in the Saxton area
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Nice sandwiches. Liked the homemade rolls on the steak sandwich. Would stop again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Service sucked at this OIP in Saxton. I’m assuming he was the owner but he was rude and really acted like he didn’t care. The food was average I wouldn’t say it was great. The pizza crust and bread were really tough. The salad was full of peppers. The sauce was very bland and our pizza was crammed into a box that was too small causing it to fold over. They placed our salads in the bag with the hot sub and fettuccine. Who does that? Anyways I will be going to the one in Huntingdon from now on. This place sucked.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Nice place, always clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
By far the best OIP I’ve ever been to. It’s not even close. The staff are great. The food is second to none. We honestly can’t recommend this place more. We love it here! ❤️
The food was acceptable . I ordered 3 large pizzas that were too large for the box they attempted to cram them in, ok not the worst problem to have. The steak sandwich was an OIP special that was made earlier than the rest of the food which made it pretty soggy but still good enough to eat on an empty stomach. The Sicilian was very thick, didn’t have a crispy bottom but it mainly fed children anyway. The cheese sticks were a little oil logged. The wings and garlic knots were the highlight of the meal and were both pleasantly very delicious. The service equally was acceptable upon pick up. However, please use caution when clicking on the menu from Google. The prices listed are very inaccurate. In this new financial world I guess it is my fault for not thinking better about it. As I returned to the restaurant to inquire about the amount I felt I was inaccurately charged, I was met with unfriendly service only an owner that couldn’t care less about the mistake and offered no apology just a simple “ that’s not our menu”. So if you are aware of the prices then order the food. Just do not base your ordering on the menu that is linked to the search.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Food was decent, the only decent pizza in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Loaded Fries
Their food is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...