Caliente Pizza & Draft House - Sewickley

This was hands down the best pizza I have ever had in my 27 years of life. I’m from Alabama and traveled to Pennsylvania for work and ordered a Brooklyn pizza with the Caliente honey and instantly knew I was in love. If there are any negative reviews on this place EVER. DO NOT LISTEN TO THEM. This place is INSANELY GOOD!!!!

I am from Buffalo NY, home of the Original Buffalo wings, and let me just say that this place hit the nail on the head!! Great wings with delicious blue cheese! The Pineapple Express pizza was amazing as well!!! The waitress was friendly and funny, great conversation and timely!

I placed a simple order at 9:15pm on a Thursday night and paid over the phone. I then got a DoorDash notification (they enlisted DoorDash, not me) at 9:50pm that the food would arrive by 10:05pm (5 minutes away). I got another notification that it was delayed until 10:15pm, I called the store at 10:35pm at which point they checked to verify my order hadn’t left their store and it hadn’t. The “customer service fanatic” assured me that it would leave within 10 minutes when the next delivery driver came through. 5 minutes before they were closing (10:55pm) I called back to again see what was going on, the “customer service fanatic” told me he would bring my food to me himself within 10 minutes. 25 minutes later, my food finally arrived (2 hours after I ordered). This particular review is regarding the Bloomfield location, it sucks. Do not consider it for delivery, or honestly any orders because they clearly do not care about their customers. It is a shame they have the means to buy their way into ad campaigns with local organizations because they are a piss poor establishment. They should refrain from calling anyone on their team “customer service fanatics” because that couldn’t be further from the truth. My hospitalized, pregnant wife would have probably wrote an even harsher review. Truly pathetic.

Wanted to try something new, but was extremely disappointed tonight. Service was slow (waited 45 minutes.) The food we got wasn’t worth the wait at all. I’m not going to diss as I want all businesses to succeed, but ya’ll need to overhaul everything to do so.

I gave this place two chances to impress me and both times were a let down. The first time the food was just cold and disappointing, and the balsamic vinegar salad dressing was way too tangy, and I like the tang of balsamic a lot. This last time, I paid an extra $3.24 for pineapple to be put on my large Velma pizza and not only did I not get pineapple, I didn’t get the fresh basil that comes with the pizza and my pizza was very poorly cut. Additionally, the gave me a HUGE amount of oil and vinegar for my small side salad, which was wilted and only had two cherry tomatoes in it. The cucumbers didn’t seem very fresh either. Next time I’ll wait the three hours for my favorite place to open, because this was NOT worth it. What was supposed to be my comfort food for a very bad day just added to the badness of my day. I also think they charge way too much for extra toppings. Several dollars PER TOPPING, are you kidding me?? Even looking at the small size pizza in the delivery app, each extra topping is $2.75. Outrageous. In summary, the best part of my order was the 2-liter or Dr. Pepper I ordered. Never again. There’s way better pizza out there.

Mediterranean pizza 🍕 was average at best, heavy on the sauce and light on the cheese. The bathroom was even worse, dirty no paper towels.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Stuff there is very rude and disrespectful. I’m talking about woman working in take out area. I don’t like this place because of her manners.

Service: 1

Terrible customer relations. Ordered food on New Year’s Eve at 6 PM for guests. Food was never delivered even though they confirmed it was on the way. At 9:45 received a text order was cancelled lol. Then didn’t refund my money till I called to speak to someone and ask for a refund.

All meals brought out at different times. Pizza was cold. Sandwich was cold and had to be sent back to be reheated….and then they forgot they had reheat it and didn’t bring it out for another 10 mins.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Go there couple times a month food good, reasonably priced and Joshua is absolutely an awesome bartender.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Walked in because we love to eat here. Hostess was unsure if she could seat 10 people. Told us we would have to wait but was not sure how long. I walked into the back and there were at least 8 tables empty. Not sure why we could not be seated. I’d suggest getting better help. Your staff was unfriendly, miserable, and unaccommodating. You just lost a loyal customer.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Stevie is great at the Sewickley location. Wish they’d get better bar stools!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rolls, Cheese Pizza

The absolute worst service in Sewickley. Guaranteed to make your children cry while you (1) wait an hour for your food or (2) are told that it will be a 45 minute wait on a Monday night, even as there are visibly empty tables and customers who are waiting to most their bills. Food is good, but it’s not at all worth the terrible treatment.

Food is great, their gm is super nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Love this place. The Brooklyn pepperoni is our favorite pizza. Love the mozzarella sticks too. Definitely try it out. Hard to find good pizza places and this one is an excellent choice.