Every time we have ordered from here they get my wife’s order wrong in some way shape or form. We tend to overlook it because we’ve made it a habit to check if they remembered her order or not. Literally every time they mess up her order, which is on the menu with no substitutions. Same thing happened tonight, and this time I decided to order the filet tips and Asiago gnocchi which is a $26 dollar meal. I was given probably the smallest portion I have ever seen on a dinner meal. The service is terrible which is bad when it’s noticeable on a to go order, and on top of that I was given 10 gnocchi’s and a cut up steak for $26 dollars.
Josh Dobbins
Our family and I cannot recommend Muscarellas enough. Their kindness and professionalism today as we dined with a child whose superpower is autism is something that needs commended publicly. No customer comments that were unkind were tolerated and they did well to make sure we were cared for and our son was treated with kindness and dignity even with a couple meltdowns. May more businesses serve as this kind of example. May ALL our children eventually live in a world where they are loved and accepted so everyone can have the opportunity to dine or go out if they want to. Until then may we praise and support the businesses who are good to others.
Marah Jane Morrison
Consider this some words of caution. It’s disappointing to have to write this about a place I used to love going to. I’ve been going to Muscarella’s with my family and friends for many years. The entire change of menu was a horrendous mistake in my opinion and I’ve only been back twice since the change. The second time was recently and it was later that night I became extremely ill with the stomach flu. I’m up to date on all of my shots and I also had two doctors tell me it was food poisoning, possibly due to cross contamination. Needless to say, due to recovering from the flu, having to miss work due to being sick and the quality of the food since decreasing in light of the menu change, I REFUSE to return and will caution anyone I know who is thinking about going. I’d hate for the same to happen to them. Be well and take your business elsewhere. There are plenty of options for Italian in Northeast Ohio that better by a landslide. ♥️🙏🏼
Judy Onestak
Recently, nearly forty members of the Alfredo Family traveled from near and far and gathered in the Loft (a lovely, private, and reservable space upstairs) at Muscarella’s for a wonderful dinner and evening together. Jamie Raykie assisted us with our plans, and she and the two servers that evening provided very prompt and kind service from start to finish. The menu we selected for our buffet was like any of the many options at Muscarella’s: delicious and enjoyed by all! Special thanks to Tim, Tom, and everyone there for making this family dinner a truly memorable one!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kenna Coltman
Sneaky place. Nondescript on the outside, amazing the inside! Delicious Italian classics. Generous portions. Save room for their cannoli!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Davie S
Very nice Chicken Parmesan and Chicken Marsala.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Marsala
Robert Truby
Prices are up everywhere but theirs are ridiculous. Trying to be a 5 star restaurant in Sharpsville PA?!?! Haven't been back since the menu change. Taking the create your own off the menu was a bad call! Offering it once a week isn't going to bring back the faithful that always ordered from that. Service is ok...we waited almost a half hour for our waitress to take our drink order and an hour before we actually got them. Definitely not the same place it used to be.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
RaNae Polan
Wonderful restaurant. Food is excellent!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jake Wittenberg
Very good Italian food but they overload the cheese sometimes.
Our take home order was absolute PERFETTO!! I was a skeptic of the menu change up, but after this meal, I must say sometimes the Chef knows what’s best, and that is absolutely the case here. We did the Tortellini Pomodoro and the lasagna. The flavors all paired so well together and you can tell there is impeccable attention to detail in the kitchen. We appreciate Muscarella’s taking an already great and established restaurant to the next level. Mwah ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charlotte D
Outstanding meal. We had the sautéed peppers for appetizers and they were delizioso incredibly delicious. With the toasted bread we could have made a meal in that alone. I had the Sunday gravy which was enough for take home and more, with all of it so good but the braciole was literally melt in your mouth. The best. My husband had the chicken Alfredo which he loved. Can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wedding Soup
Amy Harenchar-Book
Love the new menu and the daily chef selections. I'm a local and I stopped in on a Thursday for dinner. Just me: party of one❤️. I love sitting in the small intimate table in the bar area. I got the Sea Bass & spaghetti. It was fabulous.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dan Suttles
We used to frequent Muscarellsa’s quite a bit, but the last two times ( within a month) were definitely different. They have chose to be a specialty restaurant now and it has affected the quality of the food to say the least. You used to be able to mix and match certain types of pastas and sauces but on our last visit ( October 11, 2024) we were told the “Chef “ didn’t like to do that anymore. Only on “special days” was this allowed. My daughter had some type of beef tips and they were the most rubbery, tasteless, meat I’ve ever ate. Two strikes and you’re out with me, especially when I spent over $100 and was limited on my order with below par quality food. I used to buy gift cards there for friends and family, no more.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
russo maria
If your looking for a place that is fancy & decorated with expensive decor. This is place is not for you. However if your looking for a warm homelike down to earth atmosphere with great service, great food, great portions,& great prices, then this place is for you. I heard they have a venue upstairs where you can have a small wedding are other type of gathering. I am going to look into that for my daughter who is planning a small intimate wedding. Muscsrella's Cafe Italia I want to thank you for not jumping aboard the price gouging train that so many other food establishments have done. Your prices are more than fair, and the quality of your food & service goes above & beyond all expectations. My husband & I celebrated our 44th wedding anniversary at muscarella's & we were glad we did. Everything was so good that that the following week i took my brother there and once again i was totally 100% satisfied with the food & service . Next time i go I want to purchase a t-shirt i saw there. The Logo on it was funny, it made me smile.
Every time we have ordered from here they get my wife’s order wrong in some way shape or form. We tend to overlook it because we’ve made it a habit to check if they remembered her order or not. Literally every time they mess up her order, which is on the menu with no substitutions. Same thing happened tonight, and this time I decided to order the filet tips and Asiago gnocchi which is a $26 dollar meal. I was given probably the smallest portion I have ever seen on a dinner meal. The service is terrible which is bad when it’s noticeable on a to go order, and on top of that I was given 10 gnocchi’s and a cut up steak for $26 dollars.
Our family and I cannot recommend Muscarellas enough. Their kindness and professionalism today as we dined with a child whose superpower is autism is something that needs commended publicly. No customer comments that were unkind were tolerated and they did well to make sure we were cared for and our son was treated with kindness and dignity even with a couple meltdowns. May more businesses serve as this kind of example. May ALL our children eventually live in a world where they are loved and accepted so everyone can have the opportunity to dine or go out if they want to. Until then may we praise and support the businesses who are good to others.
Consider this some words of caution. It’s disappointing to have to write this about a place I used to love going to. I’ve been going to Muscarella’s with my family and friends for many years. The entire change of menu was a horrendous mistake in my opinion and I’ve only been back twice since the change. The second time was recently and it was later that night I became extremely ill with the stomach flu. I’m up to date on all of my shots and I also had two doctors tell me it was food poisoning, possibly due to cross contamination. Needless to say, due to recovering from the flu, having to miss work due to being sick and the quality of the food since decreasing in light of the menu change, I REFUSE to return and will caution anyone I know who is thinking about going. I’d hate for the same to happen to them. Be well and take your business elsewhere. There are plenty of options for Italian in Northeast Ohio that better by a landslide. ♥️🙏🏼
Recently, nearly forty members of the Alfredo Family traveled from near and far and gathered in the Loft (a lovely, private, and reservable space upstairs) at Muscarella’s for a wonderful dinner and evening together. Jamie Raykie assisted us with our plans, and she and the two servers that evening provided very prompt and kind service from start to finish. The menu we selected for our buffet was like any of the many options at Muscarella’s: delicious and enjoyed by all! Special thanks to Tim, Tom, and everyone there for making this family dinner a truly memorable one!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sneaky place. Nondescript on the outside, amazing the inside! Delicious Italian classics. Generous portions. Save room for their cannoli!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very nice Chicken Parmesan and Chicken Marsala.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Marsala
Prices are up everywhere but theirs are ridiculous. Trying to be a 5 star restaurant in Sharpsville PA?!?! Haven't been back since the menu change. Taking the create your own off the menu was a bad call! Offering it once a week isn't going to bring back the faithful that always ordered from that. Service is ok...we waited almost a half hour for our waitress to take our drink order and an hour before we actually got them. Definitely not the same place it used to be.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Wonderful restaurant. Food is excellent!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good Italian food but they overload the cheese sometimes.
GREAT FOOD AND
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Our take home order was absolute PERFETTO!!
I was a skeptic of the menu change up, but after this meal, I must say sometimes the Chef knows what’s best, and that is absolutely the case here.
We did the Tortellini Pomodoro and the lasagna. The flavors all paired so well together and you can tell there is impeccable attention to detail in the kitchen. We appreciate Muscarella’s taking an already great and established restaurant to the next level. Mwah ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outstanding meal. We had the sautéed peppers for appetizers and they were delizioso incredibly delicious. With the toasted bread we could have made a meal in that alone. I had the Sunday gravy which was enough for take home and more, with all of it so good but the braciole was literally melt in your mouth. The best. My husband had the chicken Alfredo which he loved. Can’t wait to go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wedding Soup
Love the new menu and the daily chef selections. I'm a local and I stopped in on a Thursday for dinner. Just me: party of one❤️. I love sitting in the small intimate table in the bar area. I got the Sea Bass & spaghetti. It was fabulous.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We used to frequent Muscarellsa’s quite a bit, but the last two times ( within a month) were definitely different. They have chose to be a specialty restaurant now and it has affected the quality of the food to say the least. You used to be able to mix and match certain types of pastas and sauces but on our last visit ( October 11, 2024) we were told the “Chef “ didn’t like to do that anymore. Only on “special days” was this allowed. My daughter had some type of beef tips and they were the most rubbery, tasteless, meat I’ve ever ate. Two strikes and you’re out with me, especially when I spent over $100 and was limited on my order with below par quality food. I used to buy gift cards there for friends and family, no more.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
If your looking for a place that is fancy & decorated with expensive decor. This is place is not for you.
However if your looking for a warm homelike down to earth atmosphere with great service, great food, great portions,& great prices, then this place is for you. I heard they have a venue upstairs where you can have a small wedding are other type of gathering. I am going to look into that for my daughter who is planning a small intimate wedding. Muscsrella's Cafe Italia I want to thank you for not jumping aboard the price gouging train that so many other food establishments have done. Your prices are more than fair, and the quality of your food & service goes above & beyond all expectations. My husband & I celebrated our 44th wedding anniversary at muscarella's & we were glad we did. Everything was so good that that the following week i took my brother there and once again i was totally 100% satisfied with the food & service . Next time i go I want to purchase a t-shirt i saw there. The Logo on it was funny, it made me smile.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wedding Soup, Chicken Francaise, Lasagna
Loading...