Sal's Pizza

437 S Main St, Shrewsbury
(717) 227-4846

Recent Reviews

Johnnie Sauers

We got a pepperoni pizza. What's better than I thought it would be?

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Tango Mango

Refused to sell me a dough ball. I've bought food from here before. I just sometimes like buying dough. Don't want my money ....alright then

Rick Sutherland

Great food, decent prices.But Beware!!!! This place close at 7:30 PM

Heath Chocolate

Loved the pizza, had leftovers for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Sal's Special Pizza

Samantha Lutters

If I could rate 0 stars I would! I never leave reviews but our experience with Sals was so awful I feel the need to leave a review. We ordered a taco pizza and it came COVERED in sour cream. We double checked and Sour cream was NEVER listed in the ingredients. When we called Sals the woman [Lorena] who answered the phone was incredibly rude. She stated we could reorder and repay for a correct pizza but she would not help us. She hung up on my husband and then when he called back put him on hold and never came back on the line. The food we did recieve was okay but definitely not great. I am warning anyone who reads this review to not order from here!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gary Manning

my family ordered a pizza and it came with ingredients that were unlisted and refused to remake or refund the order my wife being pregnant couldnt eat it and the customer service was incredibly rude while trying to work through the order. Lorena was the person we spoke to. id avoid this place even the correct food we got wasnt great.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Ted

Delivery..... Always the sweetest!!! Love their hand made and home made goods!! Fair priced compared to others, but worth it for the love!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Double Crust Pizza, Cheesesteak Sub, French Fries

Nancy P.

Only had Sal's twice in the last 2 weeks. Daughter just moved into town. Got subs from there the first time the steak and cheese with onions and mushrooms ordered them without the marinara sauce, they came with the marinara sauce but you know what, they were really good! Got a slice of pizza to try and it was very good! So the second time we went we got a whole pizza! It will be my go-to pizza place anytime I visit my daughter!

Natasha H.

Sals pizza is great! We're out of town and wanted to try some local pizza. The taste is amazing, great crust, perfect amount of cheese and sauce. Highly recommend!

Polly Thomas

The sandwich are freshly baked. So good!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: And Fries, Cheesesteak Sub

Fran P.

So we stopped in Sal's for the second time. A few years ago we tried it and found a place we preferred. We decided to give it a second chance and we are glad we did. The pizza is large. It could use a little more cheese but if you are a more sauce than cheese this is a good pizza for you. We picked up some boneless wings. We got the sweet and chili and everybody loved them. They were crispy and nice flavor. We also got a quesadilla.... yes at a pizza shop. The quesadilla was good. It had a lot of cheese and the tortilla was clearly crisped on a flat top. We tried the sal's special sub. It was good. It had a lot of oregano on it so if you do not like that you should order it without. The bread was really unique. It is almost like a sweet roll but in a sub roll. It wasn't too much bread but is a nice change from a traditional store bought roll. It is clearly homemade. The real winner was the cheese bread. My daughter does not like sauce on her pizza. This was a cheesey thicker pizza crust and had marinara for dipping if you want it. It was entirely eaten and my daughter will want it again. The service was great. We walked in and for some reason I never submitted my order. The husband and wife were working and they took the order fast and got it completed quickly and accurately despite my goof up. They were kind and grateful for our business which is nice on a Saturday late morning. We got a lot of food for $50. I think the value was there and I am sure we will come back. There still is pizza in the area I prefer but some of the other things we got make this a real possibility for a family night meal.

Glenn Leonard

I haven’t ordered from Sal’s since my kids moved away. My daughter was visiting so we decided to revisit a childhood favorite and are we glad we did!! The pizza has always been delicious but we also got the taco fries and holy Hannah are they amazing! Fast delivery and prices that aren’t stupid outrageous! Welcome back to our menu Sal’s! ?

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: White Pizza, And Fries

Kevin C

Amazing pizza steak.. overdelivered on any expectation I had… they make their own bread and sauce, which is just awesome. I would’ve liked to of had a picture here, but it’s too late I ate it already

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christopher Lyles

Looks like a great menu, but expensive and Service lacking. Seems like they are inconvenienced to fulfill orders. And order has been incorrect. I was charged for extra sauce on a gyro and got no sauce at all.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Kevin B

Have always loved their pizza, and their subs on fresh baked sub rolls

Load More