5 Best American Restaurants near Southampton

“Ordered a chicken pesto Stromboli and one of the reasons was the sun dried tomato’s. Unfortunately it came with regular tomatoes which made it watery. Sun-dried tomatoes are more expensive than plum tomatoes and the flavor is very different.if they were not available the server should have mentioned and the price should reflect the difference. Very disappointed and only had a couple bites.“

“We had dinner here for the first time on Sat, 11/12/22–what a wonderful experience! The staff was friendly and very helpful. We had muscles for our appetizer that were fresh and very tasty. We each had different entrees, one the salmon dish and the other chicken—both were amazing, with each of us saying we’d order our meal again or try the other one next time. Then dessert: one had the s’mores dessert and the other the chocolate bread pudding—we didn’t think we’d have room, but we made room, because both were excellent! Plus the chef said he’d be changing the menu every week—we can’t wait to go back!“

“Never disappointed fast service family of 5 out in 40 mins no issues“

“We had our Neshaminy HS Class of 1975, 50th Reunion here at Maggio's on 10/4/25.\nSam Schubert, the owner, was a fantastic person to work with. Our contract was signed in October of 2024. The food was fantastic, the ballroom was gorgeous. We chose the Rose Wedding Package for 5 hours of delicious food, butlered hors d'oeuvres, an open bar, lavish sweet table and so much more. The waitstaff did an excellent job as well as the Bartenders. The centerpieces, by Domenic Graziano Flowers were unmatched, beautifully arranged and won by one of our guests at each table. We had terrific communications throughout the entire planning process, even to the end with payment, service and clean up. What a task with 200 guests and since it was my personal, third event here at Maggio's, I knew we'd be blessed beyond measure.“

“I have been here many times but tonight I tried their new menu and it was excellent. I had to the roasted squash grilled cheese and my boyfriend had the Korean shrimp po boy. They were the best food I’ve had at a fun pub. Our server was also friendly and attentive. Highly recommend“