Made the last minute decision to order dinner instead of make it.. food was here fast and it was hot and fresh despite it being a little late. Always love Il Costello!
Tommy W.
Italian & Tex Mex? Seriously?! Yes - Seriously. Love this place Great Food Great service
greeneyes630
Stopped in on a Sunday early evening. Staff was very welcoming and friendly. Huge menu. Pizza, Tex-Mex, Italian, salads, subs. Online menu does not have everything the in restaurant menu does. We ordered a chicken burrito, good. A personal pizza, good and a side salad.
Kelly Renner
Food not as ordered...called to tell them we did not get the meatballs we ordered and paid for. The person we spoke to was very rude. Never did get a refund....
Joe Renner
Twice we ordered from there and did not get what we ordered. When we called they were very rude. Brothers will get our business now
Doug Jones
Met Dominic the other weekend at Los Amigos and he had told me that they had good food and would deliver to Maugansville. We just got our food a bit ago and it was incredible. Amazing flavor, portions and delivery was 20 minutes early. We will definitely be regulars!
Rachael B.
Great food today for lunch. My husband and I usually order burritos or quesadillas as they are a great value and delicious. Even the taco salad is a nice size and delicious. Today we both ordered calazones. They were packed with flavor and their homemade crust was delicious. We got the smaller version and had to take half of it home for dinner. Highly recommend this establishment. Our waitress was personable and efficient.
Cora Z.
This is always a go to Italian place when I'm in greencastle! The service is always fast and excellent, even when they are super busy (and they usually are)! The pizza is some of the best in town and the stuffed garlic knots are also very delicious! My boyfriend says the Alfredo is one to die for and the bread is always so fresh and delicious! My boyfriend also enjoys the Stromboli's, but they were a bit too cheesy for me in my opinion. The restaurant is in an awkward area, but don't judge it based on location! The inside is always clean and bright! The delivery is also fast too! The price can be a little on the higher end for pizza, but, it is totally worth every penny! If you are around Greencastle, be sure to stop in and have a bite!
Susan Ann Sumpter-Loebig
fantastic service!!!! very friendly and efficient staff
ThoughtsofRS
My wife ate here on a work outing and brought me home a three topping, pepperoni, mushroom and steak pizza. It was pretty solid, and what I did like was the saltiness of the steak. Played very well with the pizza. If salt is an issue, keep that in mind. Pleasantly surprised.
We placed an order. They were behind on deliveries so we picked it up. Got home and realized 1/2 cannolis were empty and they forgot the calzone. I called, they said they would drop it off at our house and never did. I called at 10p and they didn't sound surprised that it was never delivered and asked me to call back the next day at 4. They were going to refund the calzone and deliver cannolis but neither happened and I am done with them. They have people answering the phone that do not understand or speak English. Not worth the work.
Lori Sword
I ordered online last night. After waiting over an hour, I decided to call. They said the online order had never been printed and our food hadn't even been made. No apology or offer of a discount. Nothing. I don't know what has changed at your restaurant but this is the 2nd time something like this has happened. Very disappointing!
Tandy Foust
Amazing food, awesome portions and great prices!
Diana R. Lynn Bauer
I had Lasagna and added Meatballs for only $2.99 and a Greek Salad plus Garlic Bread! It was Delicious!!
Zack S.
Wonderful experience at this local restaurant! The food is delicious and full of flavor. The portions are huge. I recommend the Castello Pasta and Baked Ziti. Great service and ill definitely be back!
Made the last minute decision to order dinner instead of make it.. food was here fast and it was hot and fresh despite it being a little late. Always love Il Costello!
Italian & Tex Mex? Seriously?! Yes - Seriously. Love this place Great Food Great service
Stopped in on a Sunday early evening. Staff was very welcoming and friendly. Huge menu. Pizza, Tex-Mex, Italian, salads, subs. Online menu does not have everything the in restaurant menu does. We ordered a chicken burrito, good. A personal pizza, good and a side salad.
Food not as ordered...called to tell them we did not get the meatballs we ordered and paid for. The person we spoke to was very rude. Never did get a refund....
Twice we ordered from there and did not get what we ordered. When we called they were very rude. Brothers will get our business now
Met Dominic the other weekend at Los Amigos and he had told me that they had good food and would deliver to Maugansville. We just got our food a bit ago and it was incredible. Amazing flavor, portions and delivery was 20 minutes early. We will definitely be regulars!
Great food today for lunch. My husband and I usually order burritos or quesadillas as they are a great value and delicious. Even the taco salad is a nice size and delicious. Today we both ordered calazones. They were packed with flavor and their homemade crust was delicious. We got the smaller version and had to take half of it home for dinner. Highly recommend this establishment. Our waitress was personable and efficient.
This is always a go to Italian place when I'm in greencastle! The service is always fast and excellent, even when they are super busy (and they usually are)! The pizza is some of the best in town and the stuffed garlic knots are also very delicious! My boyfriend says the Alfredo is one to die for and the bread is always so fresh and delicious! My boyfriend also enjoys the Stromboli's, but they were a bit too cheesy for me in my opinion. The restaurant is in an awkward area, but don't judge it based on location! The inside is always clean and bright! The delivery is also fast too! The price can be a little on the higher end for pizza, but, it is totally worth every penny! If you are around Greencastle, be sure to stop in and have a bite!
fantastic service!!!! very friendly and efficient staff
My wife ate here on a work outing and brought me home a three topping, pepperoni, mushroom and steak pizza. It was pretty solid, and what I did like was the saltiness of the steak. Played very well with the pizza. If salt is an issue, keep that in mind. Pleasantly surprised.
Restaurantji Recommends
We placed an order. They were behind on deliveries so we picked it up. Got home and realized 1/2 cannolis were empty and they forgot the calzone. I called, they said they would drop it off at our house and never did. I called at 10p and they didn't sound surprised that it was never delivered and asked me to call back the next day at 4. They were going to refund the calzone and deliver cannolis but neither happened and I am done with them. They have people answering the phone that do not understand or speak English. Not worth the work.
I ordered online last night. After waiting over an hour, I decided to call. They said the online order had never been printed and our food hadn't even been made. No apology or offer of a discount. Nothing. I don't know what has changed at your restaurant but this is the 2nd time something like this has happened. Very disappointing!
Amazing food, awesome portions and great prices!
I had Lasagna and added Meatballs for only $2.99 and a Greek Salad plus Garlic Bread! It was Delicious!!
Wonderful experience at this local restaurant! The food is delicious and full of flavor. The portions are huge. I recommend the Castello Pasta and Baked Ziti. Great service and ill definitely be back!