Original Italian Pizza

5 W Pennsylvania Ave, Stewartstown
(717) 993-5555

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Harrison Smith

Good food, nice staff

Ricardo Colon

I ordered the deluxe pizza and chicken wings. Pizza was amazing. The chicken wings were very overcooked. But overall, will definitely hit it up for some za.

Diana Tedder

Sub rolls rock hard not what n I'm used to from them

Cinthya Gonzalez

New management we were impressed with the high quality of food & service now we regulars we loved the freshness of food & pastries & the professionalism in the restaurant

absmithda Go

Hands down the best authentic Italian pizza in the area. I have ordered by the slice and take out and I have never had a bad pizza from this place. The crust is crispy yet light and everything I have had here is always delicious.

Strategic BJJ

Great family owned place! High quality food at a reasonable price. Looking forward to visiting again in the future!

Oscar Perez

I will highly recommend having the salads. We had the fajita style salad and the chicken was tasty and not over spiced. Loved it’s.

Amy Schwarzer

Friendly service. Good food

Kathy Scott

Today was the first time I have ordered from OIP since the new owner took over. Let me start off my saying all new businesses have growing pains and customers need to be patient and give them a chance to improve. My order wasn’t exactly correct but they quickly made my sub the way I ordered it. They are still trying to hire new staff, but existing staff was very pleasant to deal with. I will give them more time to improve and will order from them again.

Patrick Quesenberry

One of the BEST pizzas ever the staff is amazing and food is great. What more could you ask for in a pizza shop!

Tim C

Well, I am sad to say that new ownership is not making good decisions. First time I've been to OIP since management change. It's obvious all pizza toppings are being sourced from another supplier. Ingredients are not as fresh and good. Got a mega fry and there was a very thin layer of bacon bits and hardened cheese on top. 90% were just french fries with nothing on it. Oh well, they had a good run. I'm done. Don't get me wrong, The pizza was okay, It was average good. It's just a shame that they are changing ingredients and menu options. Change the name! It's NOT OIP............ For the owner, don't even think about accusing me of reviewing another restaurant's food. This came from your place! I've lived around here for the past 20 years. Never have. I had a bad meal there until now. You do the math. It's obvious you're sourcing your ingredients from other places

Michelle Hensley

Absolutely the worst Italian sub i ever had 10 pounds of onions and no meat

H

Cheeseburger 🍔 sub was good.

sandy wilson

There pizza not good -ask well done did not happen
Service is terrible -server not trained bothers the customer too much
Kids running through dinning rm
Server should not bring cleaning bucket on table to clean again no training
Liked the old owners

Bobbert Bort

Tried for first time since new Ownership the other night. Food and value was AMAZING.... service however needs a ton of work.
It was a Friday night, so maybe their first busy night? Got our takeout order picked up and didnt realize until we got home that they forgot a sandwich which we paid for. We called the store back asking if we can come back to get it and they seemed very flustered.
When we got back to the store, 10 other customers where there for missing takeout items.
I know they are new and might be inexperienced with busy restuarunt work. I hope they improve.
I will def try again in future

Loading...