Delicious food and drinks. I had the lobster, and my husband has steak - literally melted in our mouths. Made for a memorable Valentine's Day dinner. :)
Mary Ellen
What a great find! Traveling through Pa we found this little gem of a restaurant right off Rt 80 on our way back home to NJ. We were pleasantly surprised by the charm and ambience of this place! The lighting was soft and the high back booths were so cozy. Our server Nadeem was a delight and gave us the best recommendations. Our food was amazing! We would definitely return!
Hedley
Not cheap, but worth every penny. We had great service and probably the best steak I have ever eaten.
Herbert
we where greeted by a rude host and sat down after dealing w her attitude.. we sat down to dirty menus and after realizing that this experience was not going to be good we decided let's just have some dessert, their desert options where horrible , they didn't have a cappuccino maker overall Garlic needs new management and better staff . i will never go back there again .. we went to Momebto and had the best desert selections cappuccinos and amazing host and service
Power Of Improvement
We love this place and make sure to get here every few weeks to enjoy their incredible creations. Owners are lovely!
Our family of 15 celebrated grandma's 80th birthday. One "Happy Birthday" balloon was not allowed into the restaurant. We were not allowed to sit at one long table, even though there was plenty of room and the restaurant was not busy. Our drink order was mixed up and required three redos. Filet was very good, however, the sides were four small asparagus spears and extreme garlic potatoes. It is overpriced for what you receive. We will not return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
phone rand
Had a fabulous dinner. Very delicious. They are thinking and cooking outside of the box! Skip the garlic Manhattan though, it's a little too far out of the box.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jas D
I really had high hopes for this restaurant. The food was okay. DO NOT order their flowers for special occasions. The bouquet was $25 but when we got to the table it was a small one that looked like it was worth $5 with one of the flowers already dead. As soon as I put them in a vase they started drooping. They didn’t come with any flower food which at least the grocery store flowers come with that. The server was nice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Rochelle D'Souza
Our server Nyaiah was just amazing from beginning to end. The food was absolutely divine. We went for my birthday and it was an amazing time. I highly recommend this place for any kind or celebration.
Kid-friendliness: Very accommodating, friendly and kind.
What a great little gem. Glad we discovered this restaurant. Service was excellent and food was on point. Would definately recommend for a great date night meal!
My wife and myself came in for a birthday dinner and were happy we did. We found the place in an internet search. Both of us have been to prime Italian Steak Houses around the United States so we were happy to see one advertised as being in Stroudsburg. We ordered drinks from the bar, three appetizers and two steaks. The drinks were great. The appetizers were also awesome. My wife’s filet was cooked the right way and tasted great. I ordered a New York Strip cooked rare. What was delivered did not look like New York Strip steak. It was tough, it was not rare. It was more like a London broil. Tasted terrible. It ruined what was shaping up to be a great evening. Service was fast and friendly. The atmosphere was eclectic. The lighting was industrial and the tables more traditional. I will probably come again. Recommended for drinks and appetizers
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes
James Kish
Fantastic service. Food was great. Slightly overpriced but you pay for the ambiance. Definitely will go back. The decor needs updating however. As a frequent guest, the paintings have grown old. Shake it up, a little.
Everything from the oven fresh buns with garlic butter, to the cajun shrimp tortellini was fantastic. One of the tastiest dishes I’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Face Face
Me and the wife love your restaurant and been coming for some time now, but lately we haven't, we have had everything on the menu and would like to come back, but the menu hasn't change in some time, it been five to seven years the menu has been the same, are there any changes coming. So Garlic some time ago I ask about the menu being the same for sometime and if there would be changes, never got a reply but me and the wife see the menu has changed, we're back and the food was excellent, the service was top notch and were glad we continue to check and didn't give up
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Arcadia
This place is really over priced. I’ve never heard anything positive about the owner either. Rare & Rye charges $53 for a dry aged 16oz NY strip steak and Garlic is charging over $68 for a regular 14oz strip steak.
Delicious food and drinks. I had the lobster, and my husband has steak - literally melted in our mouths. Made for a memorable Valentine's Day dinner. :)
What a great find! Traveling through Pa we found this little gem of a restaurant right off Rt 80 on our way back home to NJ. We were pleasantly surprised by the charm and ambience of this place! The lighting was soft and the high back booths were so cozy. Our server Nadeem was a delight and gave us the best recommendations. Our food was amazing! We would definitely return!
Not cheap, but worth every penny. We had great service and probably the best steak I have ever eaten.
we where greeted by a rude host and sat down after dealing w her attitude.. we sat down to dirty menus and after realizing that this experience was not going to be good we decided let's just have some dessert, their desert options where horrible , they didn't have a cappuccino maker overall Garlic needs new management and better staff . i will never go back there again .. we went to Momebto and had the best desert selections cappuccinos and amazing host and service
We love this place and make sure to get here every few weeks to enjoy their incredible creations. Owners are lovely!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan, Lobster Ravioli, Steak
Our family of 15 celebrated grandma's 80th birthday. One "Happy Birthday" balloon was not allowed into the restaurant. We were not allowed to sit at one long table, even though there was plenty of room and the restaurant was not busy. Our drink order was mixed up and required three redos. Filet was very good, however, the sides were four small asparagus spears and extreme garlic potatoes. It is overpriced for what you receive. We will not return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Had a fabulous dinner. Very delicious. They are thinking and cooking outside of the box! Skip the garlic Manhattan though, it's a little too far out of the box.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I really had high hopes for this restaurant. The food was okay. DO NOT order their flowers for special occasions. The bouquet was $25 but when we got to the table it was a small one that looked like it was worth $5 with one of the flowers already dead. As soon as I put them in a vase they started drooping. They didn’t come with any flower food which at least the grocery store flowers come with that. The server was nice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Our server Nyaiah was just amazing from beginning to end. The food was absolutely divine. We went for my birthday and it was an amazing time. I highly recommend this place for any kind or celebration.
Kid-friendliness: Very accommodating, friendly and kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood, Chicken Parmesan, Spicy Honey Salmon
What a great little gem. Glad we discovered this restaurant. Service was excellent and food was on point. Would definately recommend for a great date night meal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
Restaurantji Recommends
My wife and myself came in for a birthday dinner and were happy we did. We found the place in an internet search. Both of us have been to prime Italian Steak Houses around the United States so we were happy to see one advertised as being in Stroudsburg.
We ordered drinks from the bar, three appetizers and two steaks. The drinks were great. The appetizers were also awesome. My wife’s filet was cooked the right way and tasted great. I ordered a New York Strip cooked rare. What was delivered did not look like New York Strip steak. It was tough, it was not rare. It was more like a London broil. Tasted terrible. It ruined what was shaping up to be a great evening.
Service was fast and friendly.
The atmosphere was eclectic. The lighting was industrial and the tables more traditional. I will probably come again.
Recommended for drinks and appetizers
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes
Fantastic service. Food was great.
Slightly overpriced but you pay for the ambiance. Definitely will go back.
The decor needs updating however. As a frequent guest, the paintings have grown old. Shake it up, a little.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster, Mashed Potatoes, Steak
Everything from the oven fresh buns with garlic butter, to the cajun shrimp tortellini was fantastic. One of the tastiest dishes I’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Me and the wife love your restaurant and been coming for some time now, but lately we haven't, we have had everything on the menu and would like to come back, but the menu hasn't change in some time, it been five to seven years the menu has been the same, are there any changes coming. So Garlic some time ago I ask about the menu being the same for sometime and if there would be changes, never got a reply but me and the wife see the menu has changed, we're back and the food was excellent, the service was top notch and were glad we continue to check and didn't give up
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is really over priced. I’ve never heard anything positive about the owner either. Rare & Rye charges $53 for a dry aged 16oz NY strip steak and Garlic is charging over $68 for a regular 14oz strip steak.
Loading...