Awesome place. Great cupcakes. Friend service. Beautiful decor
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Martin
We just had our wedding over the weekend and I cannot tell you how happy I am that this cake made our special day more magical! Paula and her team are wonderful and were amazing to work with!! Thank you for our beautiful fall themed wedding cake ? everything was perfect ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Beauvais
While the coffee & cupcakes were good, they refused to change a dollar for 4 quarters for the parking meter. I can see refusal for someone who walks in off the street, but refusing a customer indicates a lack of hospitality.
Maggie Gil
Ordered a cake for my sons 4th birthday,was a simple cake design and was executed ok,buttercream was flavored nicely but the cake itself was very dense almost like bread and quite dry and crumbly took one small sliver and chucked the rest
Samantha Cipolla
I'm very disappointed in BOTH cakes I ordered. The first one was supposed to be beauty and the beast and nothing about that cake said that. My husband had to get beauty and the beast toys to make it looks somewhat good. The cake was very dry and it tasted like Bananas. Which we did not order! The "butterfly" cake looks like my 6 year old child did it. We had to cut around the outline of the butterfly to make it look decent. I definitely would not be using them again. I ordered both cakes on the same day and unfortunately i didn't cancel the butterfly cake.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Terrie Graczyk
I bought the Almond Joy cupcake and was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Gilinsky
Got a custom birthday cake while on vacation at Great Wolf Lodge for my son's 2nd birthday, they did an amazing job! The cake is absolutely adorable and the staff was very friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ally Hirsch
Just Like Magic Bakery made our wedding cake for our 8/24/24 wedding. Troi helped us to come up with our dream was cake and was such a highlight of our experience! It was quite literally the best cake we have ever had and got so many compliments for our guests. We chose the cookie butter flavor!
Z Grey
Best cinnamon buns in the business. Line was out the door. Amazing people. Business owners are awesome. Love love.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Babikian
I'm from New York City and I use to go to Crumb Bakery in Manhattan and these Cupcakes at Just Like Magic Bakery are even better ! Amazing staff and service. This is a definite must try!!
BABY I just went in here for the first time like 30minutes ago for a singular cupcake and emerged with 3 cupcakes- galaxy, funfetti and oreo. I started with one, eventually got two and then the owner(?) Mentioned that the galaxy (I love space) was their signature I had to try it. I got that thing home and tried to just taste it and ended up eating the whole thing and tasting the others. These are some of the best cupcakes I've had in a while, and I'm SUPER picky with sweets and food in general. The staff were super sweet (pun intended) and kind. Will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alivea Vento
I’m glad I was finally able to stop in and experience this bakery. I went during their 1-year anniversary celebration so they were doing a fun spin-the-wheel gift surprise when you checked out. They gave an extensive menu with baked goods and flavors for anyone! The decor and atmosphere are really fun and inviting. I got a bunch of their goodies: - apple cinnamon cupcake - chocolate chip cookie - 7 different flavor macarons - cake pucks: red velvet, cookie butter, and tiramisu All were beautifully most and flavorful. If you haven’t try them yet, stop in and check it out!!
Dietary restrictions: They have a good selection of vegan and gluten free baked goods!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Cookies
Edgard Martinez
What an awesome bakery! Paula, the owner was so pleasant and made us feel like old friends! We will be back soon for some more of the sweet delights here!
Bought several different cupcakes...all were so tasty! (the sea salt caramel cupcake, vanilla cupcake with chocolate icing, the butterscotch cupcake - my favorite, and the vanilla oreo cupcake) wanted to try all of the treats here. Freshly made breads also sold here.
Lots of art by a local artist featured here, and adorable seating areas if you want to hang out and eat your treats right away. A good variety of beverages also sold.
We are from out of town and can't wait to get back here soon!
oh and make sure to say hi to Bertha at the entrance. You can't miss her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
david daniszewski
Great place. Love the decor. According to my wife and daughter the cupcakes were great. We will definitely be coming back!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Traci Slutter-Sykes
I popped in on my walk down Main St decided I'd bring the family home a treat. I ordered the few things I wanted & used the ladies room. When I came back out, moments later, a line formed. My items were boxed & ready to go, just needed to pay. The girl behind the counter took 2 other customers, 1 was quick, then she took another one wanting to order a wedding cake & of coarse she had a lot of questions, I would too!
Cashier should have said, plz excuse me quickly while I ring this woman up. Would have taken 30 seconds & I could have been on my way, but nope I stood there for 15 mins! She never even made eye contact to tell me she'd be right with me, nothing. I left.
(She also said, she had no idea what was in one of the cake pops. I wanted to know what flavor of cake was inside. How can u sell something you know nothing about?! ) LOL!
I'm not rating the food bc I didn't try it, im only rating the service bc it was poor.
Awesome place. Great cupcakes. Friend service. Beautiful decor
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just had our wedding over the weekend and I cannot tell you how happy I am that this cake made our special day more magical! Paula and her team are wonderful and were amazing to work with!! Thank you for our beautiful fall themed wedding cake ? everything was perfect ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
While the coffee & cupcakes were good, they refused to change a dollar for 4 quarters for the parking meter. I can see refusal for someone who walks in off the street, but refusing a customer indicates a lack of hospitality.
Ordered a cake for my sons 4th birthday,was a simple cake design and was executed ok,buttercream was flavored nicely but the cake itself was very dense almost like bread and quite dry and crumbly took one small sliver and chucked the rest
I'm very disappointed in BOTH cakes I ordered. The first one was supposed to be beauty and the beast and nothing about that cake said that. My husband had to get beauty and the beast toys to make it looks somewhat good. The cake was very dry and it tasted like Bananas. Which we did not order!
The "butterfly" cake looks like my 6 year old child did it. We had to cut around the outline of the butterfly to make it look decent. I definitely would not be using them again. I ordered both cakes on the same day and unfortunately i didn't cancel the butterfly cake.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I bought the Almond Joy cupcake and was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got a custom birthday cake while on vacation at Great Wolf Lodge for my son's 2nd birthday, they did an amazing job! The cake is absolutely adorable and the staff was very friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just Like Magic Bakery made our wedding cake for our 8/24/24 wedding. Troi helped us to come up with our dream was cake and was such a highlight of our experience! It was quite literally the best cake we have ever had and got so many compliments for our guests. We chose the cookie butter flavor!
Best cinnamon buns in the business. Line was out the door. Amazing people. Business owners are awesome. Love love.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm from New York City and I use to go to Crumb Bakery in Manhattan and these Cupcakes at Just Like Magic Bakery are even better ! Amazing staff and service. This is a definite must try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownies
Restaurantji Recommends
BABY I just went in here for the first time like 30minutes ago for a singular cupcake and emerged with 3 cupcakes- galaxy, funfetti and oreo. I started with one, eventually got two and then the owner(?) Mentioned that the galaxy (I love space) was their signature I had to try it. I got that thing home and tried to just taste it and ended up eating the whole thing and tasting the others. These are some of the best cupcakes I've had in a while, and I'm SUPER picky with sweets and food in general. The staff were super sweet (pun intended) and kind. Will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m glad I was finally able to stop in and experience this bakery. I went during their 1-year anniversary celebration so they were doing a fun spin-the-wheel gift surprise when you checked out. They gave an extensive menu with baked goods and flavors for anyone! The decor and atmosphere are really fun and inviting. I got a bunch of their goodies:
- apple cinnamon cupcake
- chocolate chip cookie
- 7 different flavor macarons
- cake pucks: red velvet, cookie butter, and tiramisu
All were beautifully most and flavorful. If you haven’t try them yet, stop in and check it out!!
Dietary restrictions: They have a good selection of vegan and gluten free baked goods!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Cookies
What an awesome bakery! Paula, the owner was so pleasant and made us feel like old friends! We will be back soon for some more of the sweet delights here!
Bought several different cupcakes...all were so tasty! (the sea salt caramel cupcake, vanilla cupcake with chocolate icing, the butterscotch cupcake - my favorite, and the vanilla oreo cupcake) wanted to try all of the treats here. Freshly made breads also sold here.
Lots of art by a local artist featured here, and adorable seating areas if you want to hang out and eat your treats right away. A good variety of beverages also sold.
We are from out of town and can't wait to get back here soon!
oh and make sure to say hi to Bertha at the entrance. You can't miss her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place. Love the decor. According to my wife and daughter the cupcakes were great. We will definitely be coming back!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I popped in on my walk down Main St decided I'd bring the family home a treat. I ordered the few things I wanted & used the ladies room. When I came back out, moments later, a line formed. My items were boxed & ready to go, just needed to pay. The girl behind the counter took 2 other customers, 1 was quick, then she took another one wanting to order a wedding cake & of coarse she had a lot of questions, I would too!
Cashier should have said, plz excuse me quickly while I ring this woman up. Would have taken 30 seconds & I could have been on my way, but nope I stood there for 15 mins! She never even made eye contact to tell me she'd be right with me, nothing. I left.
(She also said, she had no idea what was in one of the cake pops. I wanted to know what flavor of cake was inside. How can u sell something you know nothing about?! ) LOL!
I'm not rating the food bc I didn't try it, im only rating the service bc it was poor.
Service: 1
Loading...