Just Like Magic Bakery

727 Main St, Stroudsburg
(570) 872-0132

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Pecan Roll Sticky Bun

Cinnamon Roll

Birthday Cake

Gift Basket

Cupcake

Brownies

Photos

+17 photos

+16 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Our cake and cupcakes were absolutely delicious and so beautifully done. The cake looked elegant and exactly how we envisioned it, and the cupcakes were a huge hit with our guests—people are still talking about them! Every flavor was fresh, moist, and full of flavor. On top of that, the bakery was easy to work with and delivered everything perfectly. It was the sweet finish to an already perfect day.

September 2025

After calling a few bakeries to order my wedding cake, we found Just Like Magic. They were super friendly, creative and affordable. They had us come in to try different flavors at no cost (which was hard to do as all of the flavors were amazing). If you are looking for a speciality cake or delicious cupcakes, this is the place!!
(We ended up with the salted caramel cake...YUM!!) Our guests raved about how cute and tasty the cake was.
(Our wedding was at a...

July 2025

Went to pick up my 10am order. Finally after 40 minutes the order was ready. As a courtesy, one would think a cup of coffee or pastry could be offered while I waited. I did receive $50 off the order bc I had to wait. It would have been nice to receive an explanation early on what the problem
Was. Wild I go back? Eh! Maybe

June 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Stroudsburg, PA

Just Like Magic Bakery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Just Like Magic Bakery