We ordered a cake for my daughter’s 6th birthday party and it was delicious and SO beautiful!
We could not be happier—it was easy to order, ready promptly, and again, so beautiful and tasted so good. Thank you!!
Jon Edwards
Delicious cookies and a nice atmosphere. Qaint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shawn Covell
Under new ownership. Improvement all around! New owner is WONDERFUL! Low carb breads and pizza shells Do yourself a favor and go to WARNERS
Low carb pizza crust is such a great idea! The Oreo cookies they’ve had lately are soo good also! Everything is affordable and everybody loves a Warner treat as a gift!
Ryan Rubaker
They have the best chocolate flavor we have ever had plus the frosting is great. Cookies and all baked goods are delicious. Our sons birthday cake for his second birthday was the coolest and dont mind paying the extra for top of the line.
We were looking for individual cinnamon rolls. They only sold them by the package. Personally, I was disappointed. We stopped there because of the reviews. Unfortunately, we left as there was much to choose from
J C
Great bakery. The only regrets you'll have, is that you didn't buy more when you were there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Jodi Hudak Vallecorsa
Best sugar cookies ever!!! Hilary is great. Titusville is lucky to have this bakery in their town.
Bethany
We love this small town bakery with homemade deliciousness that takes me back to my childhood. We agree that they have the best cookies we've ever had. They are known for their smiley face cookies (the original) that the Eat 'n Park restaurant chain took its inspiration from when they made their own version of the smiley face cookie. Warner's also can do online delivery orders now to Pittsburgh and anywhere. These cookies don't last long in our house, they're too delicious!
Stopped at the Tionesta Market for cream stick donuts that we use to love. They were tiny and smelled badly like old dirty frying oil! Not edible.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Chelsea Peeples
I absolutely love being able to come into this bakery after a long and tiring day at school to get good quality cookies and pastries! The servers are always so kind and willing to help with all of your requests. On a side note, I also loved being able to decorate my own cookies during Christmastime, it was a very fun experience for me and my family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies, Birthday Cake
Jody Welton
I was not impressed. One, my husband ordered a week in advance only to be told they forgot, come back later. When he was leaving the second time, they tell him, by the way we put buttercream frosting on your banana cream pie. What? I have never heard of frosting on pie, though, I would give it a try. After getting a piece I noticed 95% of the pie was frosting. The frosting turned out to be way to thick and sweet, couldn't eat (though to be fair, I hate really sweet stuff, especially buttercream). The filling ended up being more of a whipped cream pudding, which wasn't to bad, but not great, and the crust unfortunately didn't save it because it wasn't cooked all through.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jeremiah Shepherd
I stopped in earlier today and inquired about a specific type of cookie, hoping for pickup tomorrow. I was told that 24 hours is not enough notice for an order, which is not a big deal. The fellow at the desk said that they would have some of the specific type of cookie I wanted available at 3pm today, which was great because I could stop by then and Warner's is open until 6pm on Fridays according to Google (and their sign on the front door). I stopped in at 3:02pm today and for whatever reason, they were closed.
We ordered a cake for my daughter’s 6th birthday party and it was delicious and SO beautiful! We could not be happier—it was easy to order, ready promptly, and again, so beautiful and tasted so good. Thank you!!
Delicious cookies and a nice atmosphere. Qaint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Under new ownership.
Improvement all around!
New owner is WONDERFUL!
Low carb breads and pizza shells
Do yourself a favor and go to WARNERS
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies, Birthday Cake, Cookie, Cupcake, Wedding Cake
Low carb pizza crust is such a great idea! The Oreo cookies they’ve had lately are soo good also! Everything is affordable and everybody loves a Warner treat as a gift!
They have the best chocolate flavor we have ever had plus the frosting is great. Cookies and all baked goods are delicious. Our sons birthday cake for his second birthday was the coolest and dont mind paying the extra for top of the line.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies, Birthday Cake, Brownie, Smiley Cookie
New decor is very nice bakery is great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies, Baklava, Smiley Cookie
We were looking for individual cinnamon rolls. They only sold them by the package. Personally, I was disappointed. We stopped there because of the reviews. Unfortunately, we left as there was much to choose from
Great bakery. The only regrets you'll have, is that you didn't buy more when you were there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Best sugar cookies ever!!! Hilary is great. Titusville is lucky to have this bakery in their town.
We love this small town bakery with homemade deliciousness that takes me back to my childhood. We agree that they have the best cookies we've ever had. They are known for their smiley face cookies (the original) that the Eat 'n Park restaurant chain took its inspiration from when they made their own version of the smiley face cookie. Warner's also can do online delivery orders now to Pittsburgh and anywhere. These cookies don't last long in our house, they're too delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped at the Tionesta Market for cream stick donuts that we use to love. They were tiny and smelled badly like old dirty frying oil! Not edible.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
I absolutely love being able to come into this bakery after a long and tiring day at school to get good quality cookies and pastries! The servers are always so kind and willing to help with all of your requests. On a side note, I also loved being able to decorate my own cookies during Christmastime, it was a very fun experience for me and my family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies, Birthday Cake
I was not impressed. One, my husband ordered a week in advance only to be told they forgot, come back later. When he was leaving the second time, they tell him, by the way we put buttercream frosting on your banana cream pie. What? I have never heard of frosting on pie, though, I would give it a try. After getting a piece I noticed 95% of the pie was frosting. The frosting turned out to be way to thick and sweet, couldn't eat (though to be fair, I hate really sweet stuff, especially buttercream). The filling ended up being more of a whipped cream pudding, which wasn't to bad, but not great, and the crust unfortunately didn't save it because it wasn't cooked all through.
Food: 1
Service: 1
I stopped in earlier today and inquired about a specific type of cookie, hoping for pickup tomorrow. I was told that 24 hours is not enough notice for an order, which is not a big deal. The fellow at the desk said that they would have some of the specific type of cookie I wanted available at 3pm today, which was great because I could stop by then and Warner's is open until 6pm on Fridays according to Google (and their sign on the front door). I stopped in at 3:02pm today and for whatever reason, they were closed.
Service: 1
Best homemade bread!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Loading...