I found very little to enjoy here. As a retired professional baker myself, I understand what is from scratch and what is not. We stopped here to check it out a few weeks back. It's the only real bakery in town, which I imagine is the only reason why it is still open. It is very cutely decorated, but it's all style and no substance. The girl at the front desk was more interested on being on her phone than helping us with our order. The shelves were mostly empty. Behind the counter looked filthy, with crumbs and icing caked on the tables even though it looked like nothing was currently being prepared. We should have walked out. We ordered a few donuts, an apple dumpling, and a few packed items that were left on the shelves. The cinnamon rolls were over proofed or needed to be baked in a larger aluminum pan since they were spiraling out of the container, which made them dry inside and they had lost most of the filling which is the best part. Most of the filling had settled in the bottom of the pan. The icing tasted awful, so so sweet. We had the maple flavor. The donuts were gross. You could tell the icing on both the donuts and the rolls came out of a tub that was purchased at a restaurant supply store and not made in house. It was overly sweet and ruined what could otherwise have been a decent dessert. The apple dumpling was at one point definitely frozen and then baked. I am not convinced it was ever made in house. It was horrible, absolutely inedible and it went straight in the bin. The packaged goods were okay, on the verge of being stale, but edible. Altogether, it was a disappointing experience and we won't be back. It's a shame that this town only has this option for baked goods. Why bother taking so many short cuts and then call yourself a bakery? Hopefully some competition will sort it out someday.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Apple Dumpling, Doughnut
Sicilian Girl
My first visit here and glad I stopped by. Only got 6 cookies but they were very good. I was hoping for some rosettes but they were sold out. I will definitely be returning when in Titusville.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wendy Hodapp
HIGHLY RECOMMEND - Hilary is such a talented baker and cake decorator. She made my daughter's wedding cake and it was stunning and delicious. Definitely a 10 out of 10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kasey Archer
We enjoy Warners and she has not disappointed in the past, from cookies to cakes. This occasion we needed a gluten and dairy free cake for a birthday girl with allergies to both… let us tell you hands down the BEST gluten/dairy free dessert we have ever had! Spot on delicious! 100% recomend for every sweet treat you may need allergy it not!
Dusty H
I am very grateful that this new owner is able to carry on this iconic bakery, and it's a beautiful local gem in Titusville. The cookies are delicious and the legendary Long Johns with maple icing are banging good!
I just don't understand those who leave a 1-star review; it's just mind-boggling.
Warner's Bakery rocks and keep up the great work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Gluten-Free Cupcake, Smiley Cookie, Sugar Cookies, Sheet Cake, Brownie, Hot Dog Buns, Orange Cookie
Lime Fluff
They used to be amazing. Last years I’ve went in they’d be in the back baking. I learned recently by one of the workers that they no longer make anything there. They buy everything premade. They frost the cookies in house but that isn’t a bakery.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ferrytale Event Designs
I am a wedding coordinator and had the pleasure to have back to back weekends working with Hilary! She is so great to work with and her desserts are just stunning! Absolutely recommend!
Andrea Hirosky
Easy to work with. A mixup left them putting my order double together the day before I needed it for my daughter’s 16th birthday. Beautiful double layer cake. They had it done by the next day and it was beautiful and tasted amazing!
Birthday cake was delicious and decorated exactly how I wanted!!!!
Dan Bubenheim
They do not even sell Donuts. Plus prices on every thing are ridiculous high. i bought a Bearclaw that was very small and so hard, I could hardly bite it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Gregory Michaels
New to the area. I was excited to go to Warner’s after looking at the menu. Now I’ve never walked into a bakery that didn’t have that heavenly smell, but there was no bakery smell. The shelves were mostly bare with hardly anything available that they advertise. 1 loaf of bread and one pack of hot dog buns. There were 2 girls working but I didn’t smell anything baking? I bought the smallest apple dumpling I’ve ever seen for 5$, a packaged piece of Balaklava and a cookie for a 10$ total! I guess the big draw is the Smiley cookies that I can get at Eat n Park or make myself. I won’t be back. I’ll stick with Giant Eagle Just a follow up. We come from Butler County, Pa. We are used to walking by the old Stanley’s bakery. You could smell the goodness from 2 blocks away. Apple dumpling - mushy, stale and the wrong kind of apple used Orange cookie - was just a plain cookie, no orange taste, smeared with old icing Balaclava - was obviously not home made. My wife threw half of her half away! I see this is the only bakery in town so I’m guessing that’s how they stay afloat? If there’s no bakery smell then maybe not much is being baked there?
Jacquelyn Kyle
We ordered a cake for my daughter’s 6th birthday party and it was delicious and SO beautiful!
We could not be happier—it was easy to order, ready promptly, and again, so beautiful and tasted so good. Thank you!!
Food is wonderful and staff is always amazing and friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gluten-Free Cupcake, Smiley Cookie, Sugar Cookies, Brownie, Orange Cookie
Smile cookies are delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I found very little to enjoy here. As a retired professional baker myself, I understand what is from scratch and what is not. We stopped here to check it out a few weeks back. It's the only real bakery in town, which I imagine is the only reason why it is still open. It is very cutely decorated, but it's all style and no substance. The girl at the front desk was more interested on being on her phone than helping us with our order. The shelves were mostly empty. Behind the counter looked filthy, with crumbs and icing caked on the tables even though it looked like nothing was currently being prepared. We should have walked out. We ordered a few donuts, an apple dumpling, and a few packed items that were left on the shelves. The cinnamon rolls were over proofed or needed to be baked in a larger aluminum pan since they were spiraling out of the container, which made them dry inside and they had lost most of the filling which is the best part. Most of the filling had settled in the bottom of the pan. The icing tasted awful, so so sweet. We had the maple flavor. The donuts were gross. You could tell the icing on both the donuts and the rolls came out of a tub that was purchased at a restaurant supply store and not made in house. It was overly sweet and ruined what could otherwise have been a decent dessert. The apple dumpling was at one point definitely frozen and then baked. I am not convinced it was ever made in house. It was horrible, absolutely inedible and it went straight in the bin. The packaged goods were okay, on the verge of being stale, but edible. Altogether, it was a disappointing experience and we won't be back. It's a shame that this town only has this option for baked goods. Why bother taking so many short cuts and then call yourself a bakery? Hopefully some competition will sort it out someday.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Apple Dumpling, Doughnut
My first visit here and glad I stopped by. Only got 6 cookies but they were very good. I was hoping for some rosettes but they were sold out. I will definitely be returning when in Titusville.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
HIGHLY RECOMMEND - Hilary is such a talented baker and cake decorator. She made my daughter's wedding cake and it was stunning and delicious. Definitely a 10 out of 10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We enjoy Warners and she has not disappointed in the past, from cookies to cakes. This occasion we needed a gluten and dairy free cake for a birthday girl with allergies to both… let us tell you hands down the BEST gluten/dairy free dessert we have ever had! Spot on delicious! 100% recomend for every sweet treat you may need allergy it not!
I am very grateful that this new owner is able to carry on this iconic bakery, and it's a beautiful local gem in Titusville. The cookies are delicious and the legendary Long Johns with maple icing are banging good!
I just don't understand those who leave a 1-star review; it's just mind-boggling.
Warner's Bakery rocks and keep up the great work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Gluten-Free Cupcake, Smiley Cookie, Sugar Cookies, Sheet Cake, Brownie, Hot Dog Buns, Orange Cookie
They used to be amazing. Last years I’ve went in they’d be in the back baking. I learned recently by one of the workers that they no longer make anything there. They buy everything premade. They frost the cookies in house but that isn’t a bakery.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
I am a wedding coordinator and had the pleasure to have back to back weekends working with Hilary! She is so great to work with and her desserts are just stunning! Absolutely recommend!
Easy to work with. A mixup left them putting my order double together the day before I needed it for my daughter’s 16th birthday. Beautiful double layer cake. They had it done by the next day and it was beautiful and tasted amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Birthday cake was delicious and decorated exactly how I wanted!!!!
They do not even sell Donuts. Plus prices on every thing are ridiculous high. i bought a Bearclaw that was very small and so hard, I could hardly bite it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
New to the area. I was excited to go to Warner’s after looking at the menu. Now I’ve never walked into a bakery that didn’t have that heavenly smell, but there was no bakery smell. The shelves were mostly bare with hardly anything available that they advertise. 1 loaf of bread and one pack of hot dog buns.
There were 2 girls working but I didn’t smell anything baking? I bought the smallest apple dumpling I’ve ever seen for 5$, a packaged piece of Balaklava and a cookie for a 10$ total! I guess the big draw is the Smiley cookies that I can get at Eat n Park or make myself. I won’t be back. I’ll stick with Giant Eagle
Just a follow up.
We come from Butler County, Pa. We are used to walking by the old Stanley’s bakery. You could smell the goodness from 2 blocks away.
Apple dumpling - mushy, stale and the wrong kind of apple used
Orange cookie - was just a plain cookie, no orange taste, smeared with old icing
Balaclava - was obviously not home made. My wife threw half of her half away!
I see this is the only bakery in town so I’m guessing that’s how they stay afloat?
If there’s no bakery smell then maybe not much is being baked there?
We ordered a cake for my daughter’s 6th birthday party and it was delicious and SO beautiful! We could not be happier—it was easy to order, ready promptly, and again, so beautiful and tasted so good. Thank you!!
Delicious cookies and a nice atmosphere. Qaint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...