23 Best Italian Restaurants near Weatherly

“The building has been there for many years but these new owners take food seriously! They are always rushing behind the counter but the food is SO worth it. It has its busy times which is to be expected. If you are in the area I would 110% recommend trying something

Parking: So, this is no fault of the eatery as they do not own the parking lot BUT it is very pot hole filled. There are barely visible lines, and it's not the best to drive into

Wheelchair accessibility: There are 0 stairs and the doorway is unobstructed“

“If I’m going to eat out, I want food that surpasses what my own kitchen can make. I am delighted and humbled with each bite when eating at the Mansion House. Love love love their take on home cooked Italian cuisine and look forward to each visit.“

“yes 100%. this is so amazing food and very nice atmosphere. if you never stop there and try this place ...-sorry guys ...you're missed a lot“

“Best pizza and cheesesteaks in the Beaver Meadows / Tresckow area! You will not be disappointed!“

“Booked a private gathering (40+ people) with Macaluso’s a few months ago. From start to finish their staff did a great job. I don’t write reviews often but when I do they are deserving. Pricing was reasonable and the food was awesome. Thank for your attention to detail and an awesome meal.“

“Excellent [Original] Excellent“

“Great people. Great food. Especially like the way they treat there patons and staff“

“You can’t go wrong with anything you get.. it is all delicious“

“Only place in town that I’ll order food from! Love all the girls there! 💕“

“It had been a long time since I had real homemade Lasagna and it was so good that I had to clean my plate. It was really close to Grandma's sauce. I remember seeing the smile on her face when she saw that I had cleaned my plate.“

“Disappointed with my most recent experience. I come here a lot and always did because it was always very consistent and I always knew I would get a good meal and service. Well last night the service was not good but I can understand that. There were few waitresses on and it was busy. To start we ordered the long hots for an appetizer but they came out as just long hots and not stuffed as it said under starters. When asked about this we were told that the plain long hots are an appetizer and the stuffed ones are an entree but I looked at the menu and could only find the stuffed long hots. Bread was not given to us, we had to ask for it which normally isn’t the case it usually comes out right after your order is taken. I had ordered the antipasto with steak and they used to be huge. Last night it was small and there was barely any lunch meat on it. I also ordered it with steak. They used to be normal steak cuts, the steak on it last night was over cooked and looked like the scraps I cut off a steak to save for my dog. I also asked for no olives and balsamic dressing and it came out covered in black olives and with Italian dressing. The waitress also took my salad while I was still eating it and asked if I was still eating it while she already had it in her hand. Very disappointed and don’t know if we’ll be back for a while.“

“WOW! Just got the Chicken, Bacon & Mozzarella. Best I ever had. Will be seeing again“

“Fun place to get together.“

“We ate breakfast there four times while on vacation. The food was very good and the wait staff very friendly. We will be back next year.“

“love me some sorrento. It's our go to. pizza and antipasto. the antipast has definitely gotten smaller the last year or two but still great. The Italian hoagies could use more meat but still are great. The dinners are always a winner too! Great service and delivery as well.“

“hands down the best food in town!!“

“Great little hidden gem! Pizza is awesome, cheesesteaks are the best around! Everything is homemade and fresh! Would highly recommend this place to anyone! Prices are more than reasonable. Finally a good place to get a delicious and affordable lunch or dinner! They also do catering for private events! Awesome place!“

“Excellent pizza, garlic knots and Cheesesteak!“

“Fantastic service even better food absolutely love it here“

“I can’t say enough good things about Charlie Weavers. The cozy atmosphere, the super friendly staff, the amazing food. This restaurant truly is a hidden gem. I highly recommend!“

“excellent family run business with outstanding service and top of the line selection of the finest Italian food.“

“Think they are new owners. Had the large sweet sauce round pie and it was incredible. Only thing is it looks odd but a different kind of pizza than it’s normally made. I couldn’t stop eating it forced myself to stop. Will definitely get it again I scored it a high nine“

“Really good food and quick service!“