Tony's Italian Cuisine

3 Main Street, Wellsboro
(570) 724-2090

Recent Reviews

Sort by
gavin magnani

Food was pretty good taste wise but the price for the service and quality of food is insane. our waitress was super nice but the owner was very much the opposite of cordial, we walked and he looked at us as if we were stupid and said “you can sit” in a condescending manner. they use a canned sauce, that you would see in a school or hospital. there was a total of 25 even at the bottom of my check and when she rung my food up it came to 21.73 after i had already given her a 15% tip. they also overcharged my co-worker. he payed about 50 bucks for a medium stromboli and a thing of cheese fries. all in all not worth it at all. if you want to spend your money go to get Fox’s right down the road.

Jamson Zimmerman

Excellent Italian food.

Parker Warren

Best prices. Very clean inside. Helpful staff. Felt oddly at home here. Would definitely recommend.

Potatoes Are-Amazing

My husband and I visited on a whim a few years ago while on an anniversary trip. Passing through whole traveling, i had to stop again. I wanted to grab food to bring home with me for everyone simce we talked abut how good it was before. I ordered a pizza and stromboli, and ordered ravioli to have there while I waited. Served with bread and salad. It was fantastic and very filling. Ive seen a few reviews mention pricing it is more than your chains, but it is also on par with pretty much every similar small business establishment, so it is priced fairly. For how filling it can be, its a good deal.
Now the food I brought home...i buckler the pizza and stromboli in, and had a travel cooler for the tiramisu. The kids were thrilled that the tiramisu wasn't overwhelming. They felt it tasted like it should. Both the pizza and stromboli were fabulous even reheated. I love so much that neither were greasy, even with extra cheese, meats, etc.
My favorite part, though? It is advertised as italian cuisine, ane it does not ruin it by overcompensation like a lot of other places do. The food we had last time and this time was thoroughly enjoyable. The service was great. Being from out of town, i liked watching the interactions between the restaurant and their regulars.
The dining area was clean. I loved the photos! Its small, but situated so that there is plenty of seating room without being cramped. I look forward to when a drive brings me back through so that I can stop again.

Karen Hamblin

Best subs, pizza, and fries!

tom walrath

We love Tony's. ❤️

Sandy Worthington

I’ve never had a bad meal there ! Everything is delicious!

richard stevens

We go there every time we are in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rigatoni in Meat Sauce, Pizza, Small Calzone

Ka' Rivera

i'm from outta town ... was told their food was good.
all the family enjoyed their food , the service was great and very friendly. thank you ❣️

Parking: there was a lot on the same block.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak

Ken Grammes

Parking: Use store parking lot on side and walk street parking is a pain to get in or out .if picking up

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Anonymous

This is the best pizza for 100 miles!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

1HDOilfield Dad

its a nice restaurant with good staff and the food tastes good. they use a pizza sauce thats chunkier than i like myself, but its still good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Carol Fagley

First time there.. food was super good

Brandon Rossell ON THE MARK ARCHERY

Their Sicilian pizza is top-notch.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza, Cheese Steak, Large Pizza

Julie Glover

The waitress was awesome! Very helpful and friendly. Fries were hot and crispy, and we loved the cheese steak but thought it should've been bigger. Yummy cannoli dessert! Perfect place for a great lunch.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak

Loading...