went to Pietro’s Prime for a birthday dinner and was very disappointed. The food was terrible—so much so that when they forgot the broccoli we ordered, we didn’t even bother reminding them because everything else was already so bad., the service was poor and inattentive, what’s the point asking if we are celebrating any special occasion if they do not offer a small cake Definitely not the kind of place I would recommend for a special occasion
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Chris Aloisio
Pietros is always amazing. Mike takes phenomenal care of his guests and makes the experience top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Douglas
Good food and service a bit pricey for what you get.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
P L
Very good restaurant. Filet and baked potato was great! Cool atmosphere, friendly staff. Great drink options. Check it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
S D
They accommodated my preference for meat prep and got it right. Apps were good and plentiful. Service was prompt
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael
Outstanding all the way around! Great cocktails, table service. Michael is an outstanding waiter. We were celebrating and he went over and above to accommodate Pietro's service which made our evening very special and enjoyable. The food was delicious and atmosphere outstanding. Highly recommended restaurant for a night out.
Stacey Wall
Shrimp Lejon was killer. Nice filet too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Colin
Pietro's Prime Steak Salad is a classic! Beautifully served steak slices over a leafy salad with mushrooms. It's so good I can't persuade myself it to try anything else!
John Amour
Love this place! Always a great experience with amazing food, drink and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian
Great food. Great service. Loud (not a quiet romantic place) but the atmosphere is good. Will definitely go back.
We went for our 23rd Anniversary dinner and the choice was excellent from arrival. Our server Gina was incredible. She was energetic and knowledgeable without being too intrusive. A perfect blend. The food was fantastic. Try the Cajun Delmonico and the 8oz filet. This is a neighborhood must in the boro and never loses its fastball.
Michelle
Last night's adventure to Pietro's was ultimate! As always we have a fabulous time with wonderful friends, awesome food, the most incredible staff within the building, and of course the live music for Wednesday night courtesy of John Grecia! I had a bit of a lighter fare for dinner last night with just some potato skins and a beautiful wedge salad that they were kind enough to chop down for me. As always the chopped salad is perfectly delicious just the right amount of dressing blue cheese and bacon etc. This was my first time having the potato skins and let me tell you they don't skimp on the bacon and the cheese and the overall goodness! The staff absolutely deserved the chocolate chip cookies that I delivered there to them last night. They are sweets for the absolute sweet of staff. I told Mark last night that I go to restaurants and sometimes I don't even get half of the service that these guys go for and they go above and beyond. I really would love to encourage anybody who wants to go to Pietro's to please just go. It is the most amazing atmosphere and everybody is so awesome there.
Carolyn
Didn't live up to previous visits. We didn't see much of our server after she got busy and they didn't have a lot of other people coming around to pour wine or fill water glasses.
Jane Marie
What a wonderful experience. It was our friends Birthday. We were in a very nice room. Which was absolutely perfect. Our waiter was the best waiter I have had in years. Can't say enough about the restaurant and the food. The mushroom soup and the lobster Mac & cheese I had was to die for. My friends all loved their food. The highlight after a wonderful meal was the desserts. My favorite was the chocolate cake with cheese cake in the center. I would go there just for the desserts.
Edwin
Food and drinks were absolutely delicious. Very well prepared and served in a timely manner. Our server at times was bogged down with a large table, but he still managed to make it by and make sure everything was OK. One of our favorite places to enjoy dinner and we'll definitely be back.
went to Pietro’s Prime for a birthday dinner and was very disappointed. The food was terrible—so much so that when they forgot the broccoli we ordered, we didn’t even bother reminding them because everything else was already so bad., the service was poor and inattentive, what’s the point asking if we are celebrating any special occasion if they do not offer a small cake Definitely not the kind of place I would recommend for a special occasion
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Pietros is always amazing. Mike takes phenomenal care of his guests and makes the experience top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food and service a bit pricey for what you get.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good restaurant. Filet and baked potato was great! Cool atmosphere, friendly staff. Great drink options. Check it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They accommodated my preference for meat prep and got it right. Apps were good and plentiful. Service was prompt
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outstanding all the way around! Great cocktails, table service. Michael is an outstanding waiter. We were celebrating and he went over and above to accommodate Pietro's service which made our evening very special and enjoyable. The food was delicious and atmosphere outstanding. Highly recommended restaurant for a night out.
Shrimp Lejon was killer. Nice filet too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pietro's Prime Steak Salad is a classic! Beautifully served steak slices over a leafy salad with mushrooms. It's so good I can't persuade myself it to try anything else!
Love this place! Always a great experience with amazing food, drink and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food. Great service. Loud (not a quiet romantic place) but the atmosphere is good. Will definitely go back.
Restaurantji Recommends
We went for our 23rd Anniversary dinner and the choice was excellent from arrival. Our server Gina was incredible. She was energetic and knowledgeable without being too intrusive. A perfect blend. The food was fantastic. Try the Cajun Delmonico and the 8oz filet. This is a neighborhood must in the boro and never loses its fastball.
Last night's adventure to Pietro's was ultimate! As always we have a fabulous time with wonderful friends, awesome food, the most incredible staff within the building, and of course the live music for Wednesday night courtesy of John Grecia! I had a bit of a lighter fare for dinner last night with just some potato skins and a beautiful wedge salad that they were kind enough to chop down for me. As always the chopped salad is perfectly delicious just the right amount of dressing blue cheese and bacon etc. This was my first time having the potato skins and let me tell you they don't skimp on the bacon and the cheese and the overall goodness! The staff absolutely deserved the chocolate chip cookies that I delivered there to them last night. They are sweets for the absolute sweet of staff. I told Mark last night that I go to restaurants and sometimes I don't even get half of the service that these guys go for and they go above and beyond. I really would love to encourage anybody who wants to go to Pietro's to please just go. It is the most amazing atmosphere and everybody is so awesome there.
Didn't live up to previous visits. We didn't see much of our server after she got busy and they didn't have a lot of other people coming around to pour wine or fill water glasses.
What a wonderful experience. It was our friends Birthday. We were in a very nice room. Which was absolutely perfect. Our waiter was the best waiter I have had in years. Can't say enough about the restaurant and the food. The mushroom soup and the lobster Mac & cheese I had was to die for. My friends all loved their food. The highlight after a wonderful meal was the desserts. My favorite was the chocolate cake with cheese cake in the center. I would go there just for the desserts.
Food and drinks were absolutely delicious. Very well prepared and served in a timely manner. Our server at times was bogged down with a large table, but he still managed to make it by and make sure everything was OK. One of our favorite places to enjoy dinner and we'll definitely be back.
Loading...