Cenci's Pizzeria & Bar- Wexford

I love this place. Wish I lived closer! Great stop, check it out...

Best pizza and RANCH ever!! Like seriously though, all their food is delicious(mild bone in wings, Italian hoagie, ff, pastas, etc). I pick up my food 80% of the time, but when I've eaten in at the bar ... The bartender was A++! Dining room service is 50/50, depends on the server n how busy they r. But the food is always bangin!

Tried the fish sandwich based upon other reviews and it did not disappoint. The portion size was great. Flavor was good and it was flaky white meat and not greasy.

Service was great. Not so much with the wrap.

Decent atmosphere and food. Service was good but a little slow because there weren’t enough servers. The ones that did attend us were very friendly and attentive

Best cheese steak and pizza is the area.

Maybe it was me. But the food was great. Not an inviting enviorment for strangers...

Great food and open late!

Wexford's best kept secret after 9-10pm. Food til 1:30am. Good 'Burgh' pizza. 12 cut plain under $16 dallah make you halla! Bar is on point. Give them a try yinz.

Oversauced the pizza so the ratio of cheese to sauce was off and cheese was not sticking to the slice. Good flavor, but dough needs improvement to be a 5-star review from a tough pizza-critic. Overall a good slice, but room to improve.

One-Star Review for Cenci’s Pizzeria & Bar

I had a terrible experience at Cenci’s Pizzeria & Bar. I arrived at 1:22 AM after leaving the bar, hoping to get something to eat. When I got there, no one was at the front, so I went to knock on a nearby door to get someone’s attention. A guy finally came out from the back, and the first thing he said was, “Hey, you can’t come behind here.” No greeting, no apology for not being upfront, no “How can I help you?”—just straight to being rude.

After driving 30 minutes to get there because it was the only restaurant open, this was the last thing I wanted to hear. The interaction felt dismissive and unwelcoming, and I couldn’t help but feel like I was treated this way because I’m Black. If I were white, I truly believe the approach would have been much different.

This was an incredibly disappointing experience, and I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone. A little courtesy and respect go a long way, but sadly, I didn’t get either here.

Really…. Never again

The buffalo chicken pizza was amazing. The Italian hoagie was great too, however, the rueben was terrible. The corned beef was burnt and grissley. The bread was also burnt. Very disappointed in that. Waitress was sweet and very efficient.

Best pizza in Wexford

Keep reviewing it as so far this is our family’s favorite pizza place. Wanted to update that Staub is added into our fav list! Garlic knob great.
Still their Steak ranch onion is our #1 to go if we don’t know what to order.

3 years ago : We all love steak ranch onion pizza ! Our favorite !