Sizzler Pizza

429 W 1st St, Williamsburg
(814) 832-3424

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kimberly Westover

Ordered food over the phone. When we went to pick it up “sorry we can only accept cash our card machine isn’t working.” We left to go to an ATM. I got money out that I paid a fee for the machine plus a fee from my bank. Went back and stood there freezing because there was no heat in the building. There was an electric heater but it wasn’t plugged in. The place looked like a dump. I will never go back there again. No sorry for the inconvenience or anything.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

K S

?? ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING!! ??No clue how this place could pass inspection to be in the food handling business. The tiny black bits are not peppers... THEY ARE RODENT DROPPINGS!! ??

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jalynn Fox

terrible

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pablo Otero

The pizza is pretty good!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Sabrina Lynn

Went in with my boyfriend to get some food, looked like ur normal family owned restaurant but when we went to the counter to look at the menu we were stared at the entire time by the young man and young women at the register. It made my boyfriend and I very uncomfortable more deeply there were staring at us. We ordered and the women had a bit of an attitude until I left a tip then she was very sweet and said thank you. Food didn’t take too long, we ate and the chicken tenders were very overcooked. After i ate the food I began feeling extremely nauseous and after an hour i was laying on the ground next to my toilet throwing up profusely so don’t recommend eating here.

Stephanie Morgan

Order takeout February 2023 and the reason I am listing three stars is because I have never paid for a a pizza and on the receipt it shows medium pizza thin crust charge $10.50 that's just for the pizza no toppings. Then I get charged $1. 80 per topping that's for pepperoni a dollar 1.80 sausage 1.80 ham 1.80 bacon, 1.80 onions 1.80 for green peppers. At most pizza places you pay one price for a meat lovers. Since when did a medium pizza cost almost $19!!!!

Julia Jones

Enjoyed our food!

Steve Tinker

My #1 place for pizza.. great friendly service and consistent flavor.. keep up the great hospitality guys. 😃

Single Dad

Got a large pizza, dude at the counter was nice. Kinda run down and shady looking. No hair nets or any type of protection. Surprised they are still open. Decent if you’re hungry, considering it’s one of few food places in town. Would rather drive 30 minutes for Best Way. Miss OIP.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Avery Corrigan

Poor service. Ordered 40 minutes before closing and was told no pizza, subs, or salads. Only fryer food.

ValeenJosh McCahan

Good pizza and sandwich place

Timothy Stetser

Good pizza, and service.

Janice Plautz - Bless

Stopped in for dinner after a ride on the rail trail. Great stop!

its steeve

My #1 place for pizza.. great friendly service and consistent flavor.. keep up the great hospitality guys. ?

Susan Miller

Great food and sevice! Friendly employees!

Loading...