Federal Hill Pizza

495 Main Street, Warren
(401) 245-0045

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cassandra Brimmer

The GF pizza is hands down the best in the state and one of the few that is made from
scratch! Call before you go because it’s not always available, but when it is, run and get it while you can. GF eaters, I promise, you’ve never tasted dough this delicious. 🤤 It’s worth the drive.

david carey

This is gormet pizza!!! Owner was very friendly and cheese special for $9.99 is a great deal! Definitely recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Great Pizza

Paula Cummings

We loved the egg plant grinder .It was fabulous .He went back 2 other times after that and it was closed .I called 11 :30 am and someone answered and said they would open for 1 pm .Brought my sister who was visiting from Seattle .I live in Somerset .When we arrived for 1:00 it was not open .I called at 12:30 pm on July 30 still no answer .How can you run a business even with good food if you are closed so much .Disappointed

Joe Prew

Stopped in with my daughter and had the best chicken parm sandwich—if not the best I’ve ever had. They use pizza dough as the bread, and it was incredible. The staff was also super friendly to both my daughter and me. Can’t wait to come back and try the owner’s favorite pizza next. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rhea Vedro

Delicious!

david grinvalsky

The pizza here is delicious and healthy... if you're looking for pizza that is not soaked in grease , brick oven is what you want and Federal hill is your friend 👌

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andy Z

Great Neapolitan style pizza. Perfect amount of cornicione. Sauce is basic and delicious. The tasty cheese on the margarita was a tad undercooked or too thick for the bake time. Bonus got to watch a movie being filmed outside.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bristol Maryott

Very good & wonderful service from Elena. We appreciated that they were dog friendly & let us sit at their outside tables with our dog. We will be coming back!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rachelle Schulte

I visited tonight after moving out of the area. No where near what it used to be. The wings were subpar and slightly soggy , the pizza was like many of the other reviews stated, floppy, watery, and certainly undercooked….just not good. I will say the Caesar salad was 10/10. Service was not overly welcoming. Paid at the register she didn’t state the total, didn’t say thanks for coming, or anything a hospitable person would normally
State when closing out a customer…. Such a let down because I used to love this spot when I lived in Warren.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Deborah Botelho

When you walk in the waitress greeted us with a genuine smile so I knew this was going to be a great place. It's a hidden gem! The decor is very simple and very cozy given it a warm relaxing vibe. The food was exceptional! We ordered the BBQ Pizza and the Buffalo Pizza and it was hands down the best pizza I ever ate! Even my son said the same thing! It's crispy and a good serving size and the pedestals they are served on just adds to the charm. The chicken wings were also crispy and delicious served with the side you choose and the fries came in this huge bowl and again were crispy and delicious! The red headed waitress was friendly and quick to serve! Asked if we needed anything and very accommodating even when it was busy! I also had a non alcoholic drink and it was wonderful. It had like this hint of ginger. You know it's a good place when you are still thinking of the drink you had and are excited about your leftovers! We definitely will be back and highly recommend!

Carlene Ahern

We had 12 people (including 4 children under 5), and they were very accommodating. We ordered and were served in speedy time. Service was exceptional, and the food unbelievable! I am Italian and it definitely reminded me of my roots! The pizza was delicious. The rice balls and meatballs to die for! Dessert, muah! If you get a chance to try this hidden gem, it’s worth the trip!

Joey Diogo

Excellent pizza and great service by the Tiana herself. God bless Manzo and god bless america

Mason Luther

tiana was a wonderful waiter. 10/10 i recommend

Andrea Correia

My family of four dined in recently and it was wonderful. Food was really good and we did not wait long to get our food. The server Tiana was very friendly and attentive. We will definitely eat here again.

Adam Melville

The service seems great even on a busy night. The pizza dough was delicious. The toppings, however, were not as good. This appears to have been an off night. The BBQ chicken looked so good, but the sauce was a bit overbearing. The Greek was a bit too salty as well. After posting my honest review, the restaurant reached out and I will be trying them again. I’ll update the review then. What great service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Loading...