Bay Street Deli & Catering

112 Bay St, Westerly
(401) 596-6606

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Noah Michalski

Food was exquisite and staff very nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jess C

Love the Carousel turkey sandwich, have it every time I visit

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Graham Young

I came to go skimboarding at East Beach and thought it'd be good to grab a sandwich here. I didn't expect anything special. I got a basic turkey sandwich with lettuce, tomato, and white bread. 11.99. You can't mess that up right?

Holy f***** **** was I wrong. The turkey was oddly rigid and clearly old, smelled weird. The lettuce was piled up way too high on the bottom (???) of the bread, the tomato was almost nonexistent. The bread itself was soggy, wet, and cold, untoasted, and despite its absolutely sordid condition, had the wonderful quality of being stale and soggy at the same time. Brilliant work. It fell apart the moment I unwrapped it.

I could've made a better sandwich in my dorm with dining hall bread and another piece of bread in the middle.

The only reason I didn't walk back and request a refund or remake was because I had parked up the hill and didn't wanna waste their time because I think any place of such pathetic quality is also not going to give you a refund if you ask politely.

I'm a college student who works two full time jobs just to survive, 7 days a week. This was my first day off since the Spring semester ended in early May. I got some banging ice cream from St Clair's Annex after so the experience was not ruined but this "sandwich" was so profoundly atrocious, so appallingly sad, it stood to derail what fun I had. And for 11.99? Dystopian tbh

Service was friendly.

Atmosphere was oppressively cramped and lowkey smelly.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Gerald Leddy

My favorite Rhode Island Clam Chowder. It is simple and delicious!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Jay P

Ordered a delicious Italian sandwich today for lunch and a cup of chowder. Great sized sandwich, and flavorful chowder. 2 tables sidewalk side, and a few inside. Service was quick, and personable. Will be back next time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maria G

Delicious lobster roll...?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Rolls

Lisa Orourke

We walked into this deli one summer and the food is fabulous! I got a Ruben on Rye(Bay St Ruben) and now I get it all the time that we stop in …. It’s absolutely delicious… it’s not dry it’s so very moist every time ty !!! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Quinn Jones

Very basic, no-frills, sandwich shop occupying a narrow store front between fancier bistros and shops. Zero ambiance, good food, great prices and service.

Saul Dingfelder

Best lobster rolls in the area. Great, family run breakfast and lunch spot.

Samantha Birks

Was not even a customer of this deli and had a bad experience. Early in the morning and not many people in watch hill yet, and I wanted to take a seat at a table in front of the deli and drink my coffee. Was immediately yelled at to not sit at the table (most likely because I did not purchase anything from the deli). That experience alone made me never want to be a customer of that establishment. The man in that deli needs to learn how to be nicer to people.

Ian MacFarlane

Best lobster rolls in town!

Heavenzdesiangel

This is a nice little deli to pick up some sandwiches and drinks before heading to watch hill beach. However, we got the large lobster roll which in my opinion is more like a small/medium and not worth the price, maybe try one if the other sandwiches.

Lexi Jones

Extremely rude encounter with owner. Tried to kick us out for taking a bite of a scone while waiting for the food we ordered.

Callahan Kelly

Went in for coffee and it was the best cup of coffee I have had in a long time. I won’t go anywhere else now in Watch Hill for my morning coffee when I visit family.

Kevin Bogle

Excellent lobster rolls! #1 in RI. Be careful about parking at The Watch Hill Inn - less than good customer service. Look for other options.

Loading...

Bay Street Deli & Catering

112 Bay St, Westerly, RI 02891
(401) 596-6606