Chicken Parm, and chicken over a garden salad are my two go to meals.
James Wolfe
Best pizza (and especially the lasagna) in New England!
Shana White
Food was good, not like it use to be though.
G S
We sat and ate with coats on as did everyone else. The owner came by to check and I told him the food was good but I would have a better experience if we didnt have to eat with our coats on. The side door is wide open propped with a runner. The reply I got (as he obviously didn’t listen to a word I said ) was that it will be warmer out soon. I’ll go elsewhere. What kind of manager leaves a door blocked wide open when it’ 20 degrees???
scott Hallamore
My wife ordered a large BLT pizza to go on the phone when we picked it up it was a small pizza . The girl at the counter said she got order from her as small . But incorrect just another poor service from supreme and screw up this is just another screw up to ho along with others we have had with them . We keep giving them another chance .
LeLand 3711
We called in for food to be picked up. The person over the phone was so rude it had to been the owner. He said to us it’s the kid or me and after taking half the order he hung up on us. We ordered a salad and a calzone. It was 50$. The salad was as expected. The calzone was a disgrace it was a large pizza flopped in half ….no love. Westerly is pizza we know pizza. Stop this
Stephanie George
Wanted to give you a well deserved compliment! Ordered a couple pizzas tonight and they were absolutely delicious. Thanks for delivering hot pizza on a cold night!
john
First time trying after driving past many times. The owner was extremely friendly. Pizza was great. Look forward to coming back.
Annette Parker
So they made my order incorrect and when I called to complain the owner told me I should go to a psych ward. Do you see mayonnaise and ketchup on this bun because he said he saw it
Nikki
This was my first time trying the food, went simple with a small cheese calzone. Honest review, it was extremely good. Just the perfect amount of cheese and cooked thru. I wasn’t expecting it to be cut, and I liked that. Got extra sauce, small calzone, didn’t really need it but for a large I’m sure you would. I’ll be going back to adventure into other foods for sure. 👍🏻 👌🏻
You don’t get what you pay for next time cover my pizza With pepperoni like I asked, extra the tenant, says to me, what makes you think I didn’t give you extra pepperoni. The tenant says to me. How do you you know I didn’t give you extra pepperoni . Be consistent I never go here.
Ashtyn Belden
We ordered two sandwiches waited a hour for delivery it is a Saturday so that expected the sandwicha we received were subpar for what we paid. No lettuce on the Italian barley meat just sad look the wrap I had was so loose and cut weird it just fell apart. You can't serve food like this it's unacceptable
Food: 1
John Diniz
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Віктор Хариняк
Great service ? Awesome owner Highly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yvonne Swales
Bruschetta was not good at all. Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo wasn't really an Alfredo sauce, but it was okay.
Chicken Parm, and chicken over a garden salad are my two go to meals.
Best pizza (and especially the lasagna) in New England!
Food was good, not like it use to be though.
We sat and ate with coats on as did everyone else. The owner came by to check and I told him the food was good but I would have a better experience if we didnt have to eat with our coats on. The side door is wide open propped with a runner. The reply I got (as he obviously didn’t listen to a word I said ) was that it will be warmer out soon. I’ll go elsewhere. What kind of manager leaves a door blocked wide open when it’ 20 degrees???
My wife ordered a large BLT pizza to go on the phone when we picked it up it was a small pizza . The girl at the counter said she got order from her as small . But incorrect just another poor service from supreme and screw up this is just another screw up to ho along with others we have had with them . We keep giving them another chance .
We called in for food to be picked up. The person over the phone was so rude it had to been the owner. He said to us it’s the kid or me and after taking half the order he hung up on us. We ordered a salad and a calzone. It was 50$. The salad was as expected. The calzone was a disgrace it was a large pizza flopped in half ….no love. Westerly is pizza we know pizza. Stop this
Wanted to give you a well deserved compliment! Ordered a couple pizzas tonight and they were absolutely delicious. Thanks for delivering hot pizza on a cold night!
First time trying after driving past many times. The owner was extremely friendly. Pizza was great. Look forward to coming back.
So they made my order incorrect and when I called to complain the owner told me I should go to a psych ward. Do you see mayonnaise and ketchup on this bun because he said he saw it
This was my first time trying the food, went simple with a small cheese calzone. Honest review, it was extremely good. Just the perfect amount of cheese and cooked thru. I wasn’t expecting it to be cut, and I liked that. Got extra sauce, small calzone, didn’t really need it but for a large I’m sure you would. I’ll be going back to adventure into other foods for sure. 👍🏻 👌🏻
Restaurantji Recommends
You don’t get what you pay for next time cover my pizza
With pepperoni like I asked, extra the tenant, says to me, what makes you think I didn’t give you extra pepperoni. The tenant says to me. How do you you know I didn’t give you extra pepperoni . Be consistent I never go here.
We ordered two sandwiches waited a hour for delivery it is a Saturday so that expected the sandwicha we received were subpar for what we paid. No lettuce on the Italian barley meat just sad look the wrap I had was so loose and cut weird it just fell apart. You can't serve food like this it's unacceptable
Food: 1
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service ?
Awesome owner
Highly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bruschetta was not good at all. Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo wasn't really an Alfredo sauce, but it was okay.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Loading...