First time here. Reminded me of NYC. Loved the owner and the pies. I will be returning to try the Sicilian, soon!
N S.
good food don't recommend anybody to dine in the owner is extremely rude how u mad but im paying
piraterrr
Northeast flavor. Phenomenal crust. I recommend getting a large.
jordan s
I am originally from ny and it is very good pizza taste just like it would back home.
JENNIFER B
NY Giant Pizza 28" and Jalapeno RollImage below shows pizza in the back of a full size 4 door Dodge Ram pickup. Pizza couldn't fit inside the truck. Lol
A Wilson
Wonderful food!The garlic knots were so good and the pizza not only looked good but was good! The two beautiful waitresses were so sweet and did such a great job!
Carolyn O.
If I could give 0 I would we arrived on a Friday night at 720pm chairs were on the table when we asked are you open the rude man assuming the owner said no seating we said your sign says you are open until 8 he said we go home at 8 so we walked out will never return. Very poor customer service skills
Frosty ThaKing
Garlic bread and knots were great. The pizza however was soggy, 10x greasier than actual NY pizza and their buffalo sauce was so hot I could only eat one piece. The cook/cashier laughed after I told him. Will not be back.
John C.
Only been a resident of South Carolina and already found a go to pizza place. So flavorful and filling. Looks like everyone who give this place a poor review never mentions the pizza they complain about salad or service. I come for the pizza and didn't order a salad. The service was good too. I highly recommend this place
1980wildfire
Just ordered two calzones from this place through Bitesquad. We specifically asked for no ricotta cheese to be placed inside, just mozzarella. It was clearly placed in the “special directions” at the bottom of the order. Apparently the cooks can’t read and 42 dollars was just wasted on food we couldn’t even eat. Thanks for ripping is off!
My wife and I have been patrons of New York Pizza for twenty years. (Wow that's a long time) This is the pizza that sets the standard that I judge all other pizzas against. Some came close, but most didn't make the cut. This pizza is absolute perfection.
Maria Mosesman
I’ve been ordering food from NY Pizza for a while now, and being a Jersey girl. I can tell you this is great pizza/ food. I like my pizza well done,and they never fail, even when it’s crazy busy it’s perfect. Thank you for making me feel at home in SC …..Carmen
Roberto Rivera
Buffalo baked wings we're cold at the center,had a slimy rubber texture?. Made them aware about it and they came back less then 2 minutes later with the same wings and I asked if they we're the same and they said no ( lie, unless you can bake wings less then two minutes) they probably microwave it which is Nasty. Also very expensive. 4 *fountain* drinks cost 12 buck's and that's without tax.Not worth the visit avoid this place if you care about your health and being over charged.( And Your welcome for the kind words ??) live long and prosper ??✌?
Nita Leary
The best New York crust and pizza so far in SC! Crust is thin crispy crust with that bread doughy taste and didn't skimp on the toppings either!
jimjager350
This is not NY pizza, more like frozen. Way too much cheese, tasteless crust. Waitress never checked up on us, asked how everything was or thanked us. Dont waste your time or money here.
First time here. Reminded me of NYC. Loved the owner and the pies. I will be returning to try the Sicilian, soon!
good food don't recommend anybody to dine in the owner is extremely rude how u mad but im paying
Northeast flavor. Phenomenal crust. I recommend getting a large.
I am originally from ny and it is very good pizza taste just like it would back home.
NY Giant Pizza 28" and Jalapeno RollImage below shows pizza in the back of a full size 4 door Dodge Ram pickup. Pizza couldn't fit inside the truck. Lol
Wonderful food!The garlic knots were so good and the pizza not only looked good but was good! The two beautiful waitresses were so sweet and did such a great job!
If I could give 0 I would we arrived on a Friday night at 720pm chairs were on the table when we asked are you open the rude man assuming the owner said no seating we said your sign says you are open until 8 he said we go home at 8 so we walked out will never return. Very poor customer service skills
Garlic bread and knots were great. The pizza however was soggy, 10x greasier than actual NY pizza and their buffalo sauce was so hot I could only eat one piece. The cook/cashier laughed after I told him. Will not be back.
Only been a resident of South Carolina and already found a go to pizza place. So flavorful and filling. Looks like everyone who give this place a poor review never mentions the pizza they complain about salad or service. I come for the pizza and didn't order a salad. The service was good too. I highly recommend this place
Just ordered two calzones from this place through Bitesquad. We specifically asked for no ricotta cheese to be placed inside, just mozzarella. It was clearly placed in the “special directions” at the bottom of the order. Apparently the cooks can’t read and 42 dollars was just wasted on food we couldn’t even eat. Thanks for ripping is off!
Restaurantji Recommends
My wife and I have been patrons of New York Pizza for twenty years. (Wow that's a long time) This is the pizza that sets the standard that I judge all other pizzas against. Some came close, but most didn't make the cut. This pizza is absolute perfection.
I’ve been ordering food from NY Pizza for a while now, and being a Jersey girl. I can tell you this is great pizza/ food. I like my pizza well done,and they never fail, even when it’s crazy busy it’s perfect. Thank you for making me feel at home in SC …..Carmen
Buffalo baked wings we're cold at the center,had a slimy rubber texture?. Made them aware about it and they came back less then 2 minutes later with the same wings and I asked if they we're the same and they said no ( lie, unless you can bake wings less then two minutes) they probably microwave it which is Nasty. Also very expensive. 4 *fountain* drinks cost 12 buck's and that's without tax.Not worth the visit avoid this place if you care about your health and being over charged.( And Your welcome for the kind words ??) live long and prosper ??✌?
The best New York crust and pizza so far in SC! Crust is thin crispy crust with that bread doughy taste and didn't skimp on the toppings either!
This is not NY pizza, more like frozen. Way too much cheese, tasteless crust. Waitress never checked up on us, asked how everything was or thanked us. Dont waste your time or money here.