Food: we ordered the Dimi’s Deluxe & a pepperoni and bacon pizza, spinach artichoke dip, and a side of garlic bread. The dough on the pizza was light and fluffy, delicious and filling. The spinach artichoke dip was really good, and it’s served with hot pita bread! Packing the leftovers got a little messy, as there were so many topping on the Dimi’s Deluxe pizza everything started falling off! A small price to pay for the value of the food we ate!
Price: you can easily get away with $10-20 per person, with our appetizer, extra side, & drinks, it was closer to $25 per person ($30 if you include the tip). Pricing was similar to other dine in restaurants, and you get a lot more food to bring home!
Service: the waitress also worked in the kitchen, so service wasn’t the fastest (but also wasn’t slow) while dining in, but she was so polite and patient as we looked over all of the choices and answered all of our questions. As we paid to leave, we had a nice conversation with the manager/owner? I’m not sure of his title, but he mentioned hearing good things about eating the leftover pizza for breakfast due to his sauce recipe. We tried it this morning & he was absolutely correct; the pizza was just as good the next day!
Atmosphere: good music & kind people. There weren’t many other people in the dining room with us, but everyone seemed kind and respectful. You can see into the kitchen area & see them making your food which was cool. It felt like a homey mom & pop pizza shop.
I look forward to trying more of their menu in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Milhous
Steve the owner is a Great person and he has excellent ladies that work with him. Authentic delicious food and for the price the pizzas are unbeatable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vernie Patrick
I ate lunch at Tony's Pizzalicious two days ago. The food was ok, I left a tip and I paid with my debit card. The next day I looked at my bank online and saw a pending $512.94 tip. I called and asked to speak with owner or manager. The woman said she was manager. I explained and she said she was aware of the mistake and there were several that day. The ticket number was put in the tip amount. She said she eould fix it after lunch due to she had a large order they were working on now. I told her that if other items went thru my account and caused fees they would have to pay those so she needed to take care of it. She accused me of threatening her. I judt saud fix it. She waited then had a girl call later to say fixed but it was still pending at the end of the day. Will not go back!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Courtney Boulware
Today, I had the Meat Lovers Calzone and it was AMAZING!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quintin McFadden
I love this place. The food is yummy and worth the money. The owner and his family were so nice to me and I will definitely come back. Everything was homemade.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
M D
I stopped by & placed an order with the lady at the front counter & she relayed it to the old guy making the pizza who I assume is the owner. Owner says okay & then about a minute passes & he comes out & says he cannot make my pizza because he has a big order of 50 pizzas to make & he doesn’t have enough dough to make another pizza. He then hands me a menu & says to come back another day. See this is the thing though. If he’s working on a big 50 pizza order then why is your employee who took my order not aware of this? Why have you not locked your doors & put the closed sign up if you’re not serving customers for the next few hours? Why does your own employee seem confused that you’re canceling my order?
Funny thing is I went inside this place once before like a decade ago to pickup a Postmates order I was going to deliver & I got a similar “weird” vibe. See I waited about 30 mins for the Postmates customers order to be ready & I politely asked how much longer & an old dude yelled at me & told me he was just going to cancel the order & that I can leave. Before this when I first entered I also noticed how nice the waitress lady was to the lady before me & then how cold and disinterested she was with me. Now why did I go back to this place today after this experience? Well I saw on Facebook a few years ago someone said they had a new owner so I thought maybe they aren’t so weird & poor on customer service anymore & it’s the closest pizza spot to my house & I was craving pizza today. Welp turns out they are still “weird” & instead of being rude to your face they’ll politely tell you they don’t have enough pizza for you. Which is fine I prefer that over the rudeness & don’t want to eat food made by someone who doesn’t want to serve me. & iykyk what I mean by “weird” my brothers & sisters. I mean that “We” clearly are not welcome here 😂 I’m not buying it for a minute that the local pizzeria with 1 car in the parking lot is too busy to make a single large pizza 😂😂😂
Atmosphere: 1
Ben Bowens
Tony's pizza is easily the best in Columbia! I visited today and the experience was amazing... Classic Italian pizza that directly impacts counterterrorism and promotes high levels of patriotism! The food was fresh, quickly delivered, and the service was great! One bite made me want to salute the flag and do pushups. This business is a diamond in the rough...if you're looking for great pizza, definitely come here!
Will Marshall
I ordered two pizzas recently — the Greek Gyro Pizza and the Meat Lovers — and both were absolutely incredible! The Greek Gyro Pizza truly captured the essence of a traditional gyro, with all those bold, authentic flavors perfectly reimagined on a pizza. It’s not easy to pull off something so unique, but they nailed it. The Meat Lovers was just as impressive, packed with hearty toppings and cooked to perfection.
What really makes this place stand out is that it’s family-owned, built on tradition, and you can tell they genuinely care about the customers. On top of that, I had a great 20-minute conversation with the owner about how the restaurant began, his family’s history of running other spots in town, and even swapped stories of back home and unique pizza creations we’ve seen at the shore boardwalk. You can feel the tradition, passion, and genuine care here. Hands down, this place blow all other pizza places out of the water. I can’t recommend them enough! I have now decided to make myself a regular because even after just my first visit, I feel like family! ♥️♥️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emanuel Brown
Highly recommend this place if you love authentic Greek food! It’s so many great choices so I will give you my top 3 picks! 1.The meat lovers pizza 2. The spaghetti meat sauce with the homemade meatballs, so good and delicious! 3. Spaghetti Caruso made with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, pepperoni, Italian, sausage, and ham covered with meat sauce! Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maurice Brown
Highly recommend this place if you love authentic Greek food! It’s so many great choices so I will give you my top 3 picks!
1.The meat lovers pizza
2. The spaghetti meat sauce with the homemade meatballs, so good and delicious!
3. Spaghetti Caruso made with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, pepperoni, Italian, sausage, and ham covered with meat sauce!
Lived in the area for a while and had been wanting to try this place out. I ordered Carryout on a Friday afternoon and went through the drive thru. I got a medium pepperoni pizza. Truth is it just wasn’t that good. I won’t return
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
McKenzie Jackson
I finally tried this place after years of passing it. The food was stellar and the owner and his daughter provided excellent service. I will definitely be a returning customer!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jocelyn Y. Baker, Esq., MBA
Order the baked ziti through the drive thru and found a hair in my food. Called to report and was told she would “let them know”. Tony’s was my go to for comfort food before I left for law school but management changed. It used to be Italian but now it’s Greek. Ziti was good except for the hair but the garlic bread and salad were trash. Sadly I wont be ordering here again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Aaron Thomas
This place reminds me of the old-time pizzerias in New York state. Food was amazing, and is well worth a stop for dinner. They have specials on pizza and pasta that make it easy on the wallet. Some would say the food is almost better than Grecian Gardens!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza, Stromboli
Tiana Stirewalt
I have lived in the Columbia area for 7 years now. And in those 7 years I had passed by this place seceral times, but never thought to stop by here until tonight. On our hunt for delicious food the options took us here; I am so glad!
The owner, Stavros, is such a friendly and wonderful personality. He told me the name of the waitress who served us tonight, but her name slipped my mind. I just remember he told us that she has been there for 15 years. She was absolutely on point and so sweet!
Food: we ordered the Dimi’s Deluxe & a pepperoni and bacon pizza, spinach artichoke dip, and a side of garlic bread. The dough on the pizza was light and fluffy, delicious and filling. The spinach artichoke dip was really good, and it’s served with hot pita bread! Packing the leftovers got a little messy, as there were so many topping on the Dimi’s Deluxe pizza everything started falling off! A small price to pay for the value of the food we ate!
Price: you can easily get away with $10-20 per person, with our appetizer, extra side, & drinks, it was closer to $25 per person ($30 if you include the tip). Pricing was similar to other dine in restaurants, and you get a lot more food to bring home!
Service: the waitress also worked in the kitchen, so service wasn’t the fastest (but also wasn’t slow) while dining in, but she was so polite and patient as we looked over all of the choices and answered all of our questions. As we paid to leave, we had a nice conversation with the manager/owner? I’m not sure of his title, but he mentioned hearing good things about eating the leftover pizza for breakfast due to his sauce recipe. We tried it this morning & he was absolutely correct; the pizza was just as good the next day!
Atmosphere: good music & kind people. There weren’t many other people in the dining room with us, but everyone seemed kind and respectful. You can see into the kitchen area & see them making your food which was cool. It felt like a homey mom & pop pizza shop.
I look forward to trying more of their menu in the future!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve the owner is a Great person and he has excellent ladies that work with him. Authentic delicious food and for the price the pizzas are unbeatable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ate lunch at Tony's Pizzalicious two days ago. The food was ok, I left a tip and I paid with my debit card. The next day I looked at my bank online and saw a pending $512.94 tip. I called and asked to speak with owner or manager. The woman said she was manager. I explained and she said she was aware of the mistake and there were several that day. The ticket number was put in the tip amount. She said she eould fix it after lunch due to she had a large order they were working on now. I told her that if other items went thru my account and caused fees they would have to pay those so she needed to take care of it. She accused me of threatening her. I judt saud fix it. She waited then had a girl call later to say fixed but it was still pending at the end of the day. Will not go back!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Today, I had the Meat Lovers Calzone and it was AMAZING!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love this place. The food is yummy and worth the money. The owner and his family were so nice to me and I will definitely come back. Everything was homemade.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stopped by & placed an order with the lady at the front counter & she relayed it to the old guy making the pizza who I assume is the owner. Owner says okay & then about a minute passes & he comes out & says he cannot make my pizza because he has a big order of 50 pizzas to make & he doesn’t have enough dough to make another pizza. He then hands me a menu & says to come back another day. See this is the thing though. If he’s working on a big 50 pizza order then why is your employee who took my order not aware of this? Why have you not locked your doors & put the closed sign up if you’re not serving customers for the next few hours? Why does your own employee seem confused that you’re canceling my order?
Funny thing is I went inside this place once before like a decade ago to pickup a Postmates order I was going to deliver & I got a similar “weird” vibe. See I waited about 30 mins for the Postmates customers order to be ready & I politely asked how much longer & an old dude yelled at me & told me he was just going to cancel the order & that I can leave. Before this when I first entered I also noticed how nice the waitress lady was to the lady before me & then how cold and disinterested she was with me. Now why did I go back to this place today after this experience? Well I saw on Facebook a few years ago someone said they had a new owner so I thought maybe they aren’t so weird & poor on customer service anymore & it’s the closest pizza spot to my house & I was craving pizza today. Welp turns out they are still “weird” & instead of being rude to your face they’ll politely tell you they don’t have enough pizza for you. Which is fine I prefer that over the rudeness & don’t want to eat food made by someone who doesn’t want to serve me. & iykyk what I mean by “weird” my brothers & sisters. I mean that “We” clearly are not welcome here 😂 I’m not buying it for a minute that the local pizzeria with 1 car in the parking lot is too busy to make a single large pizza 😂😂😂
Atmosphere: 1
Tony's pizza is easily the best in Columbia! I visited today and the experience was amazing... Classic Italian pizza that directly impacts counterterrorism and promotes high levels of patriotism! The food was fresh, quickly delivered, and the service was great! One bite made me want to salute the flag and do pushups. This business is a diamond in the rough...if you're looking for great pizza, definitely come here!
I ordered two pizzas recently — the Greek Gyro Pizza and the Meat Lovers — and both were absolutely incredible! The Greek Gyro Pizza truly captured the essence of a traditional gyro, with all those bold, authentic flavors perfectly reimagined on a pizza. It’s not easy to pull off something so unique, but they nailed it. The Meat Lovers was just as impressive, packed with hearty toppings and cooked to perfection.
What really makes this place stand out is that it’s family-owned, built on tradition, and you can tell they genuinely care about the customers. On top of that, I had a great 20-minute conversation with the owner about how the restaurant began, his family’s history of running other spots in town, and even swapped stories of back home and unique pizza creations we’ve seen at the shore boardwalk. You can feel the tradition, passion, and genuine care here. Hands down, this place blow all other pizza places out of the water. I can’t recommend them enough! I have now decided to make myself a regular because even after just my first visit, I feel like family! ♥️♥️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommend this place if you love authentic Greek food! It’s so many great choices so I will give you my top 3 picks!
1.The meat lovers pizza
2. The spaghetti meat sauce with the homemade meatballs, so good and delicious!
3. Spaghetti Caruso made with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, pepperoni, Italian, sausage, and ham covered with meat sauce! Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommend this place if you love authentic Greek food! It’s so many great choices so I will give you my top 3 picks! 1.The meat lovers pizza 2. The spaghetti meat sauce with the homemade meatballs, so good and delicious! 3. Spaghetti Caruso made with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, pepperoni, Italian, sausage, and ham covered with meat sauce!
Restaurantji Recommends
Lived in the area for a while and had been wanting to try this place out. I ordered Carryout on a Friday afternoon and went through the drive thru. I got a medium pepperoni pizza. Truth is it just wasn’t that good. I won’t return
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
I finally tried this place after years of passing it. The food was stellar and the owner and his daughter provided excellent service. I will definitely be a returning customer!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Order the baked ziti through the drive thru and found a hair in my food. Called to report and was told she would “let them know”. Tony’s was my go to for comfort food before I left for law school but management changed. It used to be Italian but now it’s Greek. Ziti was good except for the hair but the garlic bread and salad were trash. Sadly I wont be ordering here again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
This place reminds me of the old-time pizzerias in New York state. Food was amazing, and is well worth a stop for dinner. They have specials on pizza and pasta that make it easy on the wallet. Some would say the food is almost better than Grecian Gardens!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza, Stromboli
I have lived in the Columbia area for 7 years now. And in those 7 years I had passed by this place seceral times, but never thought to stop by here until tonight. On our hunt for delicious food the options took us here; I am so glad!
The owner, Stavros, is such a friendly and wonderful personality. He told me the name of the waitress who served us tonight, but her name slipped my mind. I just remember he told us that she has been there for 15 years. She was absolutely on point and so sweet!
My family and i will definitely return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stromboli
Loading...