Was skeptical to try because of the lower rating. But I'm so glad we did!!!
Starting with an Arnold Palmer, absolutely delicious. It's sometimes difficult to find good tea or lemonade around here, so it's always a nice treat to have both in one drink, and they're both tasty.
By far, the best deluxe/supreme pizza I've ever had!! Sure, it was expensive ($25 for a large), but in my opinion, it was worth every penny. Perfect sauce/cheese/topping/crust ratio. A beautiful variety of peppers and meats like I've never seen. Every ingredient of the pizza (and the salad and calamari we also got) seemed 100% fresh. There was an amazing blend of seasoning on the crust, not too much like a lot of other restaurants, but just enough so it wasn't bland. The pizza was cooked to just the right temperature. The crust had a wonderful crispiness to it without being too crispy. It was the best balance of crispy outer crust and soft inner crust I've ever witnessed.
I also had their version of a Caesar salad, but no olives and a vinaigrette instead of Caesar dressing. When I tell you, this was the most incredible vinaigrette I've ever tasted. The perfect blend of oil and vinegar and herbs.
The calamari was pretty great, too. Plump rings and tentacles. They used a really nice basic batter on it, and it was, of course, fried to perfection. The marinara dipping sauce was pretty good, nothing crazy but pleasant .
The restaurant was surprisingly slow for a Friday night around dinner time, but they did have a comedy show later that I imagine some people were planning on attending then. Service was great though. Everyone from the hostess to server to bus boys were very hospitable. Our server was very attentive and really took excellent care of us.
I'll probably be going back at least once a month from now on!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron Bensen
Called in an order of pizza and salad. They gave me ranch instead of vinagrette. The box wasn't even warm when I picked it up. Got to the house opened it up and it was barely cooked. I have never not eaten a pizza until now. A bad pizza is usually still edible. When I called they said my money couldn't be refunded but they could put me on a list for a free pizza. Bro the one I just got was raw so I'm good there.
Food: 1
Michael Litten
Can't rate the food because I didn't get to eat. Waited at the front for over five minutes with out even being acknowledged by the server or the bartender. Finally got fed up and left and then someone else tried to get us to come back in and sit down. I don't think so. We went right over the tracks to Merrells and got seated and ordered and greater in less than 2 minutes. Do yourself a favor and don't bother getting disrespected at Amici and just co to Merrells...
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Ben Ivins
Pitiful experience. Food was good but overpriced. Dirty men’s bathroom. No hand soap in the dispenser. Some of the silverware was very dirty. Food took over 1 hour to come out. Waitress look overwhelmed and inexperienced. The restaurant was not busy so I was surprised by all the negatives. I did like the calzone, but it cost too much and took too long to come out. This is downtown Easley, not Downtown Manhattan…
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Bob Schintziys
Went here for a family friends B-day celebration and waited well over an hour to get our food. Took them at least 15-20 min just to come over to take our order. After getting the food, waitress would not even come by very often to check on us to see if we needed refills on drinks. Had to do without anything to drink with the rest of our food. Lousy service! The one and only time we ever went there and the very last one too!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Terry Brown
My date and I ordered spaghetti/marinara sauce sm. House salad and ice tea. The salad was good the spaghetti was not even room temperature we had to send it back to heat it.i dont like sending things back because i don't know what they do to it if it makes them mad. But it wasn't warm enough to eat And it came back warm but it was by means freshly prepared. And after I asked for the bread that was supposed to come with it. They brought two pieces the size of a deck of cards. The bill was $42.53. we were not impressed at all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
LockedN Loaded
Large pizza, tender appetizer, fries and 3 drinks was $70. Will not be returning to this spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Tasha Carpenter
Man, I do love the food but, the service is always slow and terrible. Just too many guest and not enough wait staff. It's so frustrating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Laura C
I have gone there three times. The first time the pizza was pretty good. The second time it wasn't very good at all. The third time the service was awful. I placed my order for mushroom pizza and the waitress came back 25 minutes later to let me know they were out of mushrooms. I walked out. What a lousy way to treat customers. (Also 3.5 for a soda or tea is overpriced)
Terence Livingston
Got turned away. Couldn’t handle anymore guests. Plenty of places to sit.
It took about 45 minutes for the food. And waited about 1 hour 45 minutes for ranch and refills on our drink. Others have waited to order their food for over an hour. I don't recommend this place. It's not worth the wait
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Nick Barton
Food is good but the service is absolutely awful! Ordered the buffalo chicken pizza, asked for ranch. When the pizza came out there was no ranch so we asked again. No one ever came back to our table until it was time for the check. Never refilled our tea, never even checked on us. The food is good here but get it to go.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Brook Borho
Noah, Kyle and Justin are the greatest team! So personable and accommodating!! We enjoy the atmosphere and the food at Amici. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joey Woodall
Came in for lunch with the guys from work. It was pleasantly peaceful for Easley. It's one of the best burgers I've had lately and was very comparable in price to most other places I've tried in town the past few months working down there. I'll definitely be back and hopefully it'll be just as good as my first trip. Thank yall for a good meal and great service.
Was skeptical to try because of the lower rating. But I'm so glad we did!!!
Starting with an Arnold Palmer, absolutely delicious. It's sometimes difficult to find good tea or lemonade around here, so it's always a nice treat to have both in one drink, and they're both tasty.
By far, the best deluxe/supreme pizza I've ever had!! Sure, it was expensive ($25 for a large), but in my opinion, it was worth every penny. Perfect sauce/cheese/topping/crust ratio. A beautiful variety of peppers and meats like I've never seen. Every ingredient of the pizza (and the salad and calamari we also got) seemed 100% fresh. There was an amazing blend of seasoning on the crust, not too much like a lot of other restaurants, but just enough so it wasn't bland. The pizza was cooked to just the right temperature. The crust had a wonderful crispiness to it without being too crispy. It was the best balance of crispy outer crust and soft inner crust I've ever witnessed.
I also had their version of a Caesar salad, but no olives and a vinaigrette instead of Caesar dressing. When I tell you, this was the most incredible vinaigrette I've ever tasted. The perfect blend of oil and vinegar and herbs.
The calamari was pretty great, too. Plump rings and tentacles. They used a really nice basic batter on it, and it was, of course, fried to perfection. The marinara dipping sauce was pretty good, nothing crazy but pleasant .
The restaurant was surprisingly slow for a Friday night around dinner time, but they did have a comedy show later that I imagine some people were planning on attending then. Service was great though. Everyone from the hostess to server to bus boys were very hospitable. Our server was very attentive and really took excellent care of us.
I'll probably be going back at least once a month from now on!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Called in an order of pizza and salad.
They gave me ranch instead of vinagrette. The box wasn't even warm when I picked it up. Got to the house opened it up and it was barely cooked. I have never not eaten a pizza until now. A bad pizza is usually still edible. When I called they said my money couldn't be refunded but they could put me on a list for a free pizza. Bro the one I just got was raw so I'm good there.
Food: 1
Can't rate the food because I didn't get to eat. Waited at the front for over five minutes with out even being acknowledged by the server or the bartender. Finally got fed up and left and then someone else tried to get us to come back in and sit down. I don't think so. We went right over the tracks to Merrells and got seated and ordered and greater in less than 2 minutes. Do yourself a favor and don't bother getting disrespected at Amici and just co to Merrells...
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Pitiful experience. Food was good but overpriced. Dirty men’s bathroom. No hand soap in the dispenser. Some of the silverware was very dirty. Food took over 1 hour to come out. Waitress look overwhelmed and inexperienced. The restaurant was not busy so I was surprised by all the negatives. I did like the calzone, but it cost too much and took too long to come out. This is downtown Easley, not Downtown Manhattan…
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Went here for a family friends B-day celebration and waited well over an hour to get our food. Took them at least 15-20 min just to come over to take our order. After getting the food, waitress would not even come by very often to check on us to see if we needed refills on drinks. Had to do without anything to drink with the rest of our food. Lousy service! The one and only time we ever went there and the very last one too!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
My date and I ordered spaghetti/marinara sauce sm. House salad and ice tea. The salad was good the spaghetti was not even room temperature we had to send it back to heat it.i dont like sending things back because i don't know what they do to it if it makes them mad. But it wasn't warm enough to eat And it came back warm but it was by means freshly prepared. And after I asked for the bread that was supposed to come with it. They brought two pieces the size of a deck of cards. The bill was $42.53. we were not impressed at all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Large pizza, tender appetizer, fries and 3 drinks was $70. Will not be returning to this spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Man, I do love the food but, the service is always slow and terrible. Just too many guest and not enough wait staff. It's so frustrating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
I have gone there three times. The first time the pizza was pretty good. The second time it wasn't very good at all. The third time the service was awful. I placed my order for mushroom pizza and the waitress came back 25 minutes later to let me know they were out of mushrooms. I walked out. What a lousy way to treat customers. (Also 3.5 for a soda or tea is overpriced)
Got turned away. Couldn’t handle anymore guests. Plenty of places to sit.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food but let me be blunt. The Service sucks
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Pepperoni Pizza
It took about 45 minutes for the food. And waited about 1 hour 45 minutes for ranch and refills on our drink. Others have waited to order their food for over an hour. I don't recommend this place. It's not worth the wait
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Food is good but the service is absolutely awful! Ordered the buffalo chicken pizza, asked for ranch. When the pizza came out there was no ranch so we asked again. No one ever came back to our table until it was time for the check. Never refilled our tea, never even checked on us. The food is good here but get it to go.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Noah, Kyle and Justin are the greatest team! So personable and accommodating!! We enjoy the atmosphere and the food at Amici. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came in for lunch with the guys from work. It was pleasantly peaceful for Easley. It's one of the best burgers I've had lately and was very comparable in price to most other places I've tried in town the past few months working down there. I'll definitely be back and hopefully it'll be just as good as my first trip. Thank yall for a good meal and great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...