Peace of Pie on Hartwell
17016 SC-11, Fair Play
(864) 972-1955
Customers' Favorites
Wings Double Baked by the Lake
Chocolate Covered Cherry Pizza
Double Baked by the Lake Wings
Free Spirited Supreme Pizza
Our Bruschetta Appetizer
Carolina Philly Calzone
Pimento Jalapeno Burger
Jalapeno Popper Pizza
Chocolate Chip Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Menu
Photos
+11 photos
+10 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Stopped by Peace of Pie on Hartwell before heading to the waterfalls, and had one of the best Strombolis I've ever tasted. Nothing but great things to say—huge portions, great prices, and friendly staff. The atmosphere was welcoming, filled with locals and visitors, with plenty of seating inside and out. The taproom offered many options. If you're in the area, definitely stop by—you won’t be disappointed!
We’ve always loved this pizza place, but unfortunately, our most recent experience was really disappointing. We placed a simple order for our 5-year-old daughter, and after waiting for over an hour, we had to ask where our pizza was. Turns out, they completely forgot about our order. While they did finally get it sorted, it was frustrating to have to wait so long, especially when we had a hungry kid waiting. We’ve had great experiences here in the past, but this visit was...
We went during shift change so it was kinda like we were forgot about.
Parking: Beer was 5 for Michelob on tap. We got 2 personal, Alfredo, and chicken bacon ranch. Very good.
Parking: Beer was 5 for Michelob on tap. We got 2 personal, Alfredo, and chicken bacon ranch. Very good.
You May Also Like
Taco’n Madre Grill - 17022 SC-11
![]()
Mexican, New Mexican Cuisine, Food Trucks
The Spotted Pig BBQ - 15491 SC-11
![]()
Barbecue, Barbeque, American, Vegetarian
The Overlook at Chickasaw Point - 503 S Hogan Dr
![]()
Golf, Venues & Event Spaces, Cocktail Bar, Burgers