Incredible Edibles Bakery, Pawleys Island, SC

We had a great experience booking Incredible Edibles for our wedding cake! It looked and tasted amazing, couldn’t have asked for a better vendor!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very cute tea brunch.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a wonderful experience with Incredible Edibles Bakery for our wedding cake. From the first tasting to the seamless delivery on our wedding day, Nancy and her staff were amazing to work with. The flavors were absolutely incredible and the design was beautiful. It was the perfect dessert for our special day. We highly recommend Incredible Edibles for all your cake needs, every guest loved the cake!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best cake ever. Lived up to the hype

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was terrible. Brownie with icing has zero flavor, and was very oily. Lemon bar was awful, it had so much citric acid that it had the worst aftertaste, like i had vomited.. was cute in there tho :3

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

We had a great experience ordering a birthday cake for my mom’s birthday. The staff were nice and warm and the cake was out of this world! We got a white cake with buttercream and raspberry jam. The buttercream isn’t too sweet, it’s just perfect!

I would not suggest this store. I had a bad experience and was treated very poorly by the owner when I walked into the store to place an order. I order a small cake with very little help from the establishment. A little over a month before the event, I changed the order to cup cakes. No helpful suggestions. When I picked them up they were dark tan and looked over cooked. I HAD THREE PEOPLE TASTE THEM AND IT WAS A GROUP VOTE .... THEY WERE DRY, OVER BAKED AND NOT SERVABLE! We had to purchase cupcakes from Publics last minute. 18 unedible cupcakes with a dab of icing for $50.00, what a waste!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

If I lived closer I'd be 300pds in a month. Never sampled the wedding cake but everything else is on the money. Reminds me of days gone past on Arthur Ave ?

We went at the end of the day so the selection was sparse. We shared an eclaire and took home the crumb cake square, a lemon bar, and lemon creamcheese muffin.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Amazing pastries, service, and atmosphere. We will definitely be visiting again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Macaron, Cupcake, Cruffin

Highly recommend Incredible Edibles! I ordered two 5'inch birthday cakes, lemon and chocolate for 2 special men. The pastry chief and I discussed the vision and oh boy did they create 2 spectacular cakes! Not only were they beautiful, they were absolutely delicious. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

So we just wanted a cup of coffee with a baked good. We saw this place and were excited to try it! The service was underwhelming, definitely didn't get a very warm greeting. I normally wouldn't care because I'm there for confections and coffee, not human interactions. HOWEVER...they microwaved my coffee. I repeat.. they microwaved my coffee... then charged me for it! Who does that? I was in so much disbelief.. baffled really. Even McDonalds will make you a fresh pot. The coffee tasted like it would have been good and the eclair wasn't bad. I feel disrespected. For anyone with more patience than me, hopefully you go on a good day when the coffee is rolling out continously.. but as for me I couldn't even finish my coffee. They had organic options which was great. But provide a spoon or something to scoop out the honey. It's just the little things that can make a break a business. This business has the potential for greatness, but the little things will keep me away... especially microwaving cold coffee to serve to me. "Freshly brewed" they say.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Cake was exactly as ordered and tasted great.

Nancy was so helpful in designing and making our cupcakes for a “baby in bloom” shower! Picked them up Tuesday. They were wrapped well for travel. Kept them refrigerated until event day Saturday and they were perfect!! Everyone commented how beautiful they were and tasted like a wedding cake!! Highly recommend.

Adorable and DELICIOUS cake! Staff was friendly and very accommodating