Great American Cookies

1057 Broad St, Sumter
(803) 773-4785

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shannon A

I had a last minute order for my husband and a friends promotion from E4 to E5. The lady here NAILED IT!! She had it done within a couple hours and not only did it taste good but it looked amazing!! She was so kind and super accommodating!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookie Cake by the Slice

Lex Oliver

We did the buy 5 get one free on regular cookies (M&m and orig Chocolate chip) and a regular blue raspberry jolly rancher drink, the cookies were really soft and fresh and the drink was made nicely. The service was okay, we had to wait on the server to finish talking with a friend that had come by which wasn’t great at all, once we were finally acknowledged we still had to wait as there was somebody sitting down waiting on an order and only one worker, we eventually placed our order and it was a smooth transaction from then.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Katie Rhodes

I could not be more grateful for this business! I was in a bind and needed something for my sister's birthday ASAP! and they went out of their way to make sure I got what I needed! Meka came in ON HER DAY OFF to get me this cookie cake done and ready in the same day! and not to mention she did more than an amazing job! it looked exactly like the picture and i am so excited to give it to my sister for her 40th birthday!! the whole team was amazing and I could not be happier! THANK YOU GUYS SO MUCH I LOVE YOU!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Courtney Johnson

Probably the most disappointing excuse for pretzels… no salt at all on them, kinda cold and nasty chewy almost if the yeast hadn’t properly bloomed, just threw them in the trash. Then an extra 45 cent charge for “raise in cost” wanted a nice little treat and can’t even enjoy it and have to pay extra…

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Kimberly Coughtry

Ordered a Cookie Cake. Prompt, courteous service when I arrived. The cake was ready and tasted amazing! Would definitely return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Maggie Bell

Stood there waiting for our order to be taken. Man standing there cleaning acting like he didn’t even see us. Walked by us twice and went to the back. Gave him the benefit of the doubt and was thinking maybe he wasn’t the one doing orders because someone else was in the back. Well finally he comes and puts his hands on the counter and kinda leans forward and says can I get you something…. Yeah.. not anymore. I had to walk away.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Thomas Pearson

Everything was great ? keep on doing what y'all do.....~>>>

West McAdams

Meka is amazing. She went out of her way to correct a mistake. Thank you

Morgan Burciaga

The double doozies are the best! :)

Halleluyah DeJesus

My cookies were great. The lady was very nice and attentive.

speedy9694

I love the cookies from this place, but the people were not the most patient with me and my two friends. Considering it was one of the few times I visited, I will probably end up coming again. Maybe not the one at the sumter mall though.

Halle DeJesus

My cookies were great. The lady was very nice and attentive.

Adelaida Navarro

They did an amazing job on the Father’s Day cake my fiancé and I placed for his dad if I could post a picture or knew how I would ?

Alexie Evans

We were waiting to see what we want, she was there and then mins later puts a sign up for her to be gone for 30mins. She was gone longer then that, came back with an attitude and her food. I don’t support rude businesses and will be sharing this to others.

Qua Brown

Three cookies use to be $5.97 now they are $6.97 and then it's a Commodity charge?I will be not going there again.

Loading...